Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Valentina Petrillo shouldn't be allowed to compete in the women's race

162 replies

AhBiscuits · 07/09/2024 15:19

Valentina Petrillo only started transitioning 5 years ago and previously competed as a man. How can that be fair? I appreciate that she did not make the final, but she's taken the place of a woman who has worked her arse off, but couldn't surpass Valentina's natural advantage.

Valentina Petrillo shouldn't be allowed to compete in the women's race
Valentina Petrillo shouldn't be allowed to compete in the women's race
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Delphinium20 · 07/09/2024 18:19

He's a cheating man taking advantage of this ridiculous zeitgeist of gendered souls. I can't wait for the Galileos of our time (aka JKRowling, Martina Navratilova, etc.) to finally get the credit deserved for saying, "uh, no. This is nuts."

Scammersarescum · 07/09/2024 18:21

Errors · 07/09/2024 18:09

Fuck the IOC

All women who support women's sport need a t shirt with this on.

Hairyesterdaygonetoday · 07/09/2024 18:23

Valentina Petrillo shouldn't be allowed to compete in the women's race
Of course he shouldn’t. He’s cheating, and having the time of his life kicking women’s sports into the ground.

Male humans are faster and stronger than females. See http://boysvswomen.com for the statistics showing how easily schoolboys beat elite female athletes.

The big question future generations will ask is why the hell sports governing bodies, and indeed governments, suddenly started saying that a man’s a woman if he says he is.

If boys are faster than elite female athletes, should males compete in female athletics?

See how the best high school boys stack up against the best female Olympians and World Record holders in Track & Field and Swimming.

http://boysvswomen.com

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 18:29

Things is they don't allow males to compete on the female catagory in AB sport.

They have female and male/open categories.

So why is it allowed in para sport.

Is it because they think those with disabilities should be "more inclusive" or something because they expect inclusivity and equality?

Para sport is just as tough and competitive as AB sport. It should be treated as such.

mybraindoesntwork · 07/09/2024 18:31

Of course it's not fair, and no he shouldn't be swinging his little d**k around a race track alongside women. Makes me sick.

ObelixtheGaul · 07/09/2024 19:10

ErrolTheDragon · 07/09/2024 15:48

What on earth do you think needs 'thinking about'?

I mean they haven't thought about it at all. If they had, that athlete wouldn't have been there. So yes, they need to think about it. Properly. If they want to be inclusive to trans athletes, they need to put thought into how they do that, rather than just dumping them into women's events.

Nanny0gg · 07/09/2024 19:15

AhBiscuits · 07/09/2024 15:19

Valentina Petrillo only started transitioning 5 years ago and previously competed as a man. How can that be fair? I appreciate that she did not make the final, but she's taken the place of a woman who has worked her arse off, but couldn't surpass Valentina's natural advantage.

HE'S taken the place

HE is a bloke

lifeturnsonadime · 07/09/2024 19:19

ObelixtheGaul · 07/09/2024 19:10

I mean they haven't thought about it at all. If they had, that athlete wouldn't have been there. So yes, they need to think about it. Properly. If they want to be inclusive to trans athletes, they need to put thought into how they do that, rather than just dumping them into women's events.

Easy an open category and a female only would do the trick!

UtterlyOtterly · 07/09/2024 19:26

Call me old fashioned , but isn't that an unusually large penis for a woman?

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 19:32

Easy an open category and a female only would do the trick!

That's pretty much the norm for nearly every NGB in AB sport.

I can't understand why para sport is t the same?

lifeturnsonadime · 07/09/2024 19:35

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 19:32

Easy an open category and a female only would do the trick!

That's pretty much the norm for nearly every NGB in AB sport.

I can't understand why para sport is t the same?

What do your abbreviations mean?
We have plenty of men who claim to be women across most sports & it is a massive issue. This is not limited to para sport at all.

WheresMySupportCat · 07/09/2024 19:38

viques · 07/09/2024 17:33

It’s not the IOC , it’s individual countries sports bodies who decide in the Paralympics, and as far as the Italian sports bodies are concerned if you say you are a woman you are a woman.

Even if your shorts call you out as a liar.

Well- that's not what the Italian sports bodies said when Imane Khelif was busily breaking the nose of Angela Carini.

The whole thing is rotten rotten to the core.

No man should be in womens sports, refuges, safe spaces, prisons, hospitals.

Just fuck right off with your male pattern entitlement.

(ETA- not you, viques! Just in case it was not clear. I'm agreeing with you).

WickedSerious · 07/09/2024 19:38

Helleofabore · 07/09/2024 16:31

Don’t forget though, apparently there are new discoveries that have turned the world on its head. Apparently, a group of male people should be made happy and female people should shut the fuck up.

'Science has moved on',or so we're told.

It's a shame reality can't keep up with it.

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 19:39

NGB - national governing body

AB - able bodied.

The international bodies mostly also have the same transgender policies where only females born female sex can compete as females and the rest compete male/open.

I have to admit I assumed it was the same in para sport. And I'm embarrassed I didn't realise as my ds is a para swimmer.

I want to see if WPS (world para swimming) have the same male/open and female as AB. But part of me is scared to look!

stripybobblehat · 07/09/2024 19:40

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 18:12

I realise that stripy. My comment with in regards to in AB athletics you can't run as a woman if you are a transwoman.

So how come in para athletics you can?

My point being it isn't a disability so why the difference in Ab and para?

Believe me I understand para sport extremely well - my ds is a para swimmer!

Ah right sorry I missunderstood. As you were :)

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 19:41

We have plenty of men who claim to be women across most sports & it is a massive issue. This is not limited to para sport at all.

Yes they claim.

But they can't compete when it comes to competition under the NGB license.

That's why Lia Thomas can't race as a woman in swimming. A local unlicensed club gala may allow it. Anything licensed is male/open and female. It's the same for swimming in the UK and also international swimming.

Most sports bodied nationally have adopted this as most international sports bodies have the same rules. (I know boxing doesn't).

WelshMoth · 07/09/2024 19:46

He is a cheating bastard.
Second rate male athlete in his field and now taking the competing space of another woman who has grafted her ass off to get there.
The IOC must really hate women.

itsgettingweird · 07/09/2024 19:48

It'll be the IPC. International para committee.

Although I'm not sure it's them as I'm not sure every sport allows this.

It may be IPA - international para athletics.

Although something tells me it's W - world now 😵‍💫

ThePure · 07/09/2024 19:52

I really feel as though that photo shows this is beyond cheating and into the realms of gaslighting and involving the whole world in their sexual fetish

Other styles of shorts are available.
If you were uncomfortable in your male body, ie gender dysphoric would you not make more efforts at passing??

This person looks like Grayson Perry decided to have a go at running.

WheresMySupportCat · 07/09/2024 19:54

Petrillo stole a place at the Olympics from a worthy woman.

Laurel Hubbard (the situation that peaked me) stole a place from an 18 year old woman from Nauru. A young woman from a teeny tiny country that had not had an Olympic athlete for 20 years. And hard-of-thinking numpties think that the inclusion of men in women's sports is progressive. .

x.com/WomRugbyComp/status/1680113372011048961

Namechangeforadhd · 07/09/2024 19:57

And the hypocrisy and double standards shown up by the fact that the Italians were (quite rightly) not at all happy with their female boxer having to fight Khelif, whilst in Paras they field a male.

Totallymessed · 07/09/2024 19:59

For anyone uncertain, here's a photo of the lovely lady in question. So I'll go with no, he's a fucking shameless cheat.

Valentina Petrillo shouldn't be allowed to compete in the women's race
Totallymessed · 07/09/2024 20:00

Note the ladylike bulge in his shorts 🤑

WheresMySupportCat · 07/09/2024 20:00

But....he has such lovely dangly .... earrings, Clearly a woman- bigot.

viques · 07/09/2024 20:01

WheresMySupportCat · 07/09/2024 19:38

Well- that's not what the Italian sports bodies said when Imane Khelif was busily breaking the nose of Angela Carini.

The whole thing is rotten rotten to the core.

No man should be in womens sports, refuges, safe spaces, prisons, hospitals.

Just fuck right off with your male pattern entitlement.

(ETA- not you, viques! Just in case it was not clear. I'm agreeing with you).

Edited

I know! It stinks. And the Italians need to join up the dots. The very marginal difference is that IK claims that they are a woman, has always been a woman, and will continue to say as much until the results of the chromosome tests are released, which they will be eventually, whereas Valentina is quite open that they “ transitioned” and say they are “now” a woman Personally I don’t think either of them have any right to claim to be women, but I am a mean rights hoarding dinosaur feminist who thinks women’s spaces , women’s sports and women’s language need to be protected.