Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we heading into a major recession?

430 replies

bodychanges · 12/02/2025 13:16

Things are already tough in my industry - I’m a contractor and this past year is my worst in over two decades - but should I be expecting things to get worse not better?

and I sound stupid, but what are the main economic indicators?

OP posts:
wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:09

But really it goes back to 2008 and the poor wage growth we’ve suffered since then

This, people talk about cycles but we never recovered from 08. Low interest rates boosted assets & there wasn't any investment in services.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:10
  • Yes we have a predictable Labour shit show. They have no idea whatsoever how to create growth.*

Tories did a great job!

neverthelastone · 12/02/2025 15:10

TinklySnail · 12/02/2025 14:59

Poor wage growth partly started with freedom of movement.
A warehouse worker on £10 an hour suddenly found themselves competing with EU workers who would willingly work for less.
I don’t have any issues with EU workers as they are a fab bunch but it did impact British citizens.

Not true - migration during that period was a net positive (and minimum wage actually raised wage growth). The biggest factors by far in keeping wages low were monetary policy and globalisation of East Asian production of consumer goods.

What strangled wages after 2001 was super-low interest rates/ZIRP, massive credit easing and QE, that encouraged asset price inflation rather than wage inflation. At the same time, the importing of consumer goods from Asia was a massive downwards pressure on wage growth here. This was a deliberate choice post-2001 across several central banks (there are interviews with Alan Greenspan and Eddie George where they discuss doing this deliberately to avoid a recession after 9/11).

These factors started to unwind post-2008 after the financial crash, but Tory policies after 2010 then deliberately targeted wage inflation to keep it low, whilst allowing asset price inflation to run rampant.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:10

Fire up the economy and cut the benefits bill in half by making healthy people work for longer.

You have completely forgot the demographic changes. We don't have enough young people.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:12

The whole economy is still blighted by having allowed the housing bubble to inflate well beyond sustainable fundamentals — ever since 2001, but particularly after 2010. There was a chance to allow it to continue to deflate after the financial crash; but instead the Coalition/Tory governments not only restarted the housing boom and pumped cash into keeping house prices high, but inflated them even further.

Yes and people thought this was a good thing 🤦🏻‍♀️

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:14

Poor wage growth partly started with freedom of movement.

it started under Thatcher but QE fucked it.

HauntedBungalow · 12/02/2025 15:15

Ukraine conflict will be settled soon so hopefully fuel prices will stabilise after that.

EU negotiations should get us picked up a bit too.

Going to be a bumpy 12 months though. Plenty of scope for farridge and his rosy-cheeked millionaire tractor chums to cause trouble in.

TheNuthatch · 12/02/2025 15:16

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:10

  • Yes we have a predictable Labour shit show. They have no idea whatsoever how to create growth.*

Tories did a great job!

Well our business was doing OK until Labour came in. Thats a fact. We cannot hire, invest or grow in this climate. We are currently seeing the private sector shrinking and huge problems in the jobs market as a direct result of decisions taken by Labour. The economy may not have been going great guns before, but it sure was better than it is now.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:18

The economy may not have been going great guns before, but it sure was better than it is now.

If you think that i'm not sure what to say. The Tories created most of this mess.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:19

And again it's a demographic issue, we have more over 65s than under 15s. Why did the Tories not actually get tough on immigration?

HauntedBungalow · 12/02/2025 15:20

Well our business was doing OK until Labour came in.

What business was that then? Fake covid tracking? Arms dealing? Gold?

Tories bust the economy and put halts on future recovery by brexiting us.

TinklySnail · 12/02/2025 15:22

neverthelastone · 12/02/2025 15:10

Not true - migration during that period was a net positive (and minimum wage actually raised wage growth). The biggest factors by far in keeping wages low were monetary policy and globalisation of East Asian production of consumer goods.

What strangled wages after 2001 was super-low interest rates/ZIRP, massive credit easing and QE, that encouraged asset price inflation rather than wage inflation. At the same time, the importing of consumer goods from Asia was a massive downwards pressure on wage growth here. This was a deliberate choice post-2001 across several central banks (there are interviews with Alan Greenspan and Eddie George where they discuss doing this deliberately to avoid a recession after 9/11).

These factors started to unwind post-2008 after the financial crash, but Tory policies after 2010 then deliberately targeted wage inflation to keep it low, whilst allowing asset price inflation to run rampant.

You may be correct but I do know that freedom of movement impacted British warehouse workers.
I worked in the recruitment sector and saw first hand the impact it had.

neverthelastone · 12/02/2025 15:24

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:10

Fire up the economy and cut the benefits bill in half by making healthy people work for longer.

You have completely forgot the demographic changes. We don't have enough young people.

Exactly.

The demographics of this country are weighted disproportionately towards a bigger (retired) older generation, who are taking a disproportionate share of the state budget due to over-generous pensions, public service costs (healthcare, social care, transport etc.), and who also own the majority of housing assets (including second homes and buy to lets).

There simply aren’t enough younger workers to generate enough money to maintain all these three things. That’s why previous governments turned to migration (which was actually a sensible choice when it was EU migration, as the benefits were worth more to us then the costs, and young EU workers were high-skilled and also went back to their home countries afterwards - something that Brexiteers never understood).

How do we support a disproportionate demographic of older people with fewer workers in the pyramid underneath, while trying to generate sensible economic growth?

Some suggestions:

  1. rejoin the EU. Incentivise EU migration and investment whilst disincentivising migration from outside the EU;

  2. heavy taxes on buy to let and landlords;

  3. abandon the triple lock and force older generations to release some of their assets to pay for care/healthcare;

  4. a short, sharp house price crash (otherwise we’ll only get a long, strangling one), which enables a readjustment of wages to asset prices as quickly as possible;

  5. public borrowing specifically to incentivise green investment, high-tech industry, science R&D and education (especially higher education). Replace tuition fees with a HEFCE-style public grant for universities.

That’s a start. Anyone else want to join in?

TheNuthatch · 12/02/2025 15:24

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:18

The economy may not have been going great guns before, but it sure was better than it is now.

If you think that i'm not sure what to say. The Tories created most of this mess.

Find me an economist who thinks the economy has improved under Labour. Happy to wait.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:25

@TheNuthatch I never claimed it had improved. I just said Tories didn't do a good job.

Treeper22 · 12/02/2025 15:26

LadyPoison · 12/02/2025 15:05

That is a really nasty post even by Mumsnet standards.

There are many small businesses like mine that are struggling and on the brink of survival. It's tough being a sole trader. We have no safety net. If I can't afford to buy gold then I go under. It's as simple as that! In a poor economy discretionary spending is the first thing to be cut back on and that hurts me badly.

I guess you are sitting pretty with a good job and a pension. Good for you.

My intenion was not to be nasty and i actually have sympathy for your situation.

My post was intended to demonstrate that comments like 'I might as well go on benefits' reinforce prejudice and the belief that it is a lifestyle choice and an easy life. It was an unnecessary comment based in fallacy and discrimination.

And no, I am in the situation I described. I am disabled and reliant on an increasingly hostile government, a landlord who could chuck me out at any time and keeps me in damp cold, unhealthy conditions and an NHS that doesn't have the funding to treat me. So personally, I find your comment rather more nasty than my fact based rebuke.

Moonlightstars · 12/02/2025 15:26

Well which ever dumb fucks voted for, and pushed for Brexit, told us we would have to put up with some pain. But it's apparently worth it for all the wonderful freedoms we have.
Farage should be publicly humiliated but instead for some reason people can't see through him and what he, and his ilk, have done to us.
This is made us much more vulnerable to the impacts of rising fuel costs as a result of Ukraine. However if we had properly invested in green energy decades before we wouldn't be in this mess but of course idiots like Farage actually fight against this. The reason being because they and their friends make a significant amount of money as the rest of us being poorer.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:27

The tories just kicked the can down the road & we've now run out of road...

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:29

Well which ever dumb fucks voted for and pushed for Brexit told us we would have to put up with some pain but it's worth it for all the wonderful freedoms we have.

the tragic thing is Reform are getting more popular.

neverthelastone · 12/02/2025 15:38

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:27

The tories just kicked the can down the road & we've now run out of road...

Yes - essentially our economy has become progressively ever more biased towards assets/capital at the expense of incomes/labour for the last twenty years.

Money that could have been invested productively in our manufacturing base, in improving our infrastructure, skills and education, housing stock, hospitals and living standards, instead all went into puffing up the prices of the exact same houses by five times their value, and speculating in financial products.

That’s basically what happened; and now we have: not enough workers, low productivity, old infrastructure, a low-skill population, crumbling healthcare — but houses five times the price and very rich financial speculators.

Those responsible for Brexit aren’t going to tell you this, because they own assets and are financial speculators.

Dorisbonson · 12/02/2025 15:40

Of course the UK is going to go into recession.

People's disposable incomes are in the toilet due to tax rises, inflation, interest rates and high energy costs. Several of these issues are created by our politicians.

The government decided to scare all the investors (millionaires) to move overseas and stop investing in the UK. Large numbers of high earners who pay the most amounts of tax are emigrating.

They have damaged our universities and attacked our schools, want to change tax policy to reduce innovation and have already taxed jobs.

Politicians say they want to make the UK more competitive with lots of AI and then create green energy policies which Google and other AI companies complain about because energy costs in the UK are the highest in the developed world.

It's only going one way - downhill.

It's inevitable Reform win, Labour are even more clueless than the last lot who were useless.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:43

@neverthelastone and the unbelievable thing is so many thought the fact their house had doubled in value was a good thing.

bigvig · 12/02/2025 15:44

we're already in one - the longest period of wage stagnation and reduction since WWII - at least.

wipeywipe · 12/02/2025 15:44

It's inevitable Reform win, Labour are even more clueless than the last lot who were useless.

@Dorisbonson how will reform fix it? 😆

TheNuthatch · 12/02/2025 15:45

HauntedBungalow · 12/02/2025 15:20

Well our business was doing OK until Labour came in.

What business was that then? Fake covid tracking? Arms dealing? Gold?

Tories bust the economy and put halts on future recovery by brexiting us.

Yes you got me, I'm an arms dealer.
Shame Jeremy Corbyn didn't support remain isn't it.