Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how your life would have been different if you had only had one child

172 replies

Sowetoutside · 19/09/2022 16:37

Obviously some people have chosen this and please do tell me why.

I always wanted two children but really struggling with TTC. I’m slowly coming round to the fact I may only have the one.

Im trying to think of the positives so hit me!

OP posts:
AliTheMinx · 19/09/2022 20:26

Squirrelonwheels · 19/09/2022 16:58

@AliTheMinx Totally agree re. lockdown - it was so tough for them not being able to interact with even one other child. Let’s hope never again.

@Squirrelonwheels Absolutely! I shudder at the mere thought of it! x

Choconut · 19/09/2022 20:26

I have a sibling, we hated each other from young and argued and fought all the time. The minute we were bored our first thing to do was wind each other up. It was awful for my mum. I have one, teenager now, it's been brilliant. Nothing in the world could make me wish I'd had another. No arguing, no fighting, I can give him all the time and financial help that he needs, we do lots together and it's wonderful.

userxx · 19/09/2022 20:28

Being an only child is great, I think I've massively taken for granted having their complete attention all my life.

Firemansamagain · 19/09/2022 21:18

Following with interest

Sowetoutside · 19/09/2022 21:37

Thank you.

I am coming round to the fact I may only have the one, he’s s absolutely lovely But I had him late in life, and I may just have missed the boat for no2.

I feel as if I didn’t really get to enjoy his babyhood properly as I was constantly worried and a bit depressed, and I have a real desire to do it again and enjoy this time! I also had him in lockdown.

But we would be able to afford private school for him (could probably manage for two but it would be a stretch) and there are many advantages.

OP posts:
AnnaBlush · 19/09/2022 23:12

Great thread. Thank you to all posters

TempsPerdu · 19/09/2022 23:53

We have just the one DD - mostly by choice, but we are older parents and although there were no fertility issues a second pregnancy would have been risky as I have large fibroids and my first pregnancy was complicated.

DD is 4 now, and has just started Reception. Already I’ve noticed that we are far more organised and ‘on it’ around school stuff than most of her peers with larger families. Her books are read and returned on time; she has all the appropriate equipment and clothing she needs when she needs it; forms/resources are sent in on time etc. I’m not an especially organised person, but having just the one means I can focus properly on getting this stuff done. DD was already reading fairly well before she started school because I had the time and energy to start teaching her phonics.

DD also has a lot more ‘cultural capital’ than most of her friends with siblings. Because we’re only paying for one child and there’s no need to compromise between competing developmental stages and interests, we take her everywhere that takes our fancy - the Postal Museum; Borough Market; the CBeebies Prom; the ballet. She’s been swimming with me regularly since the age of two, started formal lessons a while ago and is making excellent progress. She also does ballet and football every week, and we’re looking into Spanish lessons. The majority of her friends, meanwhile, have been largely stuck at home with their baby/toddler siblings, just playing with toys and pottering in the garden, because their parents are daunted by the idea of doing all this stuff with two kids. This is obviously not an issue per se (we do plenty of pottering too!) but now DD’s friends need to start branching out a bit some of them are now having real issues with trying new things and visiting new places (won’t get into the swimming pool etc)

We love travel (I studied Modern Languages at uni), and now DD is that bit bigger we are feeling ready to travel more widely and resume more adventurous holidays; most of our friends with younger siblings either can’t afford similar holidays or are very much still in the ‘It’s just not worth all the hassle!’ phase.

With all the current uncertainty in the world and the doom and gloom around young peoples’ prospects, I’m glad that we can focus all our resources on DD to set her up as well as we possibly can for whatever her future holds. She can aim for university if she wants to, safe in the knowledge that we’ll be able to support her through it, and hopefully the idea of getting on the property ladder one day will also be within her grasp.

I also never feel that guilt of having my attention pulled in too many different directions; DD always gets the best of me in terms of time, energy and input. Having stepped away from my career for a while to raise her, I’m hoping to retrain into a different area now she’s starting school - had I had a second it’s likely this wouldn’t have been an option (indeed, as an older mum I may well never have returned to work ‘properly’ at all). With one I’m more flexible, nimble and able to consider different options.

We’re very aware that there are also many challenges around having an only child - DD has no cousins either, and the ‘lonely only’ stereotype does sometimes loom large in my imagination. But I wish people were quicker to acknowledge the many positives of having just the one child, especially as smaller families increasingly become the norm, rather than resorting to the same old tired tropes around loneliness and social awkwardness (which all of the academic research seems to debunk anyway).

SolemnlySwear2010 · 20/09/2022 00:18

We only have 1 DD (half choice, half not) and we are settled with our decision.

We have enough money to do 'family things' most weekends - swimming, bowling, cinema, meals out etc without a thought.

Our DD attends an expensive hobby that we can easily afford and we still get 'us' time between myself and DH.

It works very well for us and although I still sometimes get pangs for another baby - it's exactly that. I want another baby, but not the upheaval of another toddler / child! It would mean one of us going part time due to childcare costs, my mental health would probably be a lot lower as I do not handle stress well and it would severely strain us financially.

DD is perfectly happy being an only child, so we have no plans to change this

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 20/09/2022 03:05

Idontknowwhatto · 19/09/2022 16:48

Much quieter, less fighting, less mess, more sleep.

pretty much, the chaos can be fun but mostly its tiring messy hard work. I'll add less laundry, and bigger gaps between the drama. Embrace the peace and dignity of having just the one if that's how it works out and don't distress yourself with might have beens.

Jetsun3456 · 20/09/2022 09:36

@TempsPerdu I could have written your post, I feel exactly the same

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 20/09/2022 09:39

Her books are read and returned on time; she has all the appropriate equipment and clothing she needs when she needs it; forms/resources are sent in on time etc.

Erm well most parents of more than one child can also manage this you know? And I know lots of single child parents who can't

AlwaysMunching · 20/09/2022 09:47

It's swings and roundabouts, there are benefits and drawbacks to every size/formation of family. It's natural to think about what might have been or how things might have been different, whether you have no children or six children!

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 20/09/2022 09:50

Well, I have a couple of friends with only children. I am amazing by the things they can achieve! Generally I find them far less frazzled than me, and much more able to faciliate what their child wants and needs to do. There is no conflicts with another child, and can do what is best for their one child always, without having to take another into consideration. I would think that's a pretty big bonus and is beneficial to both child and the parent.

Royalbloo · 20/09/2022 09:51

I love having one - we are a little team

AlwaysMunching · 20/09/2022 09:53

@TempsPerdu your post comes across as really smug. Parents of more than one child are capable of taking them to classes and organising their book bags Confused

madasawethen · 20/09/2022 09:54

I have 2 and that turned out just fine. They're grown now.
If I only had 1, I suspect that would have been ok too.

I don't think 2 has been a lot different or that much more expensive.

museumum · 20/09/2022 09:56

Dh and I were older when we met. For us it was a choice between one child or two in very quick succession. When the time came we just couldn’t bring ourselves to ttc when ds was still a tiny baby and as ds has grown we’ve loved doing new and different things with him without a younger child holding him back.

DoingJustFine · 20/09/2022 10:00

I have two. DS2 is the apple of my eye but if we'd only had DS1 we could have bought a much nicer house because two-bed houses are soooo much cheaper round here.

sóh₂wl̥ · 20/09/2022 10:00

Statically onlys do better educationally - held true for DH.

DH had a happy childhood and never had an issue being an only.

As for dealing with parents alone - well he has me and from what I've seen of aging parents it usually falls on one child anyway.

We have three - absolutely right for us - but if we didn't well my career would have continued and not be so derailed. We'd have a smaller house - so possible could have bought in better catchment area and nearer DH workplace.

So basically more money and possibly more time - but I don't think our have suffered any lack - they have all equipment they need and support - in fact worry with us having one was that I'd smoother with attention - with three that's spread out.

As PP said there up and down for any family size - I do think people projected onto only's insisting on things that may well not be true at all - like spoiling/feeling lack of sibling/loneliness etc - they do it with other family sizes as well but more so with just one I think.

Ponoka7 · 20/09/2022 10:02

Can I throw in the possibility of disability? Luckily for my DD she has me and my eldest DD to help out. It means that the eldest doesn't miss out, because the younger one would struggle on outdoor stuff, ninja type inflatables and swimming etc. The youngest is waiting for grommets and gets ear infections after swimming. Seeing to both of them during the Easter holidays, while keeping up the SATS work and the youngest's speech/physio therapy was tough. The fighting is terrible. I know a few people who have come to think that they are glad when their child goes to high school that they haven't still got one at primary. It's all the illnesses that primary brings and we've now got Covid in the mix.

RedWingBoots · 20/09/2022 10:07

madasawethen · 20/09/2022 09:54

I have 2 and that turned out just fine. They're grown now.
If I only had 1, I suspect that would have been ok too.

I don't think 2 has been a lot different or that much more expensive.

Did you send your two to nursery?

All my friends with 2 close in age were paying much more than their mortgage in nursery fees for a few years, and many had family help.

NCFT0922 · 20/09/2022 10:19

@TempsPerdu are you in a deprived area or just a school with a lot of crap parents? All the things you’ve listed are very standard and things many wouldn’t even think to mention; reading with your child and returning a book? Swimming and dance lessons? All very normal things to do. I don’t think having 1 child is the key to getting your child to a swimming lesson weekly or making sure they have the right clothes for school. Just being an able adult would suffice.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 20/09/2022 10:19

@TempsPerdu how long has your DD been in reception - a couple of weeks?! - and you’re already patting yourself on the back for being better than the other parents?

Fwiw I’ve got 2 kids (4 and 2) and have done every single thing on your list with them both.

In answer to the OP I think the thing that would be different if I’d only had one is more time and money for myself. I am happy that my kids don’t want for anything in terms of time, money, attention (so far), but I don’t have as much time for my own hobbies/seeing my friends as I used to, and I’m sure that has a knock on impact on my mood/relationship. I’ve felt a bit isolated over the past couple of years but covid has had a big role to play in that too.

Bootsandcat · 20/09/2022 10:20

We would be richer. I wouldn’t have nearly died. My husband wouldn’t have had a mental breakdown.

lawandgin · 20/09/2022 10:22

Great thread and really interesting responses. Following as I am still very much on the fence (although DD is only 5mo!)