The thing is, people are right,there is a nasty side to MN as well.
I've also seen threads on Tattle that are absolutely fine, and threads where the users are shocked by the hatred expressed on other threads for particular people in the public eye.
I agree that those in the public eye have to accept the bad with the good and if they're going to open up their lives it's reasonable to expect criticism. But those people who post viciousness about the way someone looks? About their children? Those who say someone they dislike deserves horrible things happening to them?
That's out of order, imo. And the mob mentality does come into play there - it creates a space where such venom is acceptable. People forge friendships by sharing nastiness about others and when they run out of material for criticism they resort to bullying. That's not ok.
The difference, I think, with what I've seem with this site is when that happens here - as it does - moderators step in. Not always in good time, but they do seem to react to shut down hate and bullying.
And re the comment about gender criticism on this site- it's not censored. I'm not gc myself but I don't go around reporting all those posts that espouse the opposing views to mine because I respect free speech, and given the overwhelming number of gc posts that remain, others do too.