Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to keep the compensation money

144 replies

Pink39tree · 20/07/2024 21:00

Sibling lives far overseas, is on a very high paying job and because of this can rarely visit home. Has been begging for me to bring our elderly mother out to visit. We agreed together as her joint birthday present I will travel with her over to the country they are at.

Initially sibling was expecting me to pay for my full plane ticket (very expensive tickets) and half of mums, which I was refusing to do. I was under the impression that I was to pay half of the travel costs of getting mum out there and that included my share of the costs. (I would never of visited if it wasn’t for mum) this meant sibling kept saying they had paid for the full present which was annoying. (I also paid for petrol to the airport, airport parking, mums food/drinks etc which all adds up)

on the way back the flight was delayed by a ridiculous amount of time, it was so badly handled by the airline and we were left stranded. My mum is elderly which meant this delays were a nightmare/stressful to cope with but I made sure she had everything she needed even if I was running around like a headless chicken. It was a long flight and so we also missed out transit which added to the stress as it meant I had to sort out replacements all on my own. Was the worst travel experience I ever had Sibling was not picking up any calls at the time and only sent a text after saying “what a nightmare glad it’s sorted now”

the airline refunded us the cost of both tickets and some compensation on top. (I had to chase repeatedly for this) I’ve kept the money for both tickets despite only paying for my own. Sibling has demanded i repay them for the cost of mums tickets, am I AIBU to keep the money as I feel we only got it for having to endure the suffering of being so badly delayed and sibling didn’t go through that nor did they support.

OP posts:
OneFrenchEgg · 20/07/2024 21:46

Keep the compensation for you and your mum

Repay your sister the ticket refund amount

Fgs people who are wealthy don't owe you anything

Izzynohopanda · 20/07/2024 21:51

StormingNorman · 20/07/2024 21:45

You keep the refund on your ticket.
Your sibling gets the refund on your Mum’s ticket.
You and Mum split the compensation 50/50

This

SnappyCroc · 20/07/2024 22:00

I disagree that your sibling should get the flight money.

They got what they paid for, which was your mum visiting and you accompanying her.

The reason the flight cost was refunded and compensation paid was because you and your mum had a nightmare journey. So the money is for you and your mum.

I would tell the sibling that you'll be keeping the money and putting half towards additional things for your mum to make things more enjoyable/comfortable for her.

Unless sibling would like to pay you half the going rate for your services in accompanying your mum and sorting all the travel difficulties?

AskMeTomorrow · 20/07/2024 22:02

I had a very similar situation travelling with a relative’s DC as a favour to them. Flights all paid for by my relative but we ended up with major cancellations and delays on the journey. I applied for and kept my share of the compensation and put the DC’s share into their savings account. My relative had expected to be down the cost of the flights and never even asked for anything back. We were the ones inconvenienced, hence the compensation was for us.

Fifthtimelucky · 20/07/2024 22:12

I think you are very unreasonable to keep the lot.

The refund should have gone to the people who paid for the tickets: so half to you and half to your sister.

The compensation should be paid to be people who were inconvenienced: half to you and half to your mum.

Thursa · 20/07/2024 22:37

Sibling gets refunded for mum’s ticket.
You keep refund for your ticket.
Compensation gets split between the people who were inconvenienced.

Catpuss66 · 20/07/2024 22:38

Wasn’t your moms flight a gift though? If I was given a jumper & took it back to the shop for a refund would I give the grifter the money or keep it myself? I know what I would do.

manysausages · 20/07/2024 22:52

I would keep half the money (the refund and the compensation) and with the rest buy another ticket for your mum to visit your sibling but tell sibling they must come across and collect your mum. At their own expense.

Well, of course I wouldn’t really, but it’s tempting.

Sibling should not get any of this payout, but if OP gives mum half, mum will likely reimburse sibling for their generous gift when the whole thing has been a costly nightmare for OP.

Pink39tree · 20/07/2024 23:01

the majority of the money back was the refund of the tickets, the compensation was hardly anything.

Additional costs were incurred by myself for my mum having to buy food and drinks at the airports, transport etc. We were given vouchers but they were minuscule. I don’t count that as it was for my mum and just wanted her to be okay. She’s also not the easiest of people to travel with which adds to the stress.

as far as I see it and I know many think I’m wrong, sibling got what they wanted as they got my mum to visits. I was left to deal with all the mess caused by the delays by myself. It’s not easy at all to travel with an elderly person especially with the added stress.

if it was me in their shoes I would be thankful by sibling dealt with it all, got my mum home safely and any money returned was a bonus for them for what they had to go through.

OP posts:
autienotnaughti · 20/07/2024 23:03

I'd refund your sister for what she paid for your flight not your mother's. And then split with your mother

Pink39tree · 20/07/2024 23:05

@autienotnaughti i paid for my full flight. My sibling paid for my mums. (They wanted me to pay for my own full flights and half of the cost of my mums originally)

OP posts:
Neodymium · 20/07/2024 23:07

Why did you tell your sibling that you got anything refunded? If they weren’t interested in the delays when they were happening, and didn’t want to help. You should have just got the compensation and said nothing.

autienotnaughti · 20/07/2024 23:08

Pink39tree · 20/07/2024 23:05

@autienotnaughti i paid for my full flight. My sibling paid for my mums. (They wanted me to pay for my own full flights and half of the cost of my mums originally)

Ok then I'd refund half mums flight. And then split with your mum.

But I don't know your relationship if she deserves F A then go for it!

justanothermanicmonday1 · 20/07/2024 23:08

Blisterly · 20/07/2024 21:03

Compensation is for the discomfort of being delayed. My company pay my train/air travel. If I am delayed I get to keep the compensation as I am the one delayed. Your sister’s income is irrelevant.

Edited to say that the compensation should be split between you and your mum as you both were inconvenienced by the delay.

Edited

As a claims handler, you are 100% correct.

MeganM3 · 20/07/2024 23:21

I don't think you should give your sibling any of it. It sounds like a really awful journey that you had to deal with.
Sibling paid for flight, which was taken. Mother arrived at destination. The rest of it is irrelevant to them as they weren't there to endure the dreadful delay.

You could consider splitting with your mum but I also wouldn't judge you for keeping it. As only you chased for it and sounds like you did an excellent job as unpaid, unthanked carer.

Pink39tree · 20/07/2024 23:28

Thank you for all the comments. My fear with giving the money to my mum is she just gives it all to my sibling. I think I’ll spend it on my mum instead by taking her out and treating her. The money will be nothing to my sibling who has plenty but treating my mum she will feel it more.

my relationship with my sibling has been strained, they moved away from all responsibility and because of that it’s all fallen on me. This isn’t a way of getting back at them, I just don’t think they deserve any of it a they weren’t the one to suffer through it.

I think you can start to draw a picture of how despite never doing anything for our mum, mum still thinks they are the golden child. I didn’t even get any credit for taking mum over there as “your sibling paid for my ticket”

OP posts:
booksunderthebed · 20/07/2024 23:31

Deduct whatever extra you spent on food or whatever due to the delay and then give the money to your mother. She can give it to your sibling or the cats home or buy potted plants.

Next time don't tell sibling about compensation.

SnappyCroc · 20/07/2024 23:40

If you do refund sibling the flight money, set an hourly rate for your caring services, multiply by the number of hours you were delayed and deduct 50% of that from the flight costs. Likewise, deduct 50% of any additional expenses you incurred on your and your mum's behalf.

SuncreamAndIceCream · 20/07/2024 23:41

The compo is for the disruption

Your sibling wasn't inconvenienced

The money should be split between you and your mum

If your mum chooses to give her share to your sibling that's up to her.

InsensibleMe · 20/07/2024 23:56

Sibling? It’s a MAN isn’t it? I hope that makes the solution easier.

crampyi · 21/07/2024 00:24

I don’t understand why you aren’t sharing the compensation with your mum, she was clearly affected by the issues too?

SD1978 · 21/07/2024 00:41

Disagree with you keeping all the cost, and can understand why your sibling is annoyed, your taking money she pad and deciding to keep it. I assume you don't care about any further relationship with your sibling, because you won't have one

WGACA · 21/07/2024 01:13

InsensibleMe · 20/07/2024 23:56

Sibling? It’s a MAN isn’t it? I hope that makes the solution easier.

I think this too. The sibling who has absolved all responsibility for an elderly parent is more likely to be a brother.

Scumtastic · 21/07/2024 01:20

Thank you for all the comments. My fear with giving the money to my mum is she just gives it all to my sibling. I think I’ll spend it on my mum instead by taking her out and treating her. The money will be nothing to my sibling who has plenty but treating my mum she will feel it more

You can't keep or chose how to spend your Mums compensation. If you choose to keep it to take her out then you will be benefitting too. Give your sibling the ticket money and give the compensation to your Mum and don't give her any conditions. If she wants to give it all to your sibling that's up to her.

reluctantbrit · 21/07/2024 01:41

Sibling gets the refund for what she paid
You get the refund for what you paid
Compensation is split between your mum and you 50/50

Hardly rocket science