Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask what suv type cars you have?

157 replies

Marie5678 · 22/04/2021 07:58

I'm looking to get a new car have looked at the Peugeot 2008 and Nissan qashqai and possibly the vw tiguan (although that's a bit more pricey for decent reg) my budget is 11k. What cars do you have and how reliable would you say it is?

OP posts:
thelegohooverer · 22/04/2021 14:22

Neither of mine are suvs.

I’ve had a Skoda Octavia and could get three car seats (just) in the back. Boot space was phenomenal - I could get a buggy, a wee umbrella fold buggy, 2 toddler balance bikes and a weeks shopping in there.

I then moved on to a Toyota versa. 7 seats technically but I don’t use the back ones. So lots of boot space. Lots of space inside. Very comfortable to drive. It’s only the same footprint as a normal car, easy to manoeuvre and park. Very adaptable too which came in handy for moving house.

What ages are your dc? Ime the need for space peaks with the three point car seats. Once they get onto boosters they will feel like they have more space

Starseeking · 22/04/2021 14:23

I have a Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV, which is a hybrid car. I love it! Only downside is that the electric runs for a maximum of 30 miles, so it works best if you do a lot of local driving (working from home means I only drop DC to nursery/school and go to Tesco!).

misslomi · 22/04/2021 14:28

I have a Suzuki Vitara and I love it. Huge boot and definitely more spacious than my old golf.

gwenneh · 22/04/2021 14:28

We have a Hyundai Tucson. I traded in my 2015 RAV4 against it about 18 months ago. DH drives a Honda CR-V hybrid, which I DO NOT like based on how the transmission performs. The last hybrid we had before that was a Lexus NX 300h, and it didn't feel nearly as sluggish as the CR-V.

I think which SUV you might like would depend on what reasons you want an SUV.

Alleycat02 · 22/04/2021 14:29

@thelegohooverer

Neither of mine are suvs.

I’ve had a Skoda Octavia and could get three car seats (just) in the back. Boot space was phenomenal - I could get a buggy, a wee umbrella fold buggy, 2 toddler balance bikes and a weeks shopping in there.

I then moved on to a Toyota versa. 7 seats technically but I don’t use the back ones. So lots of boot space. Lots of space inside. Very comfortable to drive. It’s only the same footprint as a normal car, easy to manoeuvre and park. Very adaptable too which came in handy for moving house.

What ages are your dc? Ime the need for space peaks with the three point car seats. Once they get onto boosters they will feel like they have more space

That's really helpful, thanks thelegohooverer - my eldest two are already in high back boosters, but still a few years off not needing car seats at all, and the youngest is not quite 2.5 so still in the 3 point seat. Will investigate the Toyota Versa.
MissDollyMix · 22/04/2021 14:37

I test drove ALL the suv/cross overs when we were looking for a new car. My favourite by far was the Mazda CX-5. Lovely handling and good spec. Also low emissions. We ended up getting a Ford s-Max though as non of the suv/crossovers are actually that spacious and we needed space. The Ford isn’t the most stylish but it’s got so much space and is so practical. Not bad to drive either!

stylemeplease · 22/04/2021 14:37

Unless you need an AWD get an estate or a people carrier type car they are better for space
Had an arteon as last car and it has so much boot space

Audi A6 estate loads of boot space but not as much as the arteon

A6 tomorrow
Is bigger all over the whole body then that fucking seat atecca that drives like a roller skate and is the size of a fiesta

AnnPerkins · 22/04/2021 14:39

We're on our second Kia Sportage and we love it. I looked at estates but I like the higher ride height, 86 yo Dad finds it easier to get in and out too. It is comfortable to ride in and nice to drive.

(I wouldn't have called it an SUV but that's what Kia calls it so...)

ineedaholidayandwine · 22/04/2021 14:40

Jaguar F-Pace R Sport. Gorgeous car

CaveMum · 22/04/2021 14:42

I’ve got a Volvo XC60 which we bought last year. I love it and it’s a vast upgrade on my old Kia Rio! The XC90 is larger and has the extra row of seats which would probably be more suitable as you have 3 kids.

Cookies2523 · 22/04/2021 14:42

Does anyone have a Ford Ecosport? If you do have one, are you happy with it?

MindyStClaire · 22/04/2021 14:48

We have a Tucson which we love, but I don't know that we'd fit a third car set. Maybe if the two non-infant ones were small.

More generally, we traded in our Astra for the Tucson as we needed more boot space when DC2 arrived so we could fit a buggy and a suitcase to go visit family.

Astra: length 4419mm, width 2013mm, boot space seats up 351L

Tucson: length 4475mm, width 2065mm, boot space seats up 513L

Octavia: length 4689mm, width 2017mm, boot space seats up 610L

I didn't want to drive a bigger car than the Astra, so we went for the Tucson for the 45% increase in boot size with no real change in the size of the car. Surely lots of people make the same choice.

bottyg · 22/04/2021 14:49

Volvo - chose it for safety

Tinkletwat · 22/04/2021 15:05

Try a Golf or Passat estate rather than an SUV. New Arteon shooting brake is a nice looking car but won't be in your budget. What about a trusty volvo estate? New model V60 boot is larger than the old. V90 might be a bit too big but you'll still get some V70s secondhand.

stylemeplease · 22/04/2021 15:12

@Tinkletwat the shooting break is lovely isn't it

I miss my Arteon so much

Had a cc as well a few years prior to it

So much fun

But the lease was ridiculous this time so I've gone for an Audi instead

I would deff say an estate car or a saloon car not an suv they are mostly bastards to see out of and are small inside

With the exception of very square suv type cars it's often hard to understand where the side of the car is!!

I have struggled so mich with the Ateca and I am so glad that thing is going tomorrow

I'll never have to drive the thing again

doubleshotespresso · 22/04/2021 15:22

Nissan Quashqai really has been the best choice for us, highly recommend it

sasparilla1 · 22/04/2021 15:27

If you're looking for a "proper" SUV then I can't recommend an older Nissan X-trail enough. We got rid of ours in September, and I flipping loved that car! In 4wd it will literally go anywhere, even over Salisbury Plain in the snow when the road was blocked by cars that were stuck.

I now have an Audi Q7 which is an AWD. It's really nice, but I now think about where I go and what I sling in the back. We bought because we needed more space for growing kids (and future proofing) and we have one which can be a 7 seater as we now have grandchildren too.

PickleSarnie · 22/04/2021 15:43

Unless you go for one of the huge SUV's like a Discovery or a Q7 or something like that then there really isn't much point in an SUV.

Literally the only advantage I can think of is that you are sat higher up - which would be useful if you have mobility issues.

Other than that, estate cars often have bigger boots (my estate has 210 more litres space with the seats up than a Quasqhai for example), they have more oomph for equivalent engine size because they are lighter and lower, better MPG, usually lower emissions and lower tax.

Horizons83 · 22/04/2021 15:53

We have a Mazda CX-5 and love it... mainly purchased because it was the only car my husband felt comfortable in with enough headspace (he has a very long back). But we are very happy with it, so easy to drive. And lower emissions that our previous hatchback.

Rootsmanouvre · 22/04/2021 16:12

We looked at SUVs as we wanted room for an ERF seat, high back booster and an adult in the back, plus decent boot space/roof bars. We needed up with not a SUV but a SKODA Octavia Estate as it was by far the roomiest 5 seater we looked at. Boot is amazing too. The only 5 seater that came close, space wise was the Sportage but we could get a much newer SKODA for our budget.

billyt · 22/04/2021 16:25

@Elai1978

Lovely car to drive, very comfortable, great acceleration

Very poor acceleration in the 1.3 QQ. I’d avoid QQ like the plague due to poor reliability which is not something you’d historically from Nissan, same with VW. Kia and Hyundai are great with long warranties, also worth looking at the Honda CRV.

Sorry, but I really disagree about your opinion of the acceleration. Maybe the older 1.3 but the new ones have 160bhp and are pretty quick off the line and when overtaking etc.

I will say I had to have the battery replaced after a few months Sad. Went away for a week (when holidays were allowed Grin) came back and it wouldn't start. It was part of a faulty batch of batteries. Since then all good.

Love driving it.

MatildaTheCat · 22/04/2021 16:30

I had 3 Honda CR-Vs in a row and found them comfortable and cheap to run. They also come with a huge range of features that the pricier makes charge a fortune for as extras.

I’ve now downsized slightly to a Mini Countryman hybrid. I like it but it has more design snags than the Honda.

DynamoKev · 22/04/2021 16:42

@Ginuwine

All the people who are quibbling over what constitutes an SUV.... knock it off. I mean, seriously. The Kia Sportage might say "estate" on the V5 but it's an SUV. It's described as such on the manufacturer website, on magazine reviews, etc..

By SUV we know what we mean. Tall boxy cars that emulate the shape and car type that first became popularised with the Discovery, Range Rover, Cayenne etc, but quickly trickled down to smaller and cheaper cars once the fashionable looks element and perception of space became a selling point. They have high ride height.

If you mean "off road worthy 4x4 with a monocoque body and low range gearbox" then you're talking a tiny proportion of cars in today's market, the kind of Land Cruiser, Jeep Wrangler vehicle that few people really need but some love if they live rurally and tow etc.

Anyways back to the OP's topic -

The SUV class is the default go-to for people who want to "feel safe by being high up" and have "space" even though other car classes offer more space.

Most are 2WD, some are 4WD.

Qashqai is one of the biggest sellers but the Nissan vehicle has serious reliability issues. Hyundai Tucson is loved by many, has the looks and the space, if a bit dull on interior. You then have the Kia Sportage (ugh, but warranty!) and then a host of ludicriously Skoda ones like Russian dolls depending on which size you want (baby Kamiq, bigger Karoq, biggest Kodiaq). The worst above all is the Vauxhall Mokka, a Corsa on stilts often found in white that somehow makes people think they're superior and drive accordingly with terrifying lack of indicating on roundabouts.

In case it's not clear, I think the whole car class is a joke. An estate car with 4wd does everything and more that it can do. It's all about image.

@Ginuwine What do understand by the term monocoque body?
MindyStClaire · 22/04/2021 16:48

@PickleSarnie

Unless you go for one of the huge SUV's like a Discovery or a Q7 or something like that then there really isn't much point in an SUV.

Literally the only advantage I can think of is that you are sat higher up - which would be useful if you have mobility issues.

Other than that, estate cars often have bigger boots (my estate has 210 more litres space with the seats up than a Quasqhai for example), they have more oomph for equivalent engine size because they are lighter and lower, better MPG, usually lower emissions and lower tax.

As per my post above, the crossover SUV type cars that OP mentioned have a similar footprint to a family hatchback, but with a significantly bigger boot size. Not as big as an estate, but not as long as an estate either.
hotpatooties1 · 22/04/2021 16:50

my budget is 11k

A lot of people missing a pivotal piece of information in the OP.. if budget is 11k I don't think a Jaguar f pace, Audi Q7 or Range Rover are very practical suggestions Confused