Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHMS ON MN

327 replies

UBIA · 23/09/2024 15:38

This is supposedly a site for mums - all types of mums.

On such a website, why is there so much hate and vitriol against mums who choose to SAH for a while?

The usual excuse for the storm of reactions is about financial vulnerability. Ok, I get that. But what if they're not financially vulnerable? How would you know? Bring a SAHM might have made you financially vulnerable - but you can't extrapolate that onto everyone else.

Why do people give anecdotes about some friend or their mother who was bored / insane / husband had an affair etc? Why? This is like saying "My friend had a job but she got depressed." So what? Also, if men are going to cheat, that's what they'll do anyway. Anyone can cheat in any type of marriage.

Why do people assume SAHMs are there for housework purposes? That depends on where / how they live and if they have cleaners, just like anyone else.

Why di people tell SAHMs their marriages are not 'equal?' Equality is about mutual respect. It has nothing to do with what job you do or money.

Frequently, people will say things like," Well, after my divorce the fact I was working meant I wasn't screwed." Ok, this is good obviously, but also, that's just you. How do you know the financial circumstances of anyone else - working or not? And why do you assume people haven't factored this sort of thing in?

Dime SAHMs will be screwed after divorce, sure. But others will not be. It depends on so many factors. Just like it does for anyone who works - it's all relative and completely circumstantial.

It is very odd that in a site for mums, the only mums that seem acceptable are the ones who don't SAH! MN is not like real life at all in this respect, it's very extreme (as I read it) because I don't know anyone in real life who makes assumptions about SAHMs or who would even care about this for 3 seconds. AIBU to think MN should be more open-minded and just live and let live without all the crazy assumptions.

OP posts:
calabria5 · 18/11/2024 14:17

Life is quite long @PaganPollyanna (if we're lucky) and there are many ways to contribute and gain fulfilment. Maybe you're quite young, I don't know, but perspectives shift through life's phases. What I do know is that women are always many things, over and above what jobs they may or may not have; for however long (or not). Life is far more multifaceted than that.

The only women who 'let the side down' are the sanctimonious twits who make statements like 'SAHMs are letting the side down..,, blah blah" or "WOHMs are missing out in their children ..., blah blah blah." Both statements equally stupid.

faroutnow · 18/11/2024 18:06

calabria5 · 18/11/2024 14:17

Life is quite long @PaganPollyanna (if we're lucky) and there are many ways to contribute and gain fulfilment. Maybe you're quite young, I don't know, but perspectives shift through life's phases. What I do know is that women are always many things, over and above what jobs they may or may not have; for however long (or not). Life is far more multifaceted than that.

The only women who 'let the side down' are the sanctimonious twits who make statements like 'SAHMs are letting the side down..,, blah blah" or "WOHMs are missing out in their children ..., blah blah blah." Both statements equally stupid.

👏

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread