Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my brother didn’t deserve to die

161 replies

Azurehawker · 25/02/2023 22:10

My brother died of an accidental drug overdose last month, he was 41 years old. When he died the attitude of a lot of people seems to be that this is what is expected when someone has been a heroin user most of their life, and it was choices he made that lead to his death so there is no one to blame for this but him. I have to admit that to me this felt almost inevitable given how he lived his life and part of me is angry that he let this happen.

Although he was once popular and well liked by the time he died he had few real friends left, some having died already or not been able to stay in contact with him in case it jeopardised their own attempts at staying off heroin. Some people just didn’t want to be around him anymore, by the time he was in his late 30s my brother was a very obvious drug user. If you met him you would probably label him as a ‘junkie’ straight away.

However he had managed to hold down a job and work most of his life. Although people knew about his drug addiction, they also knew he was a hard worker and respected him for that. He had some minor convictions for drug related crime although he had never been to prison or been convicted of a violent crime.

He openly admitted he had mental health problems, and was severely depressed. We knew that he spent his adult life trying and failing to beat his drug addiction and we tried to support him as best we could while not actually enabling him to continue taking drugs.

We had what you might call a ‘difficult’ childhood and my brother became a troubled teen, he didn’t do well at school, he got into fights and was involved with gangs, took party drugs, shoplifted etc. He and his friends were targeted by much older members of a county lines gang who introduced them to heroin, they all became addicts although many of them eventually got clean and went on to live normal lives.

When people ask how he died I sometimes lie and tell them the cause of death is ‘unexplained’ because telling them he died of a heroin overdose instantly labels him as a ‘junkie’ and in most people’s eyes a waste of space, undeserving of sympathy and respect, a person who’s life was worth nothing compared to someone who has bravely fought and lost their life to cancer or another more socially acceptable illness.

AIBU to believe that the death of my funny, kind and caring brother was a tragedy, that he was a person who was deeply depressed and damaged by a traumatic childhood, from the moment he was introduced to heroin he never really had a hope of beating drug addiction, although he tried. And that he didn’t deserve to live his life like this or to die.

OP posts:
LaughingCat · 25/02/2023 22:40

I am so, so sorry for your loss, @Azurehawker. You are obviously not being unreasonable. We’re all a product of choices, both good and bad, both of our own and of others. It sounds like you both suffered from plenty of others’ bad choices from the start…which is heartbreaking. Whatever his subsequent choices…he was always more than his addiction. He was a human being, with hopes and humour and love for those around him and he deserves to be mourned. He was your brother and you love him. Sending you all the love and strength at this time.

user80 · 25/02/2023 22:41

I’m so sorry for your loss OP. Your brother did not deserve what happened to him and neither did you deserve to lose him 💐

AlwaysGinPlease · 25/02/2023 22:41

I'm very sorry for your loss OP Flowers

LazingOnASundayAfternoon · 25/02/2023 22:43

I am so saddened to read of the loss of your brother. Addiction is so horrid. May he rest in peace x

evilharpy · 25/02/2023 22:43

No, he absolutely didn't deserve to die, or to have to live with addiction. I really believe that addiction could happen to any of us, if we all experienced the same set of circumstances that led to it. And help for mental health problems is shockingly poor. Nobody has the right to judge. I'm very sorry for your loss. Flowers

Twiggywinkle13 · 25/02/2023 22:44

I’m really sorry about your brother. That’s really tragic. It’s awful the way some folk treat people suffering from addiction. No one chooses addiction! Sending you so much love xx

Emelene · 25/02/2023 22:44

I’m so sorry for your loss.

My auntie died fairly recently of complications from alcohol abuse. She knew she would die if she kept drinking but still couldn’t or wouldn’t stop… It was so heartbreaking and difficult, the swirl of emotions is so sad.

quietnightmare · 25/02/2023 22:45

❤️

misslooloo · 25/02/2023 22:45

I’m so sorry OP. No. He absolutely did not deserve it.

Coffeellama · 25/02/2023 22:46

So sorry OP, I don’t no anyone who has died this way but it’s absolutely as much of a tragedy as anyone else who dies after a long illness. What happened wasn’t his fault, life wasn’t kind to him and it sounds like he fought it for as long as possible, despite huge mental health problems. Addiction might have been what killed him, but it wasn’t him and not everyone will assume negatively of him. So sorry for the loss of your brother OP

Clarissa111 · 25/02/2023 22:46

Oh I'm so very sorry. There for the grace of god go I.

My brother is a herion addict. He very nearly died from a burst artery, abd it sorted him out. He recovered and is now clean.
But no your brother didn't deserve to die.
I do understand why you don't want to tell people the truth though. People are so judgemental.
Noone really understands. Sending you love. X

Mermaidparades · 25/02/2023 22:47

I’m so sorry for your loss. The love and compassion you had for your brother shines through your post. He had an illness and he tried his best in difficult circumstances. He absolutely did not deserve to die. Much love to you as you process your grief xx

NotDrowningJustCrowing · 25/02/2023 22:48

Of course you're not being unreasonable. My brother was a heroin addict. He didn't die of an overdose but of an AIDS-related illness. Pneumonia we think. I always knew it was going to happen and it was both a relief that I'd no longer have to worry that it was going to happen and so bloody awful.

Anyone who judges your brother is unfair and needs to have a look at themself. Addiction doesn't make someone a bad person or not worthy of compassion. Judgey arseholes, on the other hand, are arseholes.

SemperIdem · 25/02/2023 22:48

It is terribly sad that your brother lost his life to addiction.

I find the ease many people write off drug addicts lives when they die, really upsetting.

They aren’t just “drug addicts” - they are people. People with parents, siblings, children, friends etc. Their deaths are not made less painful because addiction led to it. It is terrible the way people diminish others loss, when the person who died has been an addict.

Vloader23 · 25/02/2023 22:49

So sorry for your loss.

Thank you for sharing your story.

Shame on anyone who says or believes he was worth less because of his illness

dontgobaconmyheart · 25/02/2023 22:50

Very sorry for your loss OP. I think it's natural to want to defend your brother, or anyone that we love from what seem to be injustices or comments that we think don't do justice to the situation in all of its nuances. I lost a loved one to suicide last year in traumatic circumstances and have been blindsided by some of the cold perspectives and outdated and inhuman thoughts that people seem to have on what that means, or that they felt the need to bring it up. I have really had to learn (and am not yet there even) to focus only on what I know about that person, and how absolutely wonderful they were and how very and deeply unfair it was that they were not able to recover from the depression that plagued them. That loss has impacted every hour of my day and I presume always will and am now struggling myself in the face of the loss.

Our loved ones are seen best through the eyes of those of us that understood the soul of them, knew their worth in full terms and saw the best of them when they were dealt a hand that stacked odds against them. Those who are fortunate enough not to know what it's like to be the one walking that life, or to struggle with mental health and manage anything at all are never going to get it, and I suppose they don't really need to because the people that matter see the truth. If they knew him but didn't know him well enough to know all the wonderful little things that you know then they didn't know him well enough to matter. They knew what he was up to sure, but they didn't know him.

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 22:50

Also OP, statistically I would very much doubt the supposed friends’ claims that they became clean. The reality is so sadly in another of your sentences. More likely these ‘friends’ either cut down their use, managed to mask it better, and wanted societal praise. And as you said your brother managed to hold down a job and was a hard worker.

Ive worked with children in care for over a decade, unfortunately many of these scenarios, I may be completely wrong, but these statistics don’t fit my experience.

The ones who avoided him, they were likely fighting the same battle, and it’s true to not associate too much with people with the same issue except in safe settings.

If you’re tired of sharing, just say he was ill. Or the truth and to f*ck off, the only thing with this option is it may be hard for you to wish to justify despite yourself by spilling out your life history.

MH help is dismal,
Keep in mind the lovely memories (when you feel up to it, I have found a happy photo album helps, although it wasn’t addictions, but issues MH)

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 22:50

So sorry for your loss. The death of your brother is a tragic loss of a life where he was clearly loved.

He died from an illness, it so happened that illness was addiction, a cruel illness that targets those who are often already struggling. This is no more his fault than if he had died of cancer.

im so sorry you feel he is being judged. Those people aren’t the right people to have in your life atm.

you need time to grieve and remember the brother you love

please reach out and find some support.

I’ll be holding you and your brother in my thoughts

Nothing2lose · 25/02/2023 22:52

My brother is an addict. Not heroin as far as I’m aware but poly addict. He suffers from very poor mental health and potentially undiagnosed bipolar. He’s been to rehab twice.

If anything I’d call your brothers death a suicide. But perhaps that’s the way I see it to help me make sense of the things.

reading you brother has passed away brings me almost to tears. It is so incredibly hard. I’ve mourned the loss of the brother I used to know. Feel anger and pain weekly if not daily. His his isn’t and never will be easy and it terrifies me that he has to live with addiction daily. In times of relapse he has cried and begged to have this pain of a terrible mental illness/disease taken away and that he’d be better off dead.

I am so sorry for your loss. Gosh I’m now in tears, it really does bring such an emotional toll to your life that those who don’t live alongside addiction cannot truly understand.

Sending you lots of love.

Giggorata · 25/02/2023 22:52

I'm so sorry.
I lost siblings to addiction, too. Awful waste, tragic stories, pain. I don't always tell people because unless you've had this, it is difficult to understand, there are so many assumptions.
Of course he didn’t deserve it.
It sounds as though he knew you loved him.

NeedSomeSpace · 25/02/2023 22:53

So sorry for you OP

I used to volunteer at a soup kitchen and some of the visitors there were so troubled from trauma that they just didn't really stand a chance. Just like your brother, none of them deserved their crap hand and none deserved their addictions that stemmed from it. No one should be judging your brother, but we should be judging society in general, that we don't protect those children nor adequately support the teens and adults they become. Maybe that's why it's easier to judge the individual?

CrapBucket · 25/02/2023 22:53

I'm so sorry for your loss, and for your pain and for what your brother went through. Yanbu. Sending you love.

Cherryblossoms85 · 25/02/2023 22:57

I'm so sorry. I hope he is at peace now.

UdoU · 25/02/2023 22:57

My own brother died of addiction to prescription drugs at a similar age so I know how it feels. I felt helpless for much of adult his life.

However, having stayed away from drugs and alcohol and cigarettes away my whole life, to be what society deems a ‘good girl’, and having been burgled by drug addicts and had my home destroyed to an extent that I can’t even get fixed, I struggle to have much sympathy with drug addicts. I have my own problems to contend with.

Godlovesall26 · 25/02/2023 22:58

Nothing2lose · 25/02/2023 22:52

My brother is an addict. Not heroin as far as I’m aware but poly addict. He suffers from very poor mental health and potentially undiagnosed bipolar. He’s been to rehab twice.

If anything I’d call your brothers death a suicide. But perhaps that’s the way I see it to help me make sense of the things.

reading you brother has passed away brings me almost to tears. It is so incredibly hard. I’ve mourned the loss of the brother I used to know. Feel anger and pain weekly if not daily. His his isn’t and never will be easy and it terrifies me that he has to live with addiction daily. In times of relapse he has cried and begged to have this pain of a terrible mental illness/disease taken away and that he’d be better off dead.

I am so sorry for your loss. Gosh I’m now in tears, it really does bring such an emotional toll to your life that those who don’t live alongside addiction cannot truly understand.

Sending you lots of love.

I’m sorry to make a comment not directly related to thread, but as I’m bipolar II, rehab is completely ime pointless unless you sort out the root cause. Medications for bipolar have changed my life.