To ask your opinion on these chairs?

[rainbowpuppy]

We ordered the table and chairs in the second photo, I had my heart set on chairs with knockers.
The correct table arrived but they send the chairs in the second photo accidentally.
They have offered to either replace the chairs with the ones we originally ordered within 10-14 days, or if we keep the chairs sent in error they will send us £120. Which do you prefer? Do you think the knocker chairs look smart?

I like the knockers ones.

I’ve seen them in restaurants, they are horrid to look in real life too. But they are damn comfy.

I don't like either but prefer the ones with the knockers on them

OP

It doesn't matter what anyone here thinks.

What do YOU think?

If you want the chairs with the knockers, get the chairs with the knockers!

If everyone liked the same thing, the world would be a very boring place. Remember, MN is a tiny echo-chamber, so please don't worry that not everyone on here would pick them.

They look to me like they'd be in a (very highly decorated, expensive) caravan.

Not my vibe for either.

But definitely better sans knocker.

Eek that’s hard, I can’t decide what’s worse, the knockers or the quilting, I think thr chairs you originally wanted are better, but the knockers ruins them, but I’m not sure I could stand to look at that quilting,

I think I’d go for the knocker’s as for some reason you really wanted that.

Dislike chairs with knockers. Makes me think Titanic. I would like the replace my but hate the studs. Makes me think pirate.

Without knockers are better