@SpidersAreShitheads
I am going to comment in defence of gentle parenting because it’s got a right bashing over the entirety of the threads.
I’ve got 11yr old twins and I don’t raise my voice. Not ever. They are both kind and well-behaved. They understand what’s expected of them and why. I’ve always talked to them when a problem has occurred. We have boundaries- and they absolutely understand that I will not hesitate to follow through if they are broken. Less punishment, more natural consequences if that makes sense.
Both my two are autistic and have a collection of associated conditions too. Maybe that makes a difference, I don’t know? But gentle parenting has really worked for us and created a home which is peaceful and calm - something which is desperately needed with three autistic people in the house (I’m autistic too). It took me a while to figure out the right approach but gentle parenting really works for us. We’re not all shit parents with feral children 😂
Reading this thread I feel utterly infuriated with OP’s friend and Alyssa sounds awful. I would 100% have toddled off to my room with wine, snacks and Netflix probably much sooner than OP. Clearly OP and I disagree on lots of things about parenting but we’re all different aren’t we? I know what works for my kids and OP knows what works for hers. Neither of us have kids who are selfish or bratty so that shows there’s not a single right way to parent. Gentle parenting CAN be incredibly effective - but that doesn’t mean being a pushover. A child who is “unwell with tummy ache” doesn’t get to come downstairs and play with makeup at 10pm 😳😳😳 That’s not gentle parenting, that’s shit parenting.
I think there's a muddle generally on the thread about 'gentle parenting' and 'being railroaded by children'.
I rarely raise my voice, if I do my kids know I mean it. But that also doesn't mean that I'm shouting or disregarding their needs. Raising my voice means just that, not shouting, just speaking very clearly.
For us (and I've explained this to them when they were of an age to understand) it means "I don't have time to explain why you need to do what I say but you need to do it right now and I'll explain later".
I can 'command' my kids with an imperceptible eyebrow raise. Not because they're terrified of me, because they know that I'm the grown-up and I am handling the situation.
I take an awful lot of shenanigans from them, but they know where to stop.