Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry another MIL dilemma!

123 replies

JDAJ · 12/06/2023 14:38

Hello all just after others people's perspectives on this. Ive always found my MIL a bit prickly. Just to give some context my first memory when I was seeing DH was her storming into the lounge after I had done the washing up shouting 'who did the washing up? ' I replied meakly that it was me and she said 'I hate people who put wet washing up on top of dry washing up' and stormed off. I remember thinking at the time I'd never marry my husband because I'd have her as a MIL..well here we are! Anyway it's been much of the same sort of prickly comments ever since but I've brushed them aside because I really want our sons to have their family around them and they love it when they see their grandparents. However since her husband passed away she's on her own and now comes and stays every weekend. Now I am all for this, as I said I love the idea of her being a big part of our children's lives, however I am just getting worn down with the comments and feeling like I'm not good enough, not only in her eyes but in general. She makes me feel like I'm not doing enough or I'm failing at parenthood /life. My mums petrified of her so tends to avoid coming over if she's here. My husband tends to hide or goes off to do something else leaving me to look after her. (He spent his life at boarding school so they don't have a close relationship, he's had counselling in the past to overcome some issues with his lack of a relationship with her which has helped him but he now just completely ignores her! She never calls him she calls or texts me). I really don't want to have a confrontation with her because I think it will cause upset and I honestly don't think she knows any different or maybe she doesn't realise how she's coming across (plus I'm also petrified of her). Sometimes I think I'm being too sensitive, am I? Yesterday when she was here the comments included
'who did the washing up' (me) ' 'you've not done a very good job'.
'Are you going to feed your poor dog' (looking at a fat Labrador drooling')
'You really need to wash your car it's filthy'
Talking about electric cars 'it would be terrible if you ever got one, you need to be organised to keep it charged up'. It's hard to get across how she says it but it's like an attack or dressing down each time.
I honestly think she just does not like me. I've got to the point where I'm going to have to reduce how often she comes over but how do I ignore her when she is here! It's just so annoying because she is self sabotaging herself, I'd love nothing more than to have her around but she can't seem to bite her tongue.

OP posts:
AtlasPine · 12/06/2023 14:41

You need to sit her down and tell her all this. And if she doesn’t apologise and improve, stop allowing her to ruin your weekends. Sounds dreadful.

Nordicrain · 12/06/2023 14:41

Why are you ok with a woman who constantly criticises you, and who your husband avoids, coming to live with you every weekend? I would absolutely not be up for that. What does your husband say about it all (or is he too busy hiding)? What is the purpose of doing this?

Isolationendurance · 12/06/2023 14:41

Your husband hasn't really made progress if he outsourced the relationship to you. That needs to change. He needs to be around more and be the point of contact if she's to continue being in your lives as you're suffering.

You need to either nip the comments in the bud firmly or reduce contact.

SnapPop · 12/06/2023 14:42

Your husband has got a massive cheek hiding while she's here and leaving you to deal with her! I would be furious with him if he even did that once let alone every time!! He's got to step in here and with tell her to stop coming every weekend (maybe once a month?) or he has to be there with you, standing up for you whenever she makes these comments.

ThatWriterInTheCorner · 12/06/2023 14:42

Honestly, I would just stop welcoming this awful bully into your house for a while. I understand that you want your children to have a close relationship with their grandparents, but what are they learning from seeing your MIL be rude and horrible to you with no consequences? If your DH doesn't like you dis-inviting her, then he can come out of his man-cave and entertain her himself.

Pusillanimouswitch · 12/06/2023 14:42

No, you’re not being sensitive, she is being rude! It’s a shame because an ideal scenario would be to say to her very directly, even though you are rude to me a lot, I value you and want you to be around and spend time with your grandchildren, maybe you don’t realise how it comes across but you are really rude to me, and it’s such a shame you are doing this! However I would be incapable of such a conversation. It’s almost like she’s goading you to push her away so she can feel hard done by. Very odd.

Aquamarine1029 · 12/06/2023 14:44

My god, op. Stop being a doormat. Having this vile woman around is a terrible example for your kids.

She would no longer be welcome in my home. She's fucking horrible.

Curseofthenation · 12/06/2023 14:45

Your DH needs to suck it up and tell her to reduce her visits to once a month. She sounds awful.

I would also be booking in some things for you to do (shopping trip, hobby activity etc) whenever she is scheduled to visit. It isn't your problem that DH doesn't have a close relationship with her.

Londoner89 · 12/06/2023 14:46

OP with all due respect, you and your husband (especially your husband!) need to grow a pair and tell her to change her ways or she will be spending a lot of weekends alone. List off these things she has done, you could even say something to the effect of “make sure you are an Angel before you go criticising everyone else/me, you do realise you’re terrible at washing up and leave bits of food on the plate, you leave wet towels here..etc etc, just anything that she does that you could nit pick on if you were that way inclined.
you say you are tolerating her for your children but is this really the woman you want around them? Do you want them to see you staying quiet and condoning this? What if she starts picking at them when they are a bit older? I’m sorry but shame on your husband for checking out and allowing you to put up with this, the man had to have therapy because of her yet is fine for you to deal with her?!

Mumsnut · 12/06/2023 14:47

What will you do when she starts criticising your children to their faces?

WeightInLine · 12/06/2023 14:48

YABU - every weekend?! And DH doesn’t even help?!

This is ridiculous. Hand her, entirely to DH.

mondaytosunday · 12/06/2023 14:49

Ok do your husband is a total wimp and I wouldn't let him get away with disappearing. Also there's no need for her to come round every weekend - you could suggest your husband take your kids there on occasion. Or maybe suggest she's has them on her own so you and hubby can go away!
And when she speaks to you like that, how do you reply? If she's being rude to you I wouldn't treat her with kid gloves!
'You haven't done a very good job' 'Oh you don't think so? Well it's my house and I think I did fine. You are welcome to do it next time.'
'Are you going to feed your dog?' 'No he's on a schedule and needs to lose weight due his health so is not allowed snacks'
'You need to wash your car.' 'Well that's (your husband) chore - you can tell him.'
'Electric cars' 'I agree, you do have to be organised but it doesn't take that much effort.'
Basically have a reasonable answer for everything.
Stop having her around every weekend.
Get your husband to deal with her - he may not have much of a relationship with her growing up but you had NO relationship with her!

DontBePassiveAggresive · 12/06/2023 14:49

My husband tends to hide or goes off to do something else leaving me to look after her

why on earth do you put up with this?
Cut it back to every other weekend for starters. And tell husband directly that he is responsible for her when she comes over.
Everytime she says something rude say something like "ouch that wasn't very nice" you have to do it everytime. She will either learn to shut up or won't want to come over anymore.

Crikeyalmightey · 12/06/2023 14:51

Aquamarine1029 · 12/06/2023 14:44

My god, op. Stop being a doormat. Having this vile woman around is a terrible example for your kids.

She would no longer be welcome in my home. She's fucking horrible.

What Aquamarine said. Don't have her in Your home. And tell your husband to grow a pair.

Whenwillitallmakesense · 12/06/2023 14:51

Your kids can still have a relationship with her without seeimg her evrry weekend, all weekend.
And your kids ate going to grow up thinking its perfectly OK to treat mum like shit being around this all the time.
Tell your husband that his mum is only allowed to come visit if he is present too snd that he he has to tell his mum that that won't be every weekend.
You start making weekend plans with your own mum and your husband can take kids to go visit his mum in her own home.
Stop being a bloody doormat and acting as if you have no say on how you spend your time. With who and how they are allowed to treat you.

Maxiedog123 · 12/06/2023 14:53

Why on earth do you think it is a good idea for this awful woman to be spending so much time around your children? What will they be learning from watching her bullying you?

DisforDarkChocolate · 12/06/2023 14:53

Why are you imposing this woman on your family every weekend? I honestly think you have lost your mind.

Febreezefantastic · 12/06/2023 14:55

You could just reply "OK" and play MIL bingo in your head or with your friends.

Or just tell her to do it herself if you are not scared of standing up for yourself.

Or just stop inviting her more than once a term!

standardduck · 12/06/2023 14:56

That sounds awful.

I wouldn't want her making comments like that in front of my kids. She is constantly putting you down.

I think your kids can have a relationship with her without her staying over every weekend. That sounds honestly overbearing even if she was a kind, nice MIL. She sounds like a bully though.

I would stop inviting her over or reduce the frequency massively (although I would really not want to have anyone who speaks to me like that in my house). Can you do day out with her and kids instead of her staying over?

SophieStew · 12/06/2023 14:56

I barely know where to begin…

Why is she coming every weekend? Stop that nonsense immediately.

If she comes round, it MUST be when DH is available.

If she’s rude, tell her “wow, that was rude!” If she gets the hump and fucks off, that’s a result.

You are wrong thinking it’s good for your children to have a relationship with her just because she’s family. She’s bloody horrible to you, so she shouldn’t be around your DC. It’s your job to protect them from this kind of shit, not to expose them to it.

Topseyt123 · 12/06/2023 14:57

For god's sake grow some balls and stop being so wishy-washy towards her.

Why on earth do you want to have this dreadful woman in your home? Put a stop to these visits. You are allowing her to abuse you in your own home. Stop that. Your children do not need to witness this shit.

Either stop the visits completely (I would) or limit them to once a month or every couple of months. If she then walks in and criticises jobs you have done/not done then tell her that she can either do them herself or (preferably) leave.

StopMindlesslyScrolling · 12/06/2023 14:58

Nope.

There is no excuse for her to be this rude to you in your home when you are the one making all the effort.

If your DH isn't bothered about seeing her then don't invite her; do not let your children grow up seeing their mother belittled or they'll believe it's normal for women to be treated that way.

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 12/06/2023 14:59

Stop inviting her every weekend, it's not benefiting your kids having a toxic person around them.
Keep it once every 3/4 months if not longer. And for the love of god stick up for yourself! My MIL can be the same, since I've started to bite back she's really reeled in her stupid comments.

PuffinsRocks · 12/06/2023 15:01

You have a DH problem.

Dragonsandcats · 12/06/2023 15:02

You need to stop inviting her over!