DW's overwhelming negativity

[PinkRunningShoes]

DW has always been a bit negative but nothing too terrible. We've recently been spending a lot more time together again since we both started WFH and I really don't know how to live with this negativity anymore.

E.g.:

1. She doesn't ask normal questions. She says something accusatory and poses it as a question. I ALWAYS walk the dog at 7:30am. I come home with some coffees for us, go to take a quick shower, and the first thing she says to me when she sees me is "you didn't walk the dog right". It's her way of asking if I did but why couldn't she just ask the question!
2. Everything is a criticism. I've recently bought an umbrella with a wooden duck sort of handle and the first thing she said was "aren't we too old for that". Bought pink running shoes for the morning dog walks. "Why would you get something in that shade?" Bought some nice moisturisers and face masks. "You do know that the supermarket ones do the same thing" Which may be so but these are fun.
3. Everything I do is wrong. I buy her some croissants she complains that they taste mediocre and it's unhealthy. I don't buy her croissants and she calls me selfish. There's no winning here.

We've spoken about this issue countless times and I'm always called "sensitive" as she's just "telling it like it is". After the dog comment yesterday I asked her why couldn't she just ask a question instead of making a negative statement so early in the morning and she said "am I not allowed to talk in my own house"!!

AIBU to be affected by this?

Of course not. What a drain. I suggest you wait for all the responses that will appear on this thread, and then just show it to her.

Sounds insufferable and like DW has a fragile ego so even their comms elevate and center them at your expense.

That would really get on my nerves and make me VERY snappy. Couldn’t put up with it permanently.
By the way, I think I’d die of gratitude if someone walked the dog and brought me coffee every morning.

Your wife is unreasonable.

Honestly, I don't know how you can stay.

Kindness costs nothing.

eject! eject! eject!

This would make me really miserable.

That must be unrelentingly miserable for you both. Sit her down and suggest counselling asap. I'd make it clear there's no available option to keep behaving the way she does. Individual counselling for you would also be helpful if you can afford it.

YANBU. Comments like that would bring the sarcasm and snarky side of me and we'd end up in war zone.

Out of curiosity, is there a significant age gap between you?

I’m so sorry you live with such a joy sponge . Do you want this for the rest of your life ? What is she trying to achieve? Is her aim to put you down at every turn? Why ? Get those ducks in a row … life’s too short 💐

My mum does that asking things with a negative question too, she is really emotionally immature. Have a read around emotional immaturity and see whether it sounds like your wife.

And no you are not unreasonable to find that really hard work.

Some people just get into a habit of doing this, without even knowing why.
Start picking her up on it.When she says negative things tell her how it makes you feel "I picked this umbrella with the duck handle (sounds fab by the way) because I liked it and thought it was fun. I feel sad when you criticise what i buy" or the croissants "Should I not buy them again, you don't seem to like them ?"

I'd try to speak to her more generally in a neutral situation when she isn't making these remarks "You might not notice it, but you make a lot of critical comments about what I say and do. I don't know if you mean it, but I want to do less for you and it makes me unhappy."

That's probably not the right wording, but I'd first try to get her to notice what she is doing.

"I tell it as it is" = "I don't actually give a shit about anyone else or their feelings"

This is really helpful for framing tricky conversations https://dbt.tools/interpersonal_effectiveness/dear-man.php

I work with someone like this and it’s exhausting- so it must be so hard to live with one. Everything is negative and you have to constantly jolly along, so the “I’ll be fun” thing.

im not sure how to advise you as I could not have married someone like this. Is there anything she’s positive about?

DH is like this and it really sucks the energy out of a person. It’s really not nice and you have my sympathy.

Oh god, OP.

That sounds so hard to live with. Where's the joy?

Are there any aspects where your wife is positive, supportive, joyful?

I feel for you. People CAN overcome being critical and negative, but they have to be aware of it and want to.

You sound lovely and caring, btw.

Both late 30s. When we first met she used to joke that we were like Grumpy and Happy from Snow White and the Seven Dwarves but it was nowhere to this extent!

Sometimes I really don't know what to make of it. The accusatory "questions" sometimes feel like they're said to goad me into saying something back?

Like with the dog example, there was once where she "asked" something similar, I replied with something along the lines of "no I just went all the way to the dog park to get some coffees for us" and I was psychoanalysed and called sensitive because I probably insecure and had a bad week at work (I didn't) when I was really just sick and tired of the "questions"!!

This sounds really draining.
One of my relatives sounds similar but I don't live with her. Having that negativity everyday would be so hard.

Oh, this sounds awful and so deflating. You should leave her and come live with me. I love those duck-handled umbrellas, and would be so excited to be brought coffee and croissants and nice face masks. How bout it?

Could you calm her out on it every single time it happens? Oh living up to the grumpy name again are we? Oh here comes grumpy? Etc etc if she then gets fed up of being called grumpy all the time this will only highlight just how often she takes the grumpy approach to everything.

I don’t even understand the dog walking “question / statement / accusation” thing.
I would feel patronised as hell for any former asking if I, a grown adult and the actually dog walker, had walked the dog properly. I would have long since told her not to ask and if she didn’t respect that, it would have escalated to the mother of all rows long before now.

This isn’t just a negative outlook, it’s downright nastiness. Ain’t got time for that.

I couldn't cope with that. It sounds a little bullying. I'd be tempted to fire back every time.

"How do you know I didn't take the dog for a walk?"
"Ok then give me back the croissant."
"I'm not too old for the umbrella. You are, because you look older than me. I can pull it off."

However, that might stop the bitchiness but it not be the best way to help the marriage.

Same

I hate the line ‘I tell it as it is’ people seem to be under the delusion it makes them brave or admirable but actually, it just makes them a bit of a dick.

Sorry to say it, but she has gone off you. You need to either leave or sit down and point out that the relationship is not sustainable with her behaving like this and you must come up with a plan of action to change it. I'm afraid I am not hopeful that someone can reignite the feelings necessary to reinstate respect though. If she's lost it, it's probably gone for good.