Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I had been thinner when younger?

169 replies

Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 13:01

So this is a really stupid thread but I’ll put it out there anyway. It’s not a TAAT but I just saw a post by someone my age (41) who used to cover Miss Sixty clothes.

I started gaining weight at about 16. I was probably around 11/11 and a half stone until I was 18. Then when I went away to university I slammed it on and was over 14 and a half stone. I was nearly 25 before I lost it and got down to 11 and a half.

I’ve only been below 10 and a half twice when I was ill.

It’s stupid really as in the scheme of things it’s not important. I have a lovely life, a job I like (sometimes) gorgeous kids but I do wish I’d been slimmer and more attractive when younger.

OK now flame me Grin

OP posts:
Londoncallingme · 18/01/2022 21:42

I had bariatric surgery at 52.
Huge mistake to have it done then and not when I was 22 - I could have had 30yrs feeling as amazing and healthy as I do now.

Onceiwasfat · 18/01/2022 21:45

If the Hmm face is indicative of rage, then most of MN are raging, which admittedly does seem sometimes to be the case, but I’ve certainly never interpreted that emoji as communicating furious rage. It is more of a head tilt, a querying ‘really?’ surely, which seems a reasonable response to a blithe ah lucky you being fat and having a shit youth - I was gorgeous and happy and it makes my life now seem rubbish in comparison!

Rhetorical questions are also hardly indicative of anger. Mild exasperation at best after repeating the same points several times possibly.

OP posts:
Onceiwasfat · 18/01/2022 21:46

I can sympathise with that @Londoncallingme

OP posts:
Scottsy100 · 18/01/2022 22:39

Enjoy the now, where the nice clothes now, I was always bothered about my weight as a teen and in my twenties and now when I look back 2 kids later I wish I was that weight again lol

Pinkrose1111 · 18/01/2022 22:56

Not being rude, but I don't really understand the point of the thread if you're not relating it to now? I don't get how you can say I wish I was slimmer and more attractive when I was younger but then say I don't wanna get and more attractive slimmer now?? Surely when you're 61 your just going to be looking back at when you was 41 the same way you are now, no?

myfaceismyown · 18/01/2022 23:48

OP being slim in your early 20 isn't all its cracked up to be. I reached my full height at 11, then plonked on the pounds. It was ok, I was the fat funny clever one at school. A bookworm loner, but relatively happy. I mean no best friend but could make a group laugh. DM took me to the Dr who prescribed amphetamines, oh the good old days... At 14 I was hospitalised with a chronic infection and the weight dropped off. I emerged butterfly like, at 8 stone. I got into fitness and eating "well" for my health. Suddenly all the pretty girls liked me. I didn't get why. At 15 I had my 1st boyfriend and lost my V too early. At Uni I noticed all the attraction I was getting and was a bit of a git! - even though inside I was still fat and funny. Went to all the balls though, and dated some gorgeous guys, most of whom I am still friends with. The caveate is that this comes with 2 rapes and several attempts. Multiple. Fortunately I met my now husband who was, and is, a geek who accidentally became tall slim and handsome, much to his surprise. We have the same humour, academic ability and quirky values and I guess we just recognised each other. After a chequered history with my health I am now very overweight. So what I am saying is the best bit was finding a soul mate and having our funny, charming DCS. I don't think I like the 8 stone me at all. Yes, I wore the fashion, dated the hottest, have some great photos, but it means nothing.

Mamanyt · 19/01/2022 01:00

I think that almost every, if not ever, woman suffers from body image issues. How can we not, having been slammed with idealized, airbrushed images every time we turn around from the time we are old enough to realize what those magazines on the coffee table were. No, it is not unreasonable to feel that way. It is almost unavoidable. It is, however, something you need to work on. You may be able to change your future, but you will not change your past, and dwelling on that might cripple your ability to change the future.

Namechange466 · 19/01/2022 01:05

Not really understanding the point of this thread

you want to air your thoughts - great. But are then berating every single persons own experience in response to your AIBU question

people aren’t psychic and don’t know what you want from this thread

if they aren’t giving you the response you want because you haven’t articulated what you are expecting then there is no need to be so rude

Namechange466 · 19/01/2022 01:07

Someone who was skinny and flat and bullied for that has every right to share their experience on this thread in response to your question - not sure why you have a right to shut them down

someone saying they were too thin in the past is not always a humble brag and it’s very sad you automatically think it would be

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 19/01/2022 01:21

OP, I saw the Miss Sixty thread. I think if you had posted in S&B something like “all the clothes I wish I had worn when I was younger” you would have got very different responses.

buddythemum · 19/01/2022 02:15

@Onceiwasfat
I used to be skinny and constantly stressed as a teenager that I was unnatractive. But for so many teenagers it can ruin lives when it needs to be sorted out. Everyone matures differently

5128gap · 19/01/2022 07:06

@Pinkrose1111

Not being rude, but I don't really understand the point of the thread if you're not relating it to now? I don't get how you can say I wish I was slimmer and more attractive when I was younger but then say I don't wanna get and more attractive slimmer now?? Surely when you're 61 your just going to be looking back at when you was 41 the same way you are now, no?
I see both sides of this. The OPs point is solely related to experience lost that she can never make up for. Even if she is the most beautiful 41 year old in the world with the best possible life, she still never got to wear certain clothes and have certain experiences she could have had she been a slim 21 year old. That time is gone, nothing she will do now will give her that experience. She's not saying it's the end of the world, just something that makes her a little sad. It's a bit like saying I wish I'd been better off as a young person so I could have afforded to go clubbing in Ibiza, which I feel the window is now closed on, because its no longer something I'd enjoy in the same way. That said, I strongly agree with living in the now. My own story is of aging very positively and achieving many of the things as an older woman I didn't get to do when younger, including looking and feeling very slim attractive and enjoying the health and social benefits that come with that. The OP could, and may well be, doing the same, but for her it's unrelated to her issue about the lost experiences of her youth.
MammaMacgill87 · 19/01/2022 08:17

I was very fit and slim when I was younger and took it totally for granted. I look back wistfully at those days and make myself bloody miserable now 🤣. I'm a fat frumpy middle aged woman with zero motivation to do a damn thing about it haha. You're not being unreasonable though most of us look back at some aspect of our youth with regret. Maybe I'll bounce back at some point an be a fit party granny? I can dream lol

Mollymoostoo · 19/01/2022 08:42

@Onceiwasfat

I think for me it’s a feeling where I always felt fat and unattractive. I always felt I couldn’t wear nice clothes like my friends and never felt boys would be interested in me.
Slim and attractive are not the same. There are some thin and dog ugly people out there.
Loubilou09 · 19/01/2022 10:53

@5128gap

How did you see the thread going OP? What were you looking for?
Christ how utterly patronising.

Maybe she was just "having a conversation" you know....like you do on a chat forum.....

Onceiwasfat · 19/01/2022 11:37

I agree with living in the now, but where I seem to differ in my view from others on here is that posting one thread, once, in AIBU doesn’t constitute in any way living in the past.

Life moves on, and it’s fair to say that constantly looking back, pining, longing and regretting is self destructive and I agree that if someone is doing these things, then some form of professional help might be appropriate. However, you also can’t live solely in the here-and-now either. I think for the most part I have a good balance, to be honest, in some ways I perhaps veer more towards not thinking about my past because some of those memories are painful to me.

But sometimes memories or flashbacks or thoughts will pop into your head unbidden - when you go to a place you went to once, or hear a song, or something like seeing a thread about clothes from the early 2000s Smile and I don’t actually think it’s healthy to insist they leave your thoughts immediately and inform your brain that they are not welcome here, only memories from 2018 onwards are allowed here thank you very much! Aside from the fact you can’t do this, repressed memories generally come out in other ways when you determinedly decide you will NOT let them in.

@Namechange466 I’m certainly not trying to shut anyone down, but I am entitled to explain that they are not the same things. For one thing, I was never bullied for my weight - I only really started to put weight on once I had left school. For the most part, my role was Fat Friend. I would console my friends and counsel them through their relationship problems because there was no chance I’d have a relationship so I was ‘safe.’

If I see someone say they don’t understand the point of the thread one more time though, I promise I won’t ‘rage’, but I will confess it’s mildly annoying when I’ve explained, over and over. And others have answered, and explained. And others have shared their experiences and we have talked and we have processed and we have discussed. And still some people come on just to say ‘but I don’t understand.

Maybe, you don’t have to? There are many things I will never properly understand but it doesn’t mean I have the right to inform others they should not share their experiences, or talk about them, or try to make false comparisons by, say, telling someone with agoraphobia that I know just how they feel as some days I want to stay in bed too. It is sometimes right and appropriate to tell people - actually, that is not correct, they are not the same things at all.

Of course, some people never take being corrected well and I do think that’s really where the hostility has come from. I have read back through my posts and I have not once ‘raged’ Hmm

OP posts:
leatherboundbooks · 19/01/2022 13:41

I think it can be healthier to look at memories when for whatever reason they ping up than repress them, acknowledge the regret and maybe another time things won't be so vivid, well that's my experience, getting things out in the open, either talking about it or just pondering and trying to understand until it's been acknowledged and dealt with, well my experience anyway

MammaMacgill87 · 19/01/2022 17:24

Jesus Christ, you do realize this is a chat forum, for chat? And that not every conversation has some deep alternative meaning? It's a wistful thread she's not about to throw herself off a bridge because she wasn't a skinny teen it's a question posed for a conversation, you know, those things we all have all the time? Do none of you complainers have conversations unless they are life or death or direly important? Madness.

yzed · 21/01/2022 15:21

Hi OnceIwas fat. (And so was I, by the way.)

This has proved an interesting thread, for multitudinous reasons. If nothing else I think it shows quite how many of us are so hung-up about our weight. And for so many different reasons. But perhaps (and yes, I know I'm not the first to mention this) it's not actually about weight?

In one of your early threads you mentioned "that careless confidence" and I thought "Aah, yes, that careless confidence that I'd love so much. TBH there have been times in my life when it's been there for me, and others when it's eluded me completely. But it's the thing I'd love to have, more than the perfect figure or great beauty. More than money or brains. More than youth and energy. Would only be superseded by health

Anyway Once Was, may you long continue to question/discuss/muse over aspects of your life; and if you find the key to that elusive careless confidence do please share.

Happy Hunting

New posts on this thread. Refresh page