Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the obsession with driving / red flag if partner doesn’t drive?

388 replies

User7567 · 22/08/2024 22:04

Why is this such a big thing? I see so often here that people wouldn’t date someone who doesn’t drive. Neither me nor my husband drive (we both have a licence but no car). I just don’t see the point. I don’t enjoy it, the tube (we’re in London) is much quicker and more convenient, parking is a nightmare and expensive….these very few times we find ourselves in a position where public transport is not convenient, we call an Uber/taxi (approx once per month/once every two months). Works out so much cheaper than paying for congestion charge, parking, insurance, MOT etc. over the year. I’m glad that my partner sees it the same way and that we can invest the money we’d otherwise spend on a car elsewhere…obviously each to their own and so on, no one needs to care what works for us and I don’t care what others do, I’m just confused why the majority would consider us as a red flag for not driving.

OP posts:
Ozanj · 23/08/2024 10:45

Lol where I live it would cost the same as a zone 1-6 card for a single bus ride for 3 miles. Cars are essential here

zingally · 23/08/2024 10:48

Living in the capital, with the best public transport system in the country is not even close to comparable with people who live elsewhere.
I wouldn't be able to do the job I do if I didn't drive. My widowed mum, who lives rurally, wouldn't be able to continue living there if she didn't drive, and her social life would be almost nonexistent.

That being said, I don't particularly like driving. And if it's something I can easily walk to, then I will.

Cosyblankets · 23/08/2024 10:54

Not having a car etc is massively different if you don't live in London.
Before I was self employed my workplace was less than a 15 minute drive. By public transport it would have been a ten min walk then a 40 min bus then another ten min walk. Or a ten min walk and two trains and a 30 min walk.

ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 10:56

takealettermsjones · 23/08/2024 10:43

All right, now transpose that attitude onto a small town with no trains, no taxis, one bus that serves every stop and therefore takes 90 mins to do a 10 min drive, hills for days, three school age kids, one science project, one bake sale and a tuba, and then tell me you're going to do the school run on the bus. 🙄

As previous posters have said, it's not "not driving" that's the red flag, it's "not driving when you live in a place/have a lifestyle where you really need to fecking drive and yet you expect everyone else to either put up with you taking three times as long to get anywhere and/or drive you for free"

I do get that, which is why I don't live anywhere like that. I grew up in a remote village in Devon. If I hadn't moved when I was sixteen, if I'd wanted to keep living there, I would have had to drive, no two ways about it.

It does restrict where you can live independently, for sure. A right bummer for those who can't drive due to disability.

ginasevern · 23/08/2024 11:00

My late DH (bless him) didn't drive. He never sat a test and the whole idea made him anxious. I never pushed it but there were times when it would have been fantastic if he could've shared the burden. Getting the car to the garage for it's MOT and then collecting it for example was always my responsibility, no matter how busy or unwell I was, or driving long distances to see relatives (West Wales in our case). Just nipping to the shop for some forgotten item could take him an hour round trip as opposed to 10 minutes in the car.

There were times, just occasionally, when it would've been so, so beneficial if he could drive. It didn't cause resentment (well, not much and not that I ever showed it) but I can see how it would create an unbalance in a partnership. Especially where children are involved or if you live somewhere with crap public transport and one partner is totally dependent on the other. For clarity, I live in Bristol which is a fairly major city but unless you're retired the public transport here would give you a nervous breakdown if you relied on it all the time.

IdLikeToBeAFraser · 23/08/2024 11:01

I couldn't care less if people drive or not if those non-drivers do not expect me to compensate for them as a result.

But the reason it's a red flag (not necessarily relationship ending, but something to look out for) is that outside of major cities like London, the overlap between men who are happy to let their (female) partners take on the bulk of the effort in a relationship and men who don't drive is pretty high. It is a potential - but not guaranteed - sign of a man who is going to literally take a backseat.

aCatCalledFawkes · 23/08/2024 11:07

I’m a single woman living with two children. I hate the fact I’m the only driver and everything feels like it stops with me ☹️.
I do have a boyfriend who loves driving and tbh it’s been a bit of a revelation to be driven around, That said I’m happy to drive to him too.
My daughter is having driving lessons and I can’t wait to stop driving her everywhere.

rayofsunshine86 · 23/08/2024 11:17

DH doesn't drive and it's a royal pain in the arse.

Edited to add: Oh, and we live in the countryside. We have to drive to go anywhere. You can imagine how frustrating it is to be told "I need to learn how to drive" for six years.

FloatyBoaty · 23/08/2024 11:22

YaWeeFurryBastard · 23/08/2024 10:20

I used to live in a (non-London) large city and public transport was not good, so driving still needed for having any semblance of convenience or flexibility.

I always see non-drivers on mumsnet insist they are completely self sufficient and don’t impose on anyone, I have literally never known this to be the case, every single non-driver I have met expects help from others in some way, they just often don’t see it as “you’d be going anyway” “I’ll get a taxi to yours so you don’t have to collect me on your way”.

I remember one friend being aghast that I asked for petrol money when I drove her to the lakes as “you’d be going anyway”, er yes but it would be nice to have shared the driving on the two hour journey let alone the cost.

There were loads of places I needed to drive when I lived in a city - goApe, local nature reserve, safari park, supermarket etc. I think in almost all circumstances kids miss out without a driving parent.

This is absolute nonsense.

a sample of places my son has been this year, with a non driving single parent (and no, nobody gave us a lift)…

3 remote fishing villages/beaches in North Yorkshire (traveled by bus, and stayed each place a few nights)
Moorland walks in national park
Woodland walks in the Yorkshire dales
Stately home with excellent children playground
The zoo
A castle
Clip and climb
The theatre
Steam train trip
London- did the big museums, Ken Gardens, Kew, river boat trip etc
Liverpool maritime museum
Boating on the canal
Riverside picnic and wild swimming at remote beauty spot
Barcelona & towns on Costa Maresme

he also goes to swimming lessons, tennis lessons, beavers and has an active social life with school friends- and no, their parents aren’t expected to ferry him around. We walk or catch the bus to meet them. Occasionally I’ll accept a lift for him if they insist, but always offer petrol and will bring a small thank you gift .

I could go on… but does it SOUND like he’s “missing out” to you because he has no driving parent?

Ljcrow · 23/08/2024 11:26

CeeJay81 · 23/08/2024 09:50

My hubby stopped driving years ago partly down to finance but he never like it either. He has a new health condition now which makes him more nervous to start again but he alsk doesnt care about having a car and doesn't want too. At 43 I'm taking lessons again(suspected adhd), tried in the past and found it too much. I am doing OK atm(doing automatic) and have a good instructor but it worries me the amount of things/rules there is to remember. Even if I pass I wont be driving long distance.

So we manage on public transport in a rural part of the UK. My work is 10 mins walk and the kids schools are in walking distance too. Hourly bus to local town and trains every 1 to 2 hours to get you further. Occasionally I need a lift for dd to a school event, which I find embarassing, but thats it. We are used to it. I feel like such a loser when I read the way mumsnet thinks.

I can relate to this so much and totally empathise. You're not a loser. 💛

focacciamuffin · 23/08/2024 11:30

You used to need a red flag if you did drive. Luckily not since 1896.

To not understand the obsession with driving / red flag if partner doesn’t drive?
ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 11:45

FloatyBoaty · 23/08/2024 11:22

This is absolute nonsense.

a sample of places my son has been this year, with a non driving single parent (and no, nobody gave us a lift)…

3 remote fishing villages/beaches in North Yorkshire (traveled by bus, and stayed each place a few nights)
Moorland walks in national park
Woodland walks in the Yorkshire dales
Stately home with excellent children playground
The zoo
A castle
Clip and climb
The theatre
Steam train trip
London- did the big museums, Ken Gardens, Kew, river boat trip etc
Liverpool maritime museum
Boating on the canal
Riverside picnic and wild swimming at remote beauty spot
Barcelona & towns on Costa Maresme

he also goes to swimming lessons, tennis lessons, beavers and has an active social life with school friends- and no, their parents aren’t expected to ferry him around. We walk or catch the bus to meet them. Occasionally I’ll accept a lift for him if they insist, but always offer petrol and will bring a small thank you gift .

I could go on… but does it SOUND like he’s “missing out” to you because he has no driving parent?

TBF some kids with driving parents don't do as much as that. My old schoolfriend who lives in a rural area, is married with kids and both drive rarely leaves the county she lives in.

BigDahliaFan · 23/08/2024 11:50

I think driving is a useful skill and harder to learn the older you get. It's also a pain if friends/partner don't drive.

, either you, the driver, drive everywhere or with friends activities have to be sorted round the, where I live, inadequate public transport.

BigDahliaFan · 23/08/2024 11:52

I do judge people who could learn to drive but don't. What about holidays? Visiting places without good public transport?

FloatyBoaty · 23/08/2024 11:54

ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 11:45

TBF some kids with driving parents don't do as much as that. My old schoolfriend who lives in a rural area, is married with kids and both drive rarely leaves the county she lives in.

😂 we do do a lot- I get bored easily. And that’s last 12 months, not since the start of the year. But my point stands! I’ve designed the rest of our lives to allow for not having a car (eg choosing to live in a walkable neighbourhood with good transport links… NOT London…) and also- I’m just really determined. Ofc we have privilege in both being able bodied and my son loves walking - will often choose a 10+ mile hike as a “day out” of choice- but I really don’t think it’s fair to make blanket assumptions about non drivers in the way this thread has. Particularly not to claim we’re somehow abusing or letting our children down - which I’ve seen a few times, and is fairly vile.

OttilieKnackered · 23/08/2024 12:04

I don’t drive. I rely on DP a bit (maybe once a week/once a fortnight) to drive me. These are places like his parents’ house/hospital which I could get to alone but it’s quicker to drive.

But he relies on me for: earning most of the income, providing the deposit for our house, being on top of 90% of the mental load for us, our families, our toddler.

So I don’t think he does badly out of it. I currently walk to work (central residential suburb to city centre). I am soon moving jobs to one where there is a 20 min bus which goes every 10 mins from opposite our son’s nursery. In three years that office will move to the city centre and I wouldn’t be allowed to drive. There is no parking.

So should I learn to drive at a cost of £40-£50 an hour so I can drive occasionally on weekends and have no regular practice?

BTW the reason I can’t drive is I grew up in poverty so had no help with it. And since then I’ve had no need/not enough money (at different times). DP’s parents paid for his driving lessons, first car, insurance etc. He also works in the countryside so driving is essential day to day for him.

phoenixrosehere · 23/08/2024 12:09

takealettermsjones · 23/08/2024 10:43

All right, now transpose that attitude onto a small town with no trains, no taxis, one bus that serves every stop and therefore takes 90 mins to do a 10 min drive, hills for days, three school age kids, one science project, one bake sale and a tuba, and then tell me you're going to do the school run on the bus. 🙄

As previous posters have said, it's not "not driving" that's the red flag, it's "not driving when you live in a place/have a lifestyle where you really need to fecking drive and yet you expect everyone else to either put up with you taking three times as long to get anywhere and/or drive you for free"

Wherever did they say that or allude to that?

Not sure why some refuse to believe that there is decent public transport outside of London and many non-drivers can and do get around without a car, are happy, and not being a hindrance and asking favours to those who do drive.

Many of us get to places on time even early without having someone wait on us to get there or need a lift.

I’ve had plenty of instances where I’ve had to wait on people who drive to arrive because they either didn’t take into account traffic, parking, and assuming because it was x amount of miles, it should be quick, left their house without considering they may need extra time and were late by 30 min or even an hour.

It’s not even whether the person drives or not, but the personality of the person more than anything. A person who constantly asks or expects rides probably is like that with other things.

phoenixrosehere · 23/08/2024 12:20

BigDahliaFan · 23/08/2024 11:52

I do judge people who could learn to drive but don't. What about holidays? Visiting places without good public transport?

What about them? You either walk, take a taxi, and there’s an option to go on excursions.

There are plenty of places where you shouldn’t drive due to the way the roads are and it is better to go with someone who knows the area than trying to drive on your own. Some find that out the hard way and end up needing to be rescued or worse. Plenty also don’t want tourists going to places and leaving litter behind or messing with the environment so have guided tours.

I’ve been on plenty of holidays where DH didn’t drive or rent a car during our holidays.

takealettermsjones · 23/08/2024 12:31

phoenixrosehere · 23/08/2024 12:09

Wherever did they say that or allude to that?

Not sure why some refuse to believe that there is decent public transport outside of London and many non-drivers can and do get around without a car, are happy, and not being a hindrance and asking favours to those who do drive.

Many of us get to places on time even early without having someone wait on us to get there or need a lift.

I’ve had plenty of instances where I’ve had to wait on people who drive to arrive because they either didn’t take into account traffic, parking, and assuming because it was x amount of miles, it should be quick, left their house without considering they may need extra time and were late by 30 min or even an hour.

It’s not even whether the person drives or not, but the personality of the person more than anything. A person who constantly asks or expects rides probably is like that with other things.

Edited

Where did who say what?

We are in agreement. My point is clearly that it's not the not driving that's a problem, it's not driving if you live in a place where you really need to drive to be able to keep up your expected lifestyle and your not driving causes an issue to others. I'm not suggesting there aren't any people in the world who can go about their lives perfectly well without driving.

DinnaeFashYersel · 23/08/2024 12:36

DdraigGoch · 23/08/2024 10:35

Many remote parts of Scotland and Wales are accessible by train and bus. I've stayed in the West Highlands a few times. No cars or taxis involved; just trains, buses and ferries.

And a hell of a lot of Scotland is not.

RedPony1 · 23/08/2024 14:08

Konstantine8364 · 23/08/2024 10:32

Honestly it depends on your lifestyle and where you live. I'm very busy, I have a full time job, have horses and love hiking/outdoor swimming, my life would be absolutely impossible without a car. My lifestyle would also be impossible in London so I wouldn't live there! I want to date outdoorsy men with sporty hobbies, the vast majority of which you need to drive for. I also like a drink, so I wouldn't consider dating someone who doesn't drive. Having to drive long trips with no-one to swap with/not able to take it in turns to drink at parties etc would be rubbish.

It's also a personality thing, I'm outgoing and independent and got my license when I was 17 as driving gives you freedom. The few people I know who don't drive tend to be quite passive people, which again isn't 'my type'.

We are the same!

If i didn't drive, i wouldn't be able to do all the things i most enjoy in life. I wouldn't be able to work where i do either. Life would be so dull with a lot less opportunities

Summertimer · 23/08/2024 18:11

SweetBirdsong · 22/08/2024 23:44

All the LOLz.

Why say this? I discovered that we could do Scotland/Isle of Skye without a car in 1998 - that’s when I knew I’d give up on the idea of driving

Summertimer · 23/08/2024 18:14

InterIgnis · 23/08/2024 00:00

Do you need to get it?

I didn’t date men that couldn’t drive. I value driving as a life skill, personally, but that doesn’t mean that you or anyone else has to. We’re all entitled to our own dealbreakers based on our own criteria.

‘Dealbreaker’ I get as an expression but ‘Red flag’ means something else to me

Summertimer · 23/08/2024 18:18

FloatyBoaty · 23/08/2024 11:22

This is absolute nonsense.

a sample of places my son has been this year, with a non driving single parent (and no, nobody gave us a lift)…

3 remote fishing villages/beaches in North Yorkshire (traveled by bus, and stayed each place a few nights)
Moorland walks in national park
Woodland walks in the Yorkshire dales
Stately home with excellent children playground
The zoo
A castle
Clip and climb
The theatre
Steam train trip
London- did the big museums, Ken Gardens, Kew, river boat trip etc
Liverpool maritime museum
Boating on the canal
Riverside picnic and wild swimming at remote beauty spot
Barcelona & towns on Costa Maresme

he also goes to swimming lessons, tennis lessons, beavers and has an active social life with school friends- and no, their parents aren’t expected to ferry him around. We walk or catch the bus to meet them. Occasionally I’ll accept a lift for him if they insist, but always offer petrol and will bring a small thank you gift .

I could go on… but does it SOUND like he’s “missing out” to you because he has no driving parent?

This is us, our DC did all those things and got him to parties for pals who lived in villages out of town etc. It’s all doable

Summertimer · 23/08/2024 18:24

DinnaeFashYersel · 23/08/2024 12:36

And a hell of a lot of Scotland is not.

But not beyond a taxi service. All the hassle of driving to the ferry or abroad etc. All these threads about how to keep kids amused on long journeys when you could all be on a train together. Really not for me

Swipe left for the next trending thread