Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH’s attitude re riots etc upsetting and angering me

1000 replies

Pinkycloud · 07/08/2024 13:55

I feel so sick. Every time we talk about the riots, DH comes out with ‘well people are angry, etc’. He says he doesn’t condone violence, but there’s always a ‘but’. He voted Reform, I voted Lib Dem. I tell him he sounds racist in some of the comments he makes, which he vehemently denies.

He’s a loving, hardworking husband and father but… this! He is honestly a good man. I don’t know how to deal with it other than banning the subject. Has anyone else got very different political views from their spouse or partner?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
25percent · 07/08/2024 15:52

We just had an election so I don’t understand why anyone feels they’re not being listened too. We live in a democracy and people voted against the Tories and their Rwanda policy and most people voted against Reform. I wouldn’t be with anyone who said they understand the scum that are taking part in these riots.

Superworm24 · 07/08/2024 15:52

CautiousLurker · 07/08/2024 15:35

I think you are ‘borrowing’ trouble. Picking a fight over an issue that doesn’t directly affect you.

And (as a child raise in a Muslim refugee family who arrived here in the 1970s) I agree with him that there is more nuance to this, that it has been simmering beneath the surface for years (hence the Brexit result) and it is far more complex than ‘racism’.

the most under privileged demographic in the UK currently is poor, white, working class men/boys - they are the most likely to be free school meals, have the lowest attendance record, the poorest GCSE/BTEC/Alevel outcomes, are least likely to go to university, the most likely to be on benefits. This is obviously bugger all to do with the number of Muslim/black/Asian individuals who have moved to the UK in recent decades, but a symptom of decades of neglect by successive governments and an increasingly inadequate state education system, especially in areas of high poverty.

What is abhorrent is that, egged on/manipulated by a small contingent of far-right yobs, people are targeting their frustration and anger at Muslims. MSM and SM are responsible for feeding people the idea that the issues they face - lack of jobs, poor educations, inadequate housing - is the fault of an immigration ‘explosion’ (!!) when in fact it is a systemic and deep-seated social problem that has been allowed to percolate for decades - probably since Thatcher broke the unions and we saw the decline of mining & the manufacturing industries that supported these men. We’ve all sat back and shrugged because we were all right Jack, but until we face up to the wholesale failure to address this issue, they will continue to be angry, feel unseen, unheard, and target those that seem to be getting on alright. The economic downturn post 2008, Brexit, lockdowns, the CoL crisis has just exacerbated these simmering feelings… but no one of any political party has stepped up.

Just like poor, white displaced and angry young men readily took up arms and focused their disillusion and anger at the Jewish community in 1930s Germany after the the depression caused by the 1929 Wall Street Crash…

So, I’d say your husband is probably not wrong and you, like many people, are being disingenuous to dismiss this as mere racism.

Edited

Brilliant post. I wrote a similar on a different thread.

DH and I have differing political and religious views. I can't say I always understand his views, especially on religion as im agnostic but i can respect it. People are entitled to their own opinions and beliefs. I think the world must be incredibly small for some posters. You surround yourselves with people who only think the same way as you do.

InsensibleMe · 07/08/2024 15:52

ATenShun · 07/08/2024 14:46

I suspect brexit would not have come about had people similar to todays protestors been listened to 20 years ago. It was uncontrolled economic migration from Eastern Europe and the resulting reduction in real time wages that brought about the desire to leave the EU. I am a leave supporter, I still believe in time it will prove to be the correct decision. However prior to the open bordered policy on migration, I was very much supportive of the EU as a trading bloc.

Again, ‘Not listened to?’ It’s not as if politicians were hanging off my every word 20 years ago…. It was ever thus, and almost everybody can legitimately feel they are unheard, there are 60 million of us. But politicians make decisions that they believe are in the best interest of the country, rightly or wrongly, and not according to some particular group interest.
FWIW, 20 years ago we had a booming economy, and record levels of employment,

Redgreenfroggy · 07/08/2024 15:54

Would be a complete deal breaker for me. The nazi party started out by people having sympathy for them and understanding how they felt. Ok I know I am being a bit extreme there but

SouthLondonMum22 · 07/08/2024 15:55

I wouldn’t be able to stay with someone like that. Doesn’t sound like a good man to me.

biscuitandcake · 07/08/2024 15:55

Poppycornfields · 07/08/2024 14:58

I think this thread does throw up a lot of the problems we are dealing with as a society at the moment.

People claiming - oh well, I am angry and I haven’t resorted to violence - no, not on an individual level. But women have in the past done so in order to obtain the vote, in order to fight for some of the rights we have today. There’s also been violence when protesting against racism (is it acceptable then?) and other things most of us would consider to be positive movements. It’s probably hard to avoid to a point when big crowds congregate and feelings are high.

There is the lazy way of looking at it - this is wrong and if you say anything, anything other than how wrong it is, you are also wrong. And I wouldn’t be near a person who did because I’m not wrong; I’m very very not wrong.

Or there’s the more complex - this is wrong, how, as a society, can we all start to put it right?

The vote. Lots of debate about suffragettes versus suffragists. But outside women's suffrage there are clearly points when most people think civil disobediance including literal violence is justified - e.g. the American war of Independence (against us), French resistance in WW2. I think though that there is a really high bar for that to be justified. Really really high. Because even legitimate grievances/causes lead to bloodshed and festering resentment for decades The right to vote where you don't have a voice or any legal way of expressing yourself might have been a just cause for people in Boston or women. But we just had a sodding election. People can vote, people can see their MP, people can hold signs. Lots of people do. People can't glue themselves to the road blocking ambulances (extinction rebellion), or set fire to things ("anti-racist" rioters in 2011, "anti-immigration" rioters now) without expecting consequences.

I think violence in the name of opposing racism in particular is a very stupid idea. If you already live somewhere the majority population are oppressing you, setting fire to their stuff is not a good plan. There is a reason Martin Luther King used the tactics he did. Anti-fa are trouble causing idiots. So was the man shouting "free Palestine" as he slashed that woman's car tyre.

sunflowrsngunpowdr · 07/08/2024 15:56

If i were your husband I'd file for divorce and find a wife who doesn't think she can control my thoughts and opinions.

PeapodRas · 07/08/2024 15:59

mrshoho · 07/08/2024 15:27

Greg Thwaites, research director at the Resolution Foundation, said: “The extra 6 million people in Britain have certainly made the economy bigger, but have done little for GDP per capita. The UK’s record on productivity – which is what really matters for living standards – is exceptionally bad.

Hardly a glowing success story though is it! And what of school, hospitals and services that never expanded to deal with this extra 6million people? Back in 2010 when people protested and spoke of their concerns they were told to shut their ignorant racist mouths by middle class, privileged elites.

No it's not, but it shows that immigration has helped with growth. Something the UK is not doing on its own (that's a concern in itself).

It goes against the rhetoric that immigration is a strain on our country's resources, being my main point!

And actually where I live, schools rely on these immigrants to keep open.

Also multiplier effect - demand increases spending which in turn increases growth so I think what you've mentioned re services is probably included in the whole growth report

Diyextension · 07/08/2024 16:00

Eww I couldn’t live with anyone who voted lib dem , how utterly disgusting…..

Stripedchutney · 07/08/2024 16:01

I would find that too hard to tolerate. Sorry OP. it would be a deal breaker for me. The only sensible, calm and human response to the actions of these violent, racist thugs is utter horror and condemnation. Anyone supporting their actions in anyway would not be people I would want in my life.

oakleaffy · 07/08/2024 16:01

CautiousLurker · 07/08/2024 15:35

I think you are ‘borrowing’ trouble. Picking a fight over an issue that doesn’t directly affect you.

And (as a child raise in a Muslim refugee family who arrived here in the 1970s) I agree with him that there is more nuance to this, that it has been simmering beneath the surface for years (hence the Brexit result) and it is far more complex than ‘racism’.

the most under privileged demographic in the UK currently is poor, white, working class men/boys - they are the most likely to be free school meals, have the lowest attendance record, the poorest GCSE/BTEC/Alevel outcomes, are least likely to go to university, the most likely to be on benefits. This is obviously bugger all to do with the number of Muslim/black/Asian individuals who have moved to the UK in recent decades, but a symptom of decades of neglect by successive governments and an increasingly inadequate state education system, especially in areas of high poverty.

What is abhorrent is that, egged on/manipulated by a small contingent of far-right yobs, people are targeting their frustration and anger at Muslims. MSM and SM are responsible for feeding people the idea that the issues they face - lack of jobs, poor educations, inadequate housing - is the fault of an immigration ‘explosion’ (!!) when in fact it is a systemic and deep-seated social problem that has been allowed to percolate for decades - probably since Thatcher broke the unions and we saw the decline of mining & the manufacturing industries that supported these men. We’ve all sat back and shrugged because we were all right Jack, but until we face up to the wholesale failure to address this issue, they will continue to be angry, feel unseen, unheard, and target those that seem to be getting on alright. The economic downturn post 2008, Brexit, lockdowns, the CoL crisis has just exacerbated these simmering feelings… but no one of any political party has stepped up.

Just like poor, white displaced and angry young men readily took up arms and focused their disillusion and anger at the Jewish community in 1930s Germany after the the depression caused by the 1929 Wall Street Crash…

So, I’d say your husband is probably not wrong and you, like many people, are being disingenuous to dismiss this as mere racism.

Edited

Superb post.
Fancy standing as an MP?

Stripedchutney · 07/08/2024 16:02

Diyextension · 07/08/2024 16:00

Eww I couldn’t live with anyone who voted lib dem , how utterly disgusting…..

Why. What of their policies do you find so objectionable you couldn’t tolerate someone who had voted for them?

Devilsadvocat · 07/08/2024 16:05

Is he goong out and rioting. I dont expect he is or will in the near future. Dont discuss politics and tell him you dissagree with him and that you dont want to know, then get on with your life.

RoastChickenForDinner · 07/08/2024 16:05

ginasevern · 07/08/2024 14:21

Reform? I couldn't even bring myself to fuck a Tory.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I flipped to page 2 and just found this funny at the top of the thread. Thanks for the laugh😂😂

<Wipes tears>

(( No I'm not taking it at all seriously before I get jumped on))

blackcherryconserve · 07/08/2024 16:10

ScribblingPixie · 07/08/2024 14:22

A Lib Dem and Reform household? I'd struggle to pick a side.

Same here.

Diyextension · 07/08/2024 16:13

Op , when he starts wearing a balaclava and throwing bread rolls at the tv when the news is on then thats the time to get your suitcase out 📺 🥖 🥖🥖🥖

LlynTegid · 07/08/2024 16:13

Differing parties, at least he voted, you can agree to disagree. Not condoning violence.

Bunnygirl1902 · 07/08/2024 16:21

Soukmyfalafel · 07/08/2024 15:48

The post you are commenting on makes me laugh. Probably a bot. How do you solve the housing crisis, NHS backlog, and immigration in five weeks, all with a 20bln black hole in the budget. I'd love to know.

Not a bot 🤗Well how about not cancelling the Rwanda flight for a start?

cardibach · 07/08/2024 16:21

Marchitectmummy · 07/08/2024 15:34

Just stop talking about politics, he is entitled to his political view you are entitled to yours. The election is over, the topic will subdue.

In terms of the views on reasoning behind the riots, maybe find out more about that and what his view actually is. I'm mixed race and I can understand how it's come to this, while 100% disagreeing with violence.

Politics, to paraphrase, is for life, not just elections. Nobody should be able to forget about it, it’s part of everyday life.

viques · 07/08/2024 16:26

@Pinkycloud So why does he think the mindless rioters are targeting and physically attacking the people, the places, the businesses and possessions of certain people that they are? Why does he think the verbal language and graffiti is racist? What does he think the rioters are rioting about?

You are married to a racist.

alrightluv · 07/08/2024 16:28

Someone close to me was trying to say TR was misunderstood and sounded sympathetic about the rioting thugs. I sent them a video. They were shocked and stfu.

cardibach · 07/08/2024 16:28

Thebellofstclements · 07/08/2024 15:36

The usual MN "where's your empathy?!" seems to have gone astray these last few days. People have near to zero funds and they see millions being spent housing people who relentlessly arrive illegally. Then a government has been voted in that apparently REFUSES to acknowledge there's a problem.
When the going is good, Britain is mostly ok. But when things aren't great - and as well as a rubbish summer (weather wise), England also lost the football - the tensions bubbling under the surface will always boil over.
Relatively, Britain is not a racist country. Relatively. But that's because, relatively, we are a well-travelled bunch, which promotes accepting minds. I'd be amazed if any of the rioters have lived abroad further than Spain. It's not Christian Aid, UN or Foreign Office employees "demonstrating", is it?

Well this is a pile of bollocks.

  1. People in boats aren’t arriving illegally. There’s zero chance you haven’t been made aware already that arriving by any means and then claiming asylum is not illegal.
  2. Millions are being spent housing them because Tories took the deliberate choice not to assess very many claims so they could build up members to create a crisis for their own reasons (not least so their mates could make a fortune from letting hotel rooms to the government).
  3. The Labour government absolutely acknowledges there is a problem and has announced a series of measures to clear the backlog and reduce numbers risking the channel crossing.
  4. You’re even wrong about the weather. Riots happen when it’s hot.
Jennyathemall · 07/08/2024 16:28

It would be a ridiculous thing to end an otherwise harmonious and successful relationship over. Maybe try seeing the nuance in his point of view and failing that just agree to disagree.

askmenow · 07/08/2024 16:30

ThePassageOfTime · 07/08/2024 14:00

I couldn't continue the relationship OP.

When was he radicalized? Was it recent and do you think there is a way back for him?

Radicalised??? WTF!
That some people are rightly worried about unfettered undocumented males being foisted on their communities? We don't know who these incomers are given their chucking phones and documents overboard!

Have you watched the boats coming ashore this morning? Don't think there was a female among them.

And then watching / hearing those disenfranchised people being cast as' Far Right' by our PM? The optics are everything in this. And Starmer hasn't shown himself to be verbally sure footed so far.

I wonder how many on here will be so happy defending the "scatter dispersal "of these migrants to your local councils, the Labour government is intending to implement. They will shortly be in a HMO next to you!

And hey ho....once the universities start going bust ( now numbers are down) and halls closing they'll be in halls aswell.
And our young can't get housing.

Thats who we should be spending our hard earned tax money on. Making things better for our youth of all ethnicities.

oakleaffy · 07/08/2024 16:31

Looks like rain, so hopefully that will cool any rioting this evening.
Seems like men especially enjoy a good old riot.

Pic from 1831. The statue still stands.

Bristol.

DH’s attitude re riots etc upsetting and angering me
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.