Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

MNHQ delete every remotely interesting thread!

327 replies

wewillmeetagain · 13/02/2021 11:17

Why do they do this? Ive seen two in the last 24 hours! Nothing remotely insulting, libellous or argumentative on them! It's like the only discussion with which they agree is allowed to take place! I personally think it spoils MN, they will probably remove this discussion pretty sharpish anyway!

OP posts:
KatherineJaneway · 14/02/2021 14:35

[quote Hubblebubble75]@KatherineJaneway
It was the one ‘new partners phone is off’

The message is still there from MN in my watched posts

thread deleted

Message from MNHQ: The OP is a previously banned poster.[/quote]
Hi KatherineJaneway,

Thanks for getting in touch about this thread. We've had a quick check behind the scenes and can see that the OP's been on the site for a few years so we're going to have a read through her posting history to see if it's consistent. We can't see a match with any previously banned posters, for the record.

@Hubblebubble75

Hubblebubble75 · 14/02/2021 14:38

@KatherineJaneway which one is it then ? what a mystery !

KatherineJaneway · 14/02/2021 14:43

[quote Hubblebubble75]@KatherineJaneway which one is it then ? what a mystery ![/quote]
@Hubblebubble75

No idea. I can only paste what was emailed to me. I thought it was a troll as it had the classic signs. Maybe they dug a bit deeper 🤷‍♀️

CharityDingle · 14/02/2021 15:15

@supercee

Does anyone know what happened to the woman with a young child fleeing DV from her husband? She went to her sisters and then her parents I think. She posted a picture from her car and her friend was looking after her horse.

It got to thread two but both disappeared I think.

Both were moved to a forum where threads disappear / are deleted automatically after a certain length of time.
supercee · 14/02/2021 15:19

@CharityDingle ah thanks. I knew they had been moved to the other place but didn't realise those threads get deleted.

AlternativePerspective · 14/02/2021 15:31

How hilarious that it made it to the Daily Fail, and it was all fiction. it should fit right in on there then. Grin

Ballstothis148 · 14/02/2021 15:38

I was a bit gutted by the rude celebrities thread as was entertaining fluff :) and took it with a pinch of salt cos we all have good and bad days, and some posters might just be lying. But it was fun :) and loads of celebs have their employees use confidentiality agreements so was interesting to see a bit of real experiences

bigbird1969 · 14/02/2021 16:44

Ballstothis148 i posted on the rude celebrity thread and what i said was true....I wont say anymore about the celebrity however I was reliably informed that the same person I wrote about was caught in a school kitchen snorting coke...Grin

Jobsharenightmare · 14/02/2021 16:48

I think it's only sensible to change a few details here and there though if you know lots of people who use the site if they're incidental and not going to impact the advice people can give. So for instance if you wanted marriage advice you could say the kids were 2 and 4 instead of 1 and 3.

Fuckoffyoueviltrolls · 14/02/2021 16:56

Does anyone know what happened to the thread -about a lady thinking she was pregnant with her 7th child? Few weeks back now.

rosetylersbiggun · 14/02/2021 18:44

Regards to the Tom thread. I was starting to think this is someone fishing for book ideas.
If the OP of that thread is reading this here are some free plot ideas: Tom is a vampire. Tom is the wife's secret twin brother she never knew existed. The wife is secretly an MI6 sleeper agent. The husband is in Witness Protection/defected Russian spy and Tom's his handler. Please feel free to use any/all of those because in its current state the 'plotline' would make a pisspoor novel.

rosetylersbiggun · 14/02/2021 18:44

Haven't rtft but I'm annoyed the It's A Sin thread about the character Jill has been deleted. I was saving that for when I'd finished watching the show. Anyone know why it's gone?

Is it this one? Because I had it on my watch list and it suddenly vanished, but the thread hasn't been deleted, just gone from watch list for some reason. I don't know why, some bug I guess?

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4157883-To-feel-like-the-character-of-Jill-in-Its-A-Sin-was-really-underdeveloped-Spoiler-alert-added-by-MNHQ

bruffin · 15/02/2021 10:09

@Biscoffaddict

Why was the Australia thread deleted? I didn’t see anything offensive on it? A lot of discussion about the pros and cons of living there, but nothing else.
Of course it was offensive. Its typical of whats wrong with MN, its always the negative, I dont like it so nobody else can. Why didnt the OP just say. I never been to australia , what do you like about the country? The thread was designed to bring out criticism. OP doesnt want to go to Australia, why start a thread about it, who cares. There are way too many posts on MN "I dont like this popular film book etc, i cant stand the fact someone has different likes to me", instead of "Whats your favorite author, genre, film
JamesMiddletonsMarshmallows · 15/02/2021 10:12

I agree MNHQ are way too trigger happy with thread deletions.

I do wish they'd update the deletion messages too - there was a thread last night where it was quite obvious about the massive drip feeds and weird and inconsistent information...it's taken down now so they can "looks behind the scenes" but I'd like to know if it was a troll because when I questioned certain aspects of the inconsistent and nonsense story I got my arse handed to me by several posters (I also like being right Grin)

littlepattilou · 15/02/2021 13:13

[quote breadwidow]@littlepattilou I know what you mean and I think when people emigrate that far, and stay, things are driving them out of the UK as much as stuff pulling them to Australia/NZ. Eg my husbands uncle had a very bad relationship with his mother and I think when the family left England he wanted to put continents between them. The fact my family are all here meant our stint in Australia was always gonna be temporary [/quote]
Yeah, it does make you wonder, when people emigrate 10,000 to 12,000 miles away, why they're doing it, and what they're trying to get away from (or who!) And why they are happy to move so far away from everyone and everything they know, and their whole life, and their past and everything?

And as has been said, why go that far? Just for the sunny weather? There are plenty of places much closer to go to - like The South of France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece etc... In addition, Australia is really expensive.

Further to this. I just watched 'A Place In The Sun' on BBC1, and a youngish couple (late 30s,) with 2 little girls, were contemplating going to New Zealand.

The wife/mother of the little girls in the family (I'll call her Sarah,) was the driving force for sure. The husband/father of the little girls, (I'll call him Steve,) was half-hearted about it, and the 2 girls (around 5 and 8) were not too keen either.

Sarah insisted the weather was better, and 'their jobs paid more,' and it's 'a much better life,' and she wanted to emigrate there. A house that cost around £325,000 where they lived (north west mids,) cost £475,000-500,000 in Auckland where this woman wanted to go. So the house prices are much higher for sure.

They showed footage of Sarah's sister and BIL, and 2 friends, and they didn't want them to go, and said they'd miss them. Then Steve's sister and BIL, and 4 children were upset and said they'd miss them, and so did his grandparents. And his mother and father, were very upset, and his mother started to cry.

Then the two little girls (Sarah and Steve's,) started to get weepy too, and said they didn't want to leave their friends, and nan and grandad.

Sarah was determined they were going, and told the to stop being silly, and said they'd make new friends, and could speak to nana and grandad over zoom or skype, and she refused to listen anyone else, as her mind was made up.

When Steve (reluctantly) said 'ok then, NZ it is,' Sarah grinned and said 'I knew I'd get my own way!' Grin

It was so cringeworthy to watch. Her husband and 2 little girls clearly wanted to stay, and there was nothing in NZ that they didn't have in the UK, (but there was plenty in the UK that they didn't have in NZ.)

Weirdly, Sarah's parents weren't interviewed, so I am guessing it's HER who feels she has nothing worth leaving behind, or is trying to get away from something or someone!

I felt very sorry for Steve and the 2 girls as they definitely didn't want to go. There's been no follow-up on this as it was only filmed in late 2019, but I can't imagine it will be a happy ending, because Sarah was the only one who wanted to go to NZ.

Hubblebubble75 · 15/02/2021 13:24

I think sometimes you’re running away from something. They had one episode where the couple had had a trauma and it ended up this was the main motivation for leaving all reminders behind. I’ve had a similar couple of years and feel flying as far away as possible and starting again can be appealing for sure. I also get the appeal of the weather, outdoors lifestyle, better work/life balance, no language barrier of NZ or Oz. It’s not always possible to get the combo in say Spain, Portugal etc

StepOutOfLine · 15/02/2021 13:37

@JamesMiddletonsMarshmallows

I agree MNHQ are way too trigger happy with thread deletions.

I do wish they'd update the deletion messages too - there was a thread last night where it was quite obvious about the massive drip feeds and weird and inconsistent information...it's taken down now so they can "looks behind the scenes" but I'd like to know if it was a troll because when I questioned certain aspects of the inconsistent and nonsense story I got my arse handed to me by several posters (I also like being right Grin)

There was another totally goady frothy one last night which the OP drip-dripped to the point where every post made you want to go "now give over you goady liar" She said herself "I'm going to get this taken down now, because I can see that X and Y (the two arguments she was goading about) are no-go areas" The deletion message said she'd had privacy concerns. Hmm Only about everyone thinking what a liar and maker-upper of stories to goad she was.
littlepattilou · 15/02/2021 13:54

@StepOutOfLine

There was another totally goady frothy one last night which the OP drip-dripped to the point where every post made you want to go "now give over you goady liar" She said herself "I'm going to get this taken down now, because I can see that X and Y (the two arguments she was goading about) are no-go areas"

The deletion message said she'd had privacy concerns. Hmm
Only about everyone thinking what a liar and maker-upper of stories to goad she was.

Oh how annoying! I hate the 'OP had privacy concerns' message. Because 9 times out of 10, there is/was NOTHING in their posts that gave away who they were.

I have heard SO many people saying mumsnet refused to delete their thread, yet SOME threads get deleted at the drop of a hat, when the OP requests it. Hmm

littlepattilou · 15/02/2021 13:57

@Hubblebubble75

I also get the appeal of the weather, outdoors lifestyle, better work/life balance, no language barrier of NZ or Oz. It’s not always possible to get the combo in say Spain, Portugal etc

I kind of get the language barrier thing, but I would rather be just 2 hours flight away/500-1000 miles, and learn the language, than move 12,000 miles away, knowing that the vast majority of my family, friends, people I know, will never be able to come visit me, because of the distance, and the cost.

Hubblebubble75 · 15/02/2021 16:20

@littlepattilou yes it’s what puts me off but I guess if people came to visit and vice versa - it will be a longer stay - three weeks , rather than a week. I think it’s still the biggest issue with that distance though

ParlezVousWronglais · 15/02/2021 16:50

Does anyone know what happened to the thread where OP had been dating 6 months, hadn’t heard from him for 24 hours and was thinking of either calling his work or going round? Weren’t they meant to be meeting up Friday gone?

Hubblebubble75 · 15/02/2021 16:57

It was a troll apparently! First they said it was genuine then it was a troll

ParlezVousWronglais · 15/02/2021 17:03

Oh bugger!

KatherineJaneway · 15/02/2021 22:04

@ParlezVousWronglais

Oh bugger!
Yes, troll apparently 🙄
Thedramasummer · 16/02/2021 01:24

I was already living hundreds of miles away from family when we chose to move to Australia.
Language and similar culture, along with beautiful weather was what made us pick Australia.

It meant that our children didn’t have any further obstacles in settling in to a new country.