Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there shouldn't be measles outbreaks?

897 replies

fatandhappy47 · 20/01/2024 06:39

Surely we shouldn't be having an issue with measles?
Had an email from school (secondary) 'reminding' us to keep kids off with measles, which got me thinking

All my kids band my friends kids of the same age had their MMR (however my youngest did get measles before this)

So why is it an issue in secondary schools of all places? Are people just not vaccinating their kids?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
27
sashh · 25/01/2024 02:41

Dutch1e · 24/01/2024 13:24

I agree that 'Russian Roulette' isn't a good fit but I'm not so sure about the orders of magnitude smaller bit

Yes, you're completely correct across large numbers of people that measles, for example, is more risky than vaccine side-effects.

But on an individual level any specific medical event/outcome has either a 0% chance of happening or a 100% chance of happening. When we talk about chances and probability it really only applies to broad populations, never to just one person. To just one person it's binary.... A particular outcome either will happen or it will not.

So you can scorn someone's risk assessment capabilities all day, no problem. But you can't insist that they, personally, have a 0.0001% chance of X event happening as it's just not how it works.

That's not how it works. Stats or medicine.

The whole point of vaccination IS to produce a reaction.

Vaccine damage is an adverse reaction. And it is not binary. Many children will have a temperature and be a bit grumpy. That's an adverse reaction but not one that is permanent.

Vaccine damage can be devastating, it can also be any stage in between.

The same for measles, it can be a mild childhood disease or it can be devastating and any stage in between.

threatmatrix · 25/01/2024 09:13

I had the measles jab as a baby I’m now 58, my mother was wondering why she was getting a letter fro Great Ormond Street every year enquiring if I’d got the measles or not. She investigated it and found out I was one of the first so I was used as a guinea pig.
I had both my sons vaccinated but separately as I don’t think putting 3 things into a tiny baby makes sense. My first born was no problem because there was no hoo haa about it and had it separately through the NHS, seven years later when I asked for my second son to have it separately I was told no, in no uncertain terms. I went privately and paid for it.

threatmatrix · 25/01/2024 09:22

London, Birmingham that largest immigrant areas.

GotMooMilk · 25/01/2024 10:15

@threatmatrix why would you want your baby to have three separate injections when they could just have one and be done? That makes far less sense to me!

toomanyleggings · 25/01/2024 10:22

Not to play devils advocate but I remember seeing some news stories around 2021 saying that parents weren’t talking their kids for the jabs. I was quite annoyed because at that moment I was pestering my gp for an appointment for dd. I had rang them as I knew that she was due and they’d said they’d call with an appointment. Christmas came and went and no call. Kept getting fobbed off and in the end rang my health visitor who rang them and got us booked in. It shouldn’t have been that hard. Lots of kids just won’t have parents that will be bothered if the nhs makes it that hard for them.

Peregrina · 25/01/2024 10:23

why would you want your baby to have three separate injections when they could just have one and be done?

It could be that in the early 1980s they didn't have a mumps vaccine. I don't know when it was introduced. The German Measles one wasn't given until girls were about twelve. So one measles vaccine was considered enough.

thing47 · 25/01/2024 10:50

your view is dont cross the road because to the person who gets hit it's 100% going to happen

Yes @jannier people don't understand the difference between relative risk and actual risk.

DD was doing her (related) Masters during Covid times and her supervisor used the example of the risk of being hit by lightning. Of course it is A risk, but no one looks out of their house on a calm, dry day and says 'oh I'm not going to go to the shops/walk the dog today as I might be hit be lightning.'

CruCru · 25/01/2024 11:56

This is an interesting thread. It’s prompted me to ask my doctor if I can be vaccinated against mumps (I had both measles and rubella as a child but never mumps). I’ll see what they come back with once they’ve looked at the Econsult.

sashh · 27/01/2024 05:37

threatmatrix · 25/01/2024 09:13

I had the measles jab as a baby I’m now 58, my mother was wondering why she was getting a letter fro Great Ormond Street every year enquiring if I’d got the measles or not. She investigated it and found out I was one of the first so I was used as a guinea pig.
I had both my sons vaccinated but separately as I don’t think putting 3 things into a tiny baby makes sense. My first born was no problem because there was no hoo haa about it and had it separately through the NHS, seven years later when I asked for my second son to have it separately I was told no, in no uncertain terms. I went privately and paid for it.

So when you were weaning did you only offer your baby one food?

Scaevola · 27/01/2024 08:52

sashh · 27/01/2024 05:37

So when you were weaning did you only offer your baby one food?

Introducing one food at a time was standard weaning advice when mine were that age.

threatmatrix · 27/01/2024 15:52

sashh · 27/01/2024 05:37

So when you were weaning did you only offer your baby one food?

Are you for real. Is food a man made synthetic drug. Has food been accused of causing autism. Have you taken your meds.

MyopicBunny · 27/01/2024 16:10

Oh we're back to the autism is caused by vaccines claptrap. 🙄

MyopicBunny · 27/01/2024 16:12

@threatmatrix actually when my dc was very little, there were people who did believe that autism was caused by food. Perhaps you don't remember the hoo-ha about gluten and casein.

threatmatrix · 27/01/2024 16:28

MyopicBunny · 27/01/2024 16:10

Oh we're back to the autism is caused by vaccines claptrap. 🙄

Sorry I didn’t see where you got your science degree

MyopicBunny · 27/01/2024 16:29

I don't need a science degree. I listen to the people that do have one though. Unlike you, it seems.

pointythings · 27/01/2024 16:30

@threatmatrix I trust you are aware that the scientific consensus, agreed by people with degrees in things like immunology and neurology, is that the MMR does not in fact cause autism? Or had that snippet passed you by? 'Vaccines cause autism' is indeed claptrap.

threatmatrix · 27/01/2024 16:37

I prefer to read thesis by credited scientists that are not paid by big pharma you know ones like Dr Malone and Dr Malhotra.

pointythings · 27/01/2024 16:57

Ah, 'Big Pharma'.

Reckon I can call Bingo now.

Sweden99 · 27/01/2024 17:11

threatmatrix · 27/01/2024 16:37

I prefer to read thesis by credited scientists that are not paid by big pharma you know ones like Dr Malone and Dr Malhotra.

I worked in vaccine development. I was working well into the evening during Covid. My best friend worked himself into the ground on RNA vaccines. My sister worked long hours in ICU, and did so for far too long when people would not get vaccinated.
Are you saying that you know more about it that we do? i.e. that we are all utterly negligent and you are way smarter?
Or are you saying we are complicit in some global mass murdering conspiracy?
Or are you a narcissistic waste os space who cannot cope with not being hte expert and it not being about you?

All good, just let me know which one?

phlebasconsidered · 27/01/2024 17:38

I didn't have any vaccinations as a child after an adverse reaction to the first one hospitalised me as a child in the 70s. I remember going to hospital at about age 7 to have tests to see if I could have them and ended up ill again so i'm completely unvaccinated. My gp has ascertained i've already had mumps, whooping cough, rubella, and chicken pox as a child but we are currently deciding whether I should get the measles jab, given that i'm classed as vulnerable and am a teacher in a huge secondary.

I have since developed (over 52 years) 5 autoimmune disorders (Graves, Hashimotos, Reynauds, Granuloma annulares, Lupus)so it's evident that it's an issue for me. My latest arrival arrived after my covid vaccine, which also made me very ill, but also likely saved my life!

My son had the first vaccination as a baby, i think it was pertussis? Also ended up in hospital.

With guidance from the gp he was vaccinated with single vaccines (which i paid for) and even these made him ill but he managed and he's since been fine. My daughter is rock solid and didn't have any reaction so had the grouped vaccines. Although weirdly, she was extremely ill after the hep vaccine at school as a teen, and has since developed an autoimmune disorder.

I do think those with autoimmune family history probably need a bit more support with vaccines but i'd never, ever not do it- I had friends who were left disabled by polio. Although it's not, to my knowledge, been researched, my family has a history of autoimmune disorders (i have photos of Victorian relatives with goitres and my own mum has 4 varieties) and I think theres something in it, although i accept my own experience as anecdotal.

The vaccines offered at my school also had low teenage uptake, so I think we can expect a surge in hpv and cervical issues too, sadly.

pointythings · 27/01/2024 17:58

@phlebasconsidered it is to protect people like you and your family that the rest of us should get bloody vaccinated!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page