Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Job adverts without salary details

176 replies

stillnotworkingout · 23/05/2023 18:34

I'm finding these infuriating and it's putting me off even applying for jobs that otherwise look a good fit for me.

It makes me feel that if the company can't be transparent about salary, what kind of organisation are they otherwise?

I don't want to apply for numerous jobs only to find out it would never be financially viable for me to take up an offer.

Is there ever a benefit to potential employees of this type of advert?

Am I missing something and being unreasonable to not even apply?

OP posts:
theadultsaretalking · 23/05/2023 22:24

I am actively looking for a job right now and the job titles in my industry are highly misleading/inconsistent. I need to see the salary range to know the job level.

Less than 40% of job ads list the salary range and it boils my piss!

And do fuck off with the cycle-to-work scheme as a perk. Pay me well and I will buy the bloody bike myself (should I want one!)

theadultsaretalking · 23/05/2023 22:32

Just realised that I might come across as a little bit angry 😂. I am actually a very level-headed and calm person normally. Just really fed up!

OnlyFannys · 23/05/2023 22:35

theadultsaretalking · 23/05/2023 22:32

Just realised that I might come across as a little bit angry 😂. I am actually a very level-headed and calm person normally. Just really fed up!

Totally justified anger

Biscuitmonster2318 · 23/05/2023 22:41

That is where I have been going wrong. My last job after I accepted it and was getting excited etc a waiting to start. Also waiting for the moment HR would have that discussion with me regarding salary. Clearly I was so excited about actually getting a job after years at Uni and all that debt
finally feeling like an adult and very proud of myself! The naïveté showing even then.
i signed contracts and handed in all my documents and registration papers and documents needed for my job. Still waiting for the discussion around salary.
Still waiting for the discussions to happen and assumed the HR department was just super busy with new starters etc
When I was asked what point I had been started at and what my salary would be.
I had to just stare blankly and change the subject quickly.
until I received my first salary payment in to my account I actually had no idea what I was getting paid. But as I was paid monthly I had to work all of September and all October before my first payment.
But by the time I realised no conversation from HR would occur and every one who had started around the time I did had already discussed that and knew their salary. I was too embarrassed to confess 😂😂😂

dontwaitup · 23/05/2023 22:50

I don't apply for these jobs. Invariably it means the salary is so poor they don't want to highlight it.

Frabbits · 23/05/2023 22:56

GoldenRetriever4 · 23/05/2023 19:57

I’m a senior manager and company director. We never provide salary information in job adverts as we find it just attracts money grabbers.

Pay is only one part of what makes an employer attractive in our view and we offer a fantastic culture and benefits package. We also tailor our salary offer highly to the candidate so giving a band would make no sense.

We need to focus our resources where they have most impact. We will push the boat out for John the sales director at a big competitor. Barbara on reception does not make a material difference to our performance as a business, so will receive an offer below market.

"Money grabbers".

People work for money. They don't want your shitty free fruit or other crap you pass off as benefits. What you are doing is disuading people who know their worth - like me - from wasting our time applying.

OnlyFannys · 23/05/2023 22:56

Biscuitmonster2318 · 23/05/2023 22:41

That is where I have been going wrong. My last job after I accepted it and was getting excited etc a waiting to start. Also waiting for the moment HR would have that discussion with me regarding salary. Clearly I was so excited about actually getting a job after years at Uni and all that debt
finally feeling like an adult and very proud of myself! The naïveté showing even then.
i signed contracts and handed in all my documents and registration papers and documents needed for my job. Still waiting for the discussion around salary.
Still waiting for the discussions to happen and assumed the HR department was just super busy with new starters etc
When I was asked what point I had been started at and what my salary would be.
I had to just stare blankly and change the subject quickly.
until I received my first salary payment in to my account I actually had no idea what I was getting paid. But as I was paid monthly I had to work all of September and all October before my first payment.
But by the time I realised no conversation from HR would occur and every one who had started around the time I did had already discussed that and knew their salary. I was too embarrassed to confess 😂😂😂

Was the salary not stated in the contract?

dontwaitup · 23/05/2023 22:57

@shadowofadoubt I totally agree with your comment and I am amazed that someone can be so clueless as to say that out loud about their own staff.
For a start anyone with any decent client based experience knows that how a receptionist handles calls and visitors makes a big difference.
I work for a company where the CEO is a groundbreaking leader. He honestly recognises and values everyone's contribution and it shows in how he runs the business. As a result people work hard for him.

EddieHoweisMYmanager · 23/05/2023 23:03

Imagine the arrogance of someone who calls other who go to work for the most money they can get, ‘money grabbers’. I suppose you work for claps and high praise and pay your mortgage with your free tea and coffee aye?

Starseeking · 23/05/2023 23:44

LaurieFairyCake · 23/05/2023 21:30

Good god, I don't give a FLYING FUCK about benefits and culture

I've worked 33 years and not one benefit has ever been of benefit to me:

Company car - never wanted one
Cycle to work scheme - fuck off
Free tea and coffee - shittest coffee, I went round the corner

Private health care - NEVER used it

It's ALL BOLLOCKS - money is the MOST important thing to me

I go to work to pay my fucking massive mortgage not dick about hoping for a free Friday cunting biscuit 🍪

Tell it like it is lol love it!

Biscuitmonster2318 · 24/05/2023 01:04

No it wasn’t just that is negotiable with experience and qualifications. It was a job where there is a set pay scale. Where you start is what is negotiated.
Unfortunately I didn’t realise that the conversation should have started after being offered the job and before I accepted the contract 😂

Speedweed · 24/05/2023 07:16

@LaurieFairyCake I wish I worked with you, you sound great!

All so true!!!

Can I add 'collegiate culture'? Do I care about this - no, because every colleague would recommend me for redundancy ahead of them, as would I them if it came to it! We'd happily watch each other go under the bus and stand there waving.

Aprilx · 24/05/2023 07:21

I joined the workforce in 1992 and job advertisements in my field of work, which is accountancy, rarely have salaries. They generally don’t like to broadcast it, however the ballpark is quickly established as soon as talks begin. It is really no big deal.

Peashootpetra · 24/05/2023 07:25

So annoying - got a friend who works for the I am what I am airline, always plugging them on linked in and not one job she promotes has salary listed 🤔

Phineyj · 24/05/2023 07:54

@Aprilx has just really clearly shown how in her industry at that time, secret cultural capital was required to get a decent offer.

That is exactly the kind of thing that excludes "non traditional" applicants. You don't know what you don't know.

Butchyrestingface · 24/05/2023 08:10

Rightly or wrong, I chalk companies up who aren't transparent about salaries on the job ad as cynical and exploitative and probably not organisations I'd want to work for.

SaltyCrisps · 24/05/2023 08:13

Drives me mad as well, but seems to be increasingly common.

gamerchick · 24/05/2023 09:15

GoldenRetriever4 · 23/05/2023 21:31

We provide a fantastic range of benefits, including subsidised gym membership, on site restaurant, 4pm finish on Fridays and complimentary tea, coffee and fruit.

We find that many of our ‘workhorse’ staff like receptionists, admin staff etc really value these along with our friendly culture over an extra few quid down the road.

However, we do need to be able to pay above market rates to attract people into ‘superstar’ roles that make a big difference to the company.

I wonder if you know what you sound like with your posts. Anyone who looks down on the front of house staff doesn't sound like a good employer. Do you give your cleaners a box of chocolates for Christmas and a pat on your back afterwards?

Horrible to read that last bit of your first post. Poor buggers having that thought of them.

I don't bother with job adverts that rave about their excellent to work for company but don't put the wage in the advert. Just makes me think they're not very good employers.

GoodChat · 24/05/2023 09:16

Do you give your cleaners a box of chocolates for Christmas and a pat on your back afterwards?

You expect her to touch the peasants?!

ToeJammed · 24/05/2023 09:19

Goldenretrievers posts remind me of a poster a few years ago who apparently managed an office, where according to her, the staff were locked in while working and had to seek permission to leave even in an emergency, amongst other things 😂
Free tea, coffee and fruit? That's a benefit? Shit instant coffee too I bet.
I don't eat fruit, so you can shove that.
I don't do gyms either, so you can shove that with the fruit.
Friday's 16.00 finish? Wahey, crack out the crunchies.
Poor Barbara on reception, I don't even know the woman, but I feel sorry for her, does she know the higher uppers look down their conks at her, while throwing her the crumbs from their tables?
Never mind Barbara, here's a crap coffee and a bruised apple.
I wouldn't apply anywhere that doesn't state the salary either, or at least say salary negotiable. They're usually shit companies who want to drive you into the ground while paying what they think is a great salary!
Mind you, those bigwigs at the top don't drive those fancy cars and live in fancy houses due to paying the staff their worth.
Family culture? Hah...I've yet to see one big happy family workforce. It usually means we demand that you work on our terms only and any complaints will immediately go into file 13 ( bin ) any sickness will result in a disciplinary unless you're in a coma, in which case we expect you to phone in yourself. Being in a coma isn't a good enough excuse. You're letting the team down otherwise, after all, Barbara on reception has managed to drag herself to work every day for the last forty years, even when in labour.
Company car? Certainly, once you've worked here for ten years and managed to get promoted to area manager, then we'll bestow you with a crappy Corsa, with the company logo stamped all over it for free advertising of course.
Annual leave? We offer two days more than the law says we have to, to show our appreciation of your hard work. However, we do expect you to answer emails and phone calls. Yes, I know you're on your honeymoon, but we expect you to show commitment to your role. Don't worry, we provide a laptop and mobile so you can keep up with everything.
Gah!

gamerchick · 24/05/2023 09:21

GoodChat · 24/05/2023 09:16

Do you give your cleaners a box of chocolates for Christmas and a pat on your back afterwards?

You expect her to touch the peasants?!

Bet they don't get anywhere near the excellent 'benefits' either.

I'm just a bit gobsmacked at the utter contempt in this posts. Reception staff are vital to any company. Be right up shit creak without them imo.

TallulahBetty · 24/05/2023 09:27

Yeah, I'd immediately discount it.

The salary of a job is the ABSOLUTE MINIMUM you should get in exchange for your labour. If they can't even be transparent about that begore you apply....!

greennotepad · 24/05/2023 09:55

@GoldenRetriever4

Sadly I've met enough CEOs and MDs like you to think you are not on the wind-up.

Pay your staff properly ffs, and learn what the word benefit means- hint, its not free tea and coffee.

OCarumba · 24/05/2023 09:58

LetMeGoogleThat · 23/05/2023 18:39

I completely agree. It's rude! They wouldn't expect me to write that my skills are competitive, I want to know that the role is worth it and I'm sorry but salary is really important.

Exactly 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread