AIBU?
To not give up my Playmobil and cut cousins hands off if she tries to take it?
Qantaqa · 19/03/2023 13:15
Ok Ok .. the last part is possibly U....
I have an extensive collection of playmobil which has been boxed up for many years. I briefly got it out 10 years ago when my DSs were 7/8ish but after a particularly traumatising incident where they broke some I boxed it all back up and put it away and never got it back out. I say this to show that my attachment to it is frankly ridiculous.
My cousins daughter is 6. She is in many ways an mini version of me at that age and I adore her and obviously indulge her and am silly with her in ways her parents can't be. I (obviously) have been buying her Playmobil for birthdays and Xmas which she loves. My collection came up in a discussion at a birthday meal recently and cousins daughter asked if she could come over and play. I said it was boxed away and that was it.
Except it isn't. Cousin has asked about "getting some sets for her DC since I aren't using it". I've politely said various versions of no with excuses, but this morning I had this message,
Hey Q. Any more thoughts over the Playmobile? DC is beside herself with excitement ay the thought of having some of yours! We are out for Mothers Day this afternoon but I'll give you a bell later. xx
Clearly I need a stronger "No over my dead body" response but having moaned mentioned this to DM at lunch she thinks IABU to not "pass it down".
DB thinks I should just go buy a box off Facebook and hand that over which I am considering.
So AIBU to want to keep my Playmobil?
Am I being unreasonable?
AIBUYou have one vote. All votes are anonymous.
Pixiedust1234 · 21/03/2023 12:47
OnaBegonia · 21/03/2023 12:42
I never see the point in this keeping things never to be used, you're a long time dead as my granpa said, enjoy things whilst you can.
Not even let your own kids play with it is silly, it's plastic toys.
She IS enjoying them though. Just because she's not enjoying them how you would or how you feel she should doesn't mean her enjoyment isn't valid.
Lunde · 21/03/2023 13:20
toomuchlaundry · 21/03/2023 11:04
What enjoyment do people get from toy collections boxed up and never seen? Will it stay in boxes until you die? What poor sod is going to have to then decide what to with it. More than likely the children who were never allowed to play with or look at it!
What enjoyment does anyone get from collecting things? I mean -
- shouldn't you be making tea in the tea service from 1785? What use is a tea service in a china cupboard
- why not spend the coins in the coin collection?
- why not let the kids climb all over the wooden chair from 1810?
- put wine in the glass from 1697 and then stick it in the dishwasher
The fact is that people collect all sorts of things for their own pleasure - sometimes they are just for pleasure and are never worth much but sometimes they turn out to be very valuable (was watching Darth Vader toys from the 1980s on Antiques Roadshow)
toomuchlaundry · 21/03/2023 13:39
@lunde but most of those things are probably things you can see or get out to look at from time to time. OP (and others) have toys in boxes that are not looked at, and haven't even let their own children play with. And they wouldn't have been antiques when the children were small. Maybe, keep a couple of things separate if they were your favourite, but seems weird to not let your own children play with them and have no desire to let future grandchildren play with them.
DH's mum had his lego collection in her loft. When DS was old enough he was let loose on it, and then added to it. Same with toy cars. DH saw the pleasure DS got from them (and unleashed the inner child in DH when he got to play with them again). We have some lego models on display (not enough room for all of them). So yes we have things boxed up, but if we have children come to visit then we can get some of it out for them to play with (maybe keeping some of the precious stuff away) and if grandchildren come along then they may inherit a huge collection if they want it! But I can't imagine not having let DS get enjoyment from these toys. Much more enjoyment than them sitting in a box unseen by anyone.
We also got some Sylvanian Family items when DS was little, which were in his bedroom, caught MIL playing with them once when DS wasn't there! To be fair I can see us playing with the lego once DS is at university!
NailsForBreakfastTacksForSnacks · 21/03/2023 13:45
OnaBegonia · 21/03/2023 12:42
I never see the point in this keeping things never to be used, you're a long time dead as my granpa said, enjoy things whilst you can.
Not even let your own kids play with it is silly, it's plastic toys.
My Gran used to say,
You're a long time dead so surround yourself with things that make you happy..
And OP is.
SoMuchToBits · 21/03/2023 14:11
But as I said previously, the OP used to have her Playmobil on display until her dcs were born and she no longer had the space. So it's likely that when she has the space again in the future, she will get it out of the boxes and display it again. In the meantime she keeps it safely boxed up and put away so that none of it gets broken.
I can't see anything wrong with that!
TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 21/03/2023 14:15
toomuchlaundry · 21/03/2023 11:28
@whumpthereitis but wouldn’t the equivalent of someone who likes their boxed collection of playmobil be someone who enjoys camping but just having the tent in the loft until they die
No, because the key is their enjoyment, not your opinion on usage.
You still seem to be having a problem understanding that other people enjoy different things to you.
Millions of people have boxed/shelved collectors items - it's hardly unusual.
VaseWaterFlowers · 21/03/2023 14:19
someone who enjoys camping but just having the tent in the loft until they die
That's not so bad either. Having the tent in the loft may give them pleasure because they know that camping is an option to them because the tent is there. No tent = no camping.
Sometimes knowing you have a choice or an option is a pleasure in itself.
Pixiedust1234 · 21/03/2023 14:21
OnaBegonia · 21/03/2023 13:30
@Pixiedust1234
Enjoy? knowing it's locked up
in a cupboard? not even her own kids got a use of it. Likely the kids will chuck it the bin eventually.
Its not locked up. Its safely stored until she has time and space to use it. (Same reasoning as keeping money in a savings account - its for later use).
Having kids does not mean giving them everything of yours. Parents are allowed to keep things for just themselves.
She won't care if the kids throw it away as she will be dead.
Again, why is your view of enjoyment the only valid one. She IS enjoying them.
OnaBegonia · 21/03/2023 15:40
@NailsForBreakfastTacksForSnacks
The meaning of the saying is to enjoy and use things not 'keep for good/later', we've recently cleared an elderly relatives home, full of boxes of 'stuff' kept for good, savings kept for rainy days whilst living like a pauper, what was the point? no enjoyment was had.
NailsForBreakfastTacksForSnacks · 21/03/2023 16:01
OnaBegonia · 21/03/2023 15:40
@NailsForBreakfastTacksForSnacks
The meaning of the saying is to enjoy and use things not 'keep for good/later', we've recently cleared an elderly relatives home, full of boxes of 'stuff' kept for good, savings kept for rainy days whilst living like a pauper, what was the point? no enjoyment was had.
That might be the meaning of your saying, but the meaning of my Nans was to surround yourself with things that make you happy and to not give any fucks what anyone else thinks. Why should OP deprive herself of something that brings her joy because you think it's a waste?
How on earth could you possibly know what enjoyment that relative had? They could well have felt more content at just having it in a box somewhere.
You seem to lack an understanding that different people seek comfort and enjoyment from different things, be that a box of random stuff, a box of playmobil or a bank account full of cash.
Qantaqa · 21/03/2023 17:57
@watcherintherye I did manage to save him yes. Hes got a permalimp and would defo be the first picked off by predators but I'll make sure when he comes back out he's in a safe lion proof enclosure :)
My vague plan has been to get them back out if when the DSs leave and play with display them. I'd be fine with older people playing with them .. its youngish kids that give me the heebie jeebies so those wanting to come play there is an open invitation. Hopefully we can get @SoMuchToBits round to set us up holiday appropriate sets ;)
I actually off the back off this asked the DSs what they would do with it when I died - DS1 said he's going to leave it in a cupboard and tell his children never to touch it, and then tell them to tell their kids the same, and them theirs and so on and so on forever...... DS2 said he'd not thought about it but he likes DS1s idea.
SchoolTripDrama · 21/03/2023 19:06
Missingpop · 20/03/2023 19:31
The real reason your cousin wants to get her sweaty paws on it is because she knows it’s worth a few quid politely tell her to fuck off & that when they are sold on they will be sold for the benefit of you & yours not her & hers !!!
Sweaty paws? 
WTF 
Hawkins003 · 21/03/2023 20:13
SchoolTripDrama · 21/03/2023 19:06
Sweaty paws? WTF
Missingpop · 20/03/2023 19:31
The real reason your cousin wants to get her sweaty paws on it is because she knows it’s worth a few quid politely tell her to fuck off & that when they are sold on they will be sold for the benefit of you & yours not her & hers !!!
It's possible,
VaseWaterFlowers · 21/03/2023 20:45
DS1 said he's going to leave it in a cupboard and tell his children never to touch it, and then tell them to tell their kids the same, and them theirs and so on and so on forever...... DS2 said he'd not thought about it but he likes DS1s idea.
@Qantaqa DS1 is very funny. This is brilliant. made me chuckle.
myfaceismyown · 21/03/2023 21:11
My DH has a particularly rare sci-fi book he bought in a charity shop for a couple of quid over 20 years ago. In sci-fi circles it is incredibly rare and ridiculously valuable. After he found it he voluntarily donated £50 to the charity, which was surprising as he is normally very frugal. Its in our loft carefully stored. He likes to know he has it and that it increases in value. He will never sell it, he likes that he found it and owns it. It makes him very happy. No the DCS can't read it, but you only have to mention it and he beams with pride. We all need things that make us happy whatever they may be! if I go second I might just pop it in his urn....
snitzelvoncrumb · 22/03/2023 04:02
Qantaqa · 21/03/2023 17:57
@watcherintherye I did manage to save him yes. Hes got a permalimp and would defo be the first picked off by predators but I'll make sure when he comes back out he's in a safe lion proof enclosure :)
My vague plan has been to get them back out if when the DSs leave and play with display them. I'd be fine with older people playing with them .. its youngish kids that give me the heebie jeebies so those wanting to come play there is an open invitation. Hopefully we can get @SoMuchToBits round to set us up holiday appropriate sets ;)
I actually off the back off this asked the DSs what they would do with it when I died - DS1 said he's going to leave it in a cupboard and tell his children never to touch it, and then tell them to tell their kids the same, and them theirs and so on and so on forever...... DS2 said he'd not thought about it but he likes DS1s idea.
It sounds like it’s sorted! You don’t have to give away your toys. I have a cabbage patch kid I love. I would never give Lucy away.
AppleandSpice · 29/03/2023 10:10
GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 22/03/2023 08:35
I would lend it to the little girl but ask her to keep yours separate. You won't have to actually watch her like did for your own kids. She will probably grow of it fairly soon.
The reason op has it boxed up is because Firstly she doesn’t currently have anywhere to display it and secondly she doesn’t want it being played with as there is huge potential of it being lost and broken. So with that in mind, why would she ‘lend’ it to her niece?
or is it a case of, if the op can’t see it being played with then it will come back in immaculate condition? I highly doubt it.
These are vintage sets, the op wants to keep, nobody is entitled to have or even borrow them. There’s a difference between ‘just toys’ and a collection.
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.