We already have evidence of the harm that female people experience with the inclusion of this sub group of male people. It is the additional numbers of female people harmed.
Hence we asked for the number of additional female people you consider acceptable and Stolen replied they found 31 additional female people harmed acceptable. I am sure that the two girls raped by Dolatowski will feel that Stolen’s reply was fair. I am sure that the women staying in the female only hostel where Dolatowski lied to get residency would also believe it was fair.
31 is apparently the number. I expect we already have passed that. Considering how few sexual abuses are even reported.
How many girls were in that changing room that the male swimming official walked through because the swimming organisation running the completions didn’t think a male person needed to be told that even if they considered themselves a woman, it didn’t mean they could access a changing room full of girls bouncing into competitive swimwear. This, of course, was not reported to the police because the policy was unclear at the time.
It doesn’t need to be reported for there to be harm, of course. We have had several posters tell us about historic events where males with trans identities even decades ago exposed themselves in the female toilets. Or were wanking in the mirrored communal basin area. I really think 31 has well and truly been passed.
There was the rape in the NHS hospital in the past year or two where the NHS Trust staff told the woman she wasn’t raped as there were no male people on the ward that night. After significant public pressure, turns out there was, the staff gaslighted the woman because they deemed that rapist’s privacy more important than the raped woman’s needs. She was raped by someone registered at the hospital as eligible for a female ward who was male with a trans identity. The woman collecting the accounts from other raped women on hospital wards ended up with over one thousand rapes by male people here in the UK. Never investigated apparently or publicised before. With the statistics we already know, there will be a % of those male people also belonging to the sub group who have trans identities. But we will never have an actual figure, none of those women expected to get justice and they will not. Doesn’t mean it didn’t happen though.
Then there was the women reporting the male prisoner who like to masturbate in the shower with the curtain open while making eye contact with any female prisoner coming into the
space. When a female prisoner reported this she was sanctioned herself. Of course, no other female prisoner at that time felt they could report their abuse.
The harm is happening. Despite the denials that a few bad people shouldn’t mean all from a subgroup are excluded. Strong safeguarding looks at the risk of harm and DOES exclude whole groups from spaces when it is felt a legitimate aim. That is the very basis of having those sex segregated spaces in the first place. It is not that hard to understand.
The constant mantraing of TWAW is there to obfuscate the fact they are not female. And the spaces they are using are female single sex spaces. They retain the same risk of committing sex crimes as all other male people and should therefore be excluded.