I am going to comment in defence of gentle parenting because it’s got a right bashing over the entirety of the threads.
I’ve got 11yr old twins and I don’t raise my voice. Not ever. They are both kind and well-behaved. They understand what’s expected of them and why. I’ve always talked to them when a problem has occurred. We have boundaries- and they absolutely understand that I will not hesitate to follow through if they are broken. Less punishment, more natural consequences if that makes sense.
Both my two are autistic and have a collection of associated conditions too. Maybe that makes a difference, I don’t know? But gentle parenting has really worked for us and created a home which is peaceful and calm - something which is desperately needed with three autistic people in the house (I’m autistic too). It took me a while to figure out the right approach but gentle parenting really works for us. We’re not all shit parents with feral children 😂
Reading this thread I feel utterly infuriated with OP’s friend and Alyssa sounds awful. I would 100% have toddled off to my room with wine, snacks and Netflix probably much sooner than OP. Clearly OP and I disagree on lots of things about parenting but we’re all different aren’t we? I know what works for my kids and OP knows what works for hers. Neither of us have kids who are selfish or bratty so that shows there’s not a single right way to parent. Gentle parenting CAN be incredibly effective - but that doesn’t mean being a pushover. A child who is “unwell with tummy ache” doesn’t get to come downstairs and play with makeup at 10pm 😳😳😳 That’s not gentle parenting, that’s shit parenting.