Peanut butter and butter on toast is wrong

[QuentinWinters]

Settle a debate for me If you are eating peanut butter on toast do you butter the toast first? I don't because it seems like too much fat but DP does and calls me weird.
YABU - Toast, butter and peanut butter
YANBU - toast and peanut butter doesn't require extra

It isnt. Its so delicious. Only when its crunchy peanut butter though.

Yes I do, or it ends up too claggy in your mouth. If I'm eating peanut butter on toast I'm not doing it for the health beni😂

Butter, then marmite, then peanut butter.

Definitely yes to butter. Makes it all oozy and delicious.

Surely the whole point of peanut butter is that it's claggy? It's a sensory experience as well as a taste experience.

Butter ~ Peanut butter ~ Welch's grape jelly

REAL FOOD

No butter for me, otherwise it's too greasy

IMO the toast needs a slight scrape of butter otherwise the PB is too claggy.

On non-toasted bread I'd probably spread the PB straight on.

@Mydogisagentleman

YANBU, but some sliced ripe banana elevates it

This!

Two 'butters' plus honey. Just saying.

Lead me not into temptation.......

YABU.
It’s dry as feck without it.

Welch's grape jelly

Fake jam. Yes alright, it's jelly not preserve but whilst I don't mind it, it just makes me crave proper jam. Of pretty much any flavour. Oh, with or without peanut butter of course.

BTW you PBJ aficionados is the PB smooth or crunchy in your / on your PBJ.

Just peanut butter for me.
Has to be crunchy as well, none of that smooth muck.

Butter for me and both the butter and peanut butter thickly spread

Butter, peanut butter, blackcurrant jam. Delicious.

Peanut butter and Nutella.

YABVVU

Oh god me and dh have this argument all the time!
Or course you don't but butter on as well, peanut BUTTER is the butter.

(No butter necessary for that one)

To answer your actual question, I generally do butter and peanut butter. So good, so rich, so delicious.

@ToffeeNotCoffee

Welch's grape jelly

Fake jam. Yes alright, it's jelly not preserve but whilst I don't mind it, it just makes me crave proper jam. Of pretty much any flavour. Oh, with or without peanut butter of course.

BTW you PBJ aficionados is the PB smooth or crunchy in your / on your PBJ.

PBJ is home made PB and ideally home made grape jelly I really miss my grandmother BUT the PB has to be crunchy and the J utterly smooth

@RavingAnnie

YABU butter is amazing and makes everything better. Plus peanut butter is dry and toast is dry so the butter provides some much needed moisture.

Totally agree.

Too dry without the butter

Definitely with butter, it's too dry and 'gacky' on the roof of my mouth otherwise.

Toast, peanut butter and marmite. No extra butter.

YANBU - It never occurred to me to put butter and peanut butter on toast until a colleague mentioned it recently. I always have butter and jam/marmalade/syrup but no peanut butter/Nutella and butter just seem wrong