Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about your worst CF MIL stories?

178 replies

MessyMummy15 · 10/12/2020 10:49

I'm actually very lucky to have a lovely mother in law now but my ex's mum was something else!

Once when I had to move in with her temporarily for a couple of week. I had taken my first shower in the house. Afterwards she came to find me and frogmarched me to the bathroom telling me that she doesn't like the shower curtain getting wet and to fold it back when I'm showering which is already 🤔
The next time I had a shower I did as she asked and then asked her where I could find a mop / towel to clean the water on the floor (since you know... there's no shower curtain) she had the biggest flip out when she discovered there was a smal puddle on the floor and the bathroom mat was a bit wet.
She also told me that I wasn't allowed to use the towels as they was for display? (Wasn't going to they was about a million years old)
She proceeded to tell my ex that I was trying to destroy the house. Baffles me to this day how she washed??

That woman has made me sooo thankful for the MIL I have now!

What's your CF MIL stories? The crazier the better!!

OP posts:
Shinyletsbebadguys · 10/12/2020 14:06

@FuzzyPuffling

Well, this is a nasty thread isn't it. "The crazier the better"?

Good luck to all of you who might be MILs in the future.

I may well be , I have two DS. On the grounds that I'm not going to try to turf my DIL out of her hospital bed hours after having a baby and being really unwell afterwards , I think I'm probably safe.

You are missing the fact in these cases the MIL behaved disgustingly but should we never say a word in case their feelings are hurt? Possibly best they don't start off batshit then.

EmbarrassingMama · 10/12/2020 14:06

Mine asked me - genuinely - if I sympathised with a terrorist organisation. She didn't, but she had concerns about me.

W.T.A.F.

Merryhobnobs · 10/12/2020 14:06

My MIL is great. She is widowed and lives far from us so can't really do practical help but she has always made me feel of value in the family, even before we had children or were married. In the last year she has given me a beautiful diamond ring that my late father in law gave to her as an eternity ring. I didn't have an engagement ring, and now I wear this ring everyday. She has listened to me, offered words of support and advice when I have sought it. She isn't an emotional or huggy person but I know I am very lucky.

My own Mum has many issues, which have become worse since I've had children. She ate my chocolate and lied about it when I was just home after having my first baby (46 hour labour, home 12 hours after that, I needed the choc) got upset and huffy because I tried to breastfeed and didn't make dinner for everyone. There is so much and not just trivial stuff like this, and it is hurtful but mum clearly has mental health issues. Makes me appreciate my MIL more. I don't see this thread as 'all MIL are awful' just examples of when it is a bit crazy.

BashfulClam · 10/12/2020 14:09

Mine is a sly manipulative old bag.

Moshe acts like a dotty old lady but knows exactly what she’s doing. When DH left his job and handed back his company car we were carless for a short time as we couldn’t afford one straight away. She was weeping on the phone (because her free chauffeur was gone) and kept asking what I had to say about him giving up his job...what could I say? It was done and I just had to be supportive, being angry wouldn’t help

She uses emotional blackmail regularly and tries to be too involved. We went on our first holiday together just me and DH and she took the memory card and had her own set of OUR holiday photos printed to show her friends. Other people’s pictures are dead boring anyway 🤦🏻‍♀️.

When we moved into our new house she kept banging on about inviting his uncle round as he lived nearby (only met his aunt and uncle once before). We were unpacking and working full time but she would not stop the started saying ‘they are desperate to see your house!’ We invited them and had a nice evening(they are actually really lovely) and then said they were surprised that we had asked them round. I said ‘Oh really? Mil has been saying you are desperate to see our house so often!’ His aunt was mortified and said ‘oh god no we have never said anything like that , oh I’m so sorry!’ Told her not to worry it’s fine.

During lockdown we got a new car, mil called wanting several small favours and asked if DH would go round on the Saturday, he turned up on the Friday evening as we were going to the supermarket nearby. She said ‘oh aren’t you coming tomorrow then?’ We said no as we were passing ‘but I wanted to go to x town!’ In other words she wanted DH to go over and she’d guilt him into taking her to x town (everything was shut). He did put her in her place ‘no mum it’s against the rules and I don’t have as much money now to be running about in the car!’

We have to lie about trips away of days out as she expects to come on every one. When we bought our house it was a new build and we had to nip up to the office to sign some paperwork, DH mentioned it and she got herself an invite. When we went into the sakes office there were 2 chairs and she immediately settled herself into one . So DH ended up standing whilst we went over legal stuff and signed forms. She kept interjecting to tell us shit about her house and friends and their houses...not relevant.

When we got into our house we were buying dibs new furniture and she kept saying ‘oh no don’t get that etc...’ shut it it’s our home, she then told me as it DH’s house she had more rights to it than me...yes me who owns half and oas half the mortgage. She was put straight re that notion!

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 10/12/2020 14:11

Mine sent anonymous Valentine’s cards with all sorts of things inside them, to try to get me to believe my now husband was having an affair.

Fortunately, she’d always sent birthday cards with our correct street address but a particular wrong spelling of the post code. Not just transposing letters, but a completely different final letter.

Let’s guess which post code had been written on the Valentine’s card envelopes?

MIL later admitted it, yelling that we wouldn’t be together for more than 5 years.

26 years and counting...

My son’s Gran, my ex partner’s Mum, is lovely. And we still send cards to each other.

WhySoSensitive · 10/12/2020 14:19

And to add that although my MIL is horrific... my FIL is amazing.

AlternativePerspective · 10/12/2020 14:21

What concerns me about these threads is that they don’t actually paint a very good picture of parenthood. After all, all these MILs were mums once, much like the majority of us on here. And I’m sure that if there were men posting on these threads there would be equally horrific stories of their MILs so I’m sure the issue is not unique to the parents of boys.

So bearing that in mind, how many of the people on these threads will be the ones being written about in the next generation of MIL stories?

And what would the stories from MILs look like about their DILs.

There are plenty of stories on here about MILs who told all their friends how unreasonable the DIL was, but equally there are as many stories on here from DILs saying the same about MILs, how can we know which is true? Iyswim.

And why is it always the MIL who is in the spotlight. That doesn’t say much about the view of women as parents does it?

I am still very much in touch with my ILs from my marriage to eXH and I love them.

My now DP was removed from his biological parents as a child so it goes without saying that I wish them all manner of ill, but his foster family are... erm, interesting. His foster mum is very much the matriarch and is very demanding of people’s time but only on her terms e.g. she will have people round but not on a day when her football team are playing (whoever they are, I can’t remember.)

One of DP’s foster brothers is ok, but the other one is a sanctimonious arsehole. But it’s ok, he doesn’t like me and the feeling is mutual, so we have no contact. He actually tried to suggest that my life-limiting heart condition, which will one day see me on the transplant list, was brought about because I have strong opinions and dare to voice them on facebook. Hmm Clearly he’s a bit thick if he really believes that but still.... I removed him as a fb friend after that and he re-requested me almost immediately, I did not accept.

FelicityPike · 10/12/2020 14:26

My MIL forged my DH’s signature on a loan form, one of those ones where if you default the other guy pays.
£5k she took off us. Just as we were about to get married. She refused our invitation and refused to allow DH’s younger siblings (but still young adults) to attend.
Kept telling DH we should’ve sued her....

ChocolateCherrybomb · 10/12/2020 14:27

@FuzzyPuffling

Well, this is a nasty thread isn't it. "The crazier the better"?

Good luck to all of you who might be MILs in the future.

Reporting how someone behaves poorly in general or treats you horribly personally is not "nasty". The perpetrator is still the nasty one, telling others does not switch the nasty person label onto the victim. Calling categorically crazy behaviour crazy is not nasty either.

MIL's are not exempt, nor should they be. Raising another human being doesn't entitled you to behave horribly and get away with it while expecting silence from your victim and all who witnessed it.

Also, being a MIL in the future is not the same thing as being an entitled/abusive/hateful/vicious/hurtful/thieving MIL when and if you get there.

CorianderQueen · 10/12/2020 14:28

About a week later I came "home" from work and couldn't find my kitten. ExMIL informed me that she had put it in the garden because it was making her house smell... not her kitten just my one... I never saw that kitten again

How disgustingly abusive. I'd have taken her kitten as she clearly can't look after them.

YoniAndGuy · 10/12/2020 14:31

@MessyMummy15

More stories about that same exMIL keep popping into my head

When I had recently moved into her house I politely declined dinner one evening as I had already evening and she took it the wrong way. From then on she would bring my ex hot steaming full roast dinners etc up to the room and never bring me any dinners because "I was obviously too good for her food" I lived off crisps for the 9 months I was living there until I ended up in hospital severely ill and deficient in every victims you can think of. 😒

And your ex sat there and gorged his Lovely Mummykins Dinner and watched you eat crisps and said and did nothing?

What an absolute dicksplash.

JanieBP · 10/12/2020 14:31

What concerns me about these threads is that they don’t actually paint a very good picture of parenthood. After all, all these MILs were mums once, much like the majority of us on here. And I’m sure that if there were men posting on these threads there would be equally horrific stories of their MILs so I’m sure the issue is not unique to the parents of boys

Have you not heard the saying:

Have a daughter, it’s for life
Have a son until he gets a wife

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 10/12/2020 14:35

Actually, I strive to be a lovely MIL. I dearly love my son & daughter’s partners, I don’t intrude in their lives, and they know my door is always open.

My daughter in law chats to me all the time (via FaceTime, so difficult to get the wrong end of the stick or be two faced), and my soon to be son in law stayed here during both Lockdowns. Lovely guy.

Having a godawful mother in law may teach you how not to behave, just as my ex mother in law taught me the right way to be. If I can be a tiny fraction of the warm, loving & kind lady she is, then I know I’m doing a bloody good job.

puzzledquiz · 10/12/2020 14:35

I was so lucky in my pil, they would always help if they could, when I had dd2 who was a nightmare baby dh phoned her to see if she could help when he had to go back to work(had only started a new job a month before so couldn't take any more time off), she came the next day(4hr ferry journey+traveling) and stayed for 10 days!

PoppyOppy · 10/12/2020 14:36

@johnstownflood
Surely there must be some DILs that actually like their MIL ?

My first was a cow to me until one day I told her to fuck off. She then became my best bud because, as she said, ”PoppyOppy isn't afraid of me”

She even took my side when I divorced ex.

My second was a lovely lady, really welcoming and kind. Sadly she died 9 years ago and I miss her every day. Sad

Charcutaria · 10/12/2020 14:37

I'm sure that all you mothers of sons with the nasty Mil stories are going to be the best ever most perfect MILs NOT.

sqirrelfriends · 10/12/2020 14:37

My mil is great, she's human though so has her flaws (as we all do) but on the whole she's lovely.

My ex's mum was a piece of work and raised a complete mummy's boy:

Once during dinner she told him he was never to get married or have children (while I was present).

She told me off for stepping on the bath mat, I was meant to dry my feet in the cubicle before getting out.

She couldn't afford her lifestyle without his rent so when he wanted to finally move out to live with me, she started looking for houses we could all live in together, no thanks.

She charged his for the times I spent the night, even though he spent an equal amount of time at mine. I only found this out later and then she got offended when I refused to come visit any more.

I gave her a lift to the train station and she wouldn't put out her cigarette or open the window because it was cold outside and this was her last chance to have one before her journey. I'm asthmatic and it made me wheeze.

hansgrueber · 10/12/2020 14:37

@johnstownflood

I'm guessing you're not a MIL yourself yet OP ? I'm not either and I think I'm a pretty nice person but there is so much vitriol on MN against MILs that I'm feeling quite nervous at the prospect.

Surely there must be some DILs that actually like their MIL ?

These tales are naturally all one-sided, I'd love to hear the MIL's versions or what the men think of their MILs! Some DILs can be very hurtful, a friend was told by the DIL's mother that she would inform friend when she could go and see her first grandchild, 'they'll need a month or so to settle down'. A week after the 'little family' got home social media was full of photos of the baby with every Tom, Dick and Harry from the DIL's family and her friends but the paternal family still had to wait for the gatekeeper's nod.
puzzledquiz · 10/12/2020 14:38

( We got on well and shared a similar sense of humour-think dh felt left out at times when we were together)

CorianderQueen · 10/12/2020 14:38

@MessyMummy15

More stories about that same exMIL keep popping into my head

When I had recently moved into her house I politely declined dinner one evening as I had already evening and she took it the wrong way. From then on she would bring my ex hot steaming full roast dinners etc up to the room and never bring me any dinners because "I was obviously too good for her food" I lived off crisps for the 9 months I was living there until I ended up in hospital severely ill and deficient in every victims you can think of. 😒

Why didn't your ex share his food with you??
hashbrownsandwich · 10/12/2020 14:40

My exMIL is a pain but I always remember she used to make digs about my weight. Her trick when we went out to eat or to theirs to eat, she would always make a point of saying she wouldn't have a main as she was watching her weight. She would order/make a salad and then when my main would arrive she would literally take half! No jokes.
I had the last laugh, when her DS decided to run off with another woman, I didn't see her for 6 months. Then ExH started having contact with our kids at MIl's house. The first time I turned up to pick the kids up they were having a big extended family bbq. I walked in having lost nearly 4 stone. Her jaw dropped and she said 'Oh my god, you look like a supermodel'.
I just said 'thanks', got the kids and went Grin

Vivi0 · 10/12/2020 14:41

@FuzzyPuffling

Well, this is a nasty thread isn't it. "The crazier the better"?

Good luck to all of you who might be MILs in the future.

I’d much rather be in a position to not be able to contribute to this thread, but my MIL only has herself to blame for that. I’ve had police protection at my home, where my children sleep, because of her.

I very well may be a MIL in the future, and if any lesson has been learnt from my MIL, it is how to be a good one.

changefortheday · 10/12/2020 14:43

my MIL says things completely unthinkingly and seriously expects her son to put her first.
she's said many thoughtless and hurful things 'my son's wedding was the worst day of my life because I knew I'd lost him forever'; she completely blanks me every xmas, she came and stayed every weekend when we had our first (until I told DH either his mother left our house or I did); one christmas I had a 4 month old but still cooked dinner for everyone, then went and sat in a different room while they all ate because baby needed feeding and it made her and FIL uncomfortable.
On telling her about pregnancies the reactions started with 'but you can't I'm too young to be a grandma'; then 'another one? really' then 'I presume this one was an accident'.
She tries to visit every week and just sits and talks to DH - no one else (me or the children), and everyone treads on eggshells around her because in the past she's reacted very badly to being pulled up on stuff and made FIL and DH's life hell. Honestly - I'm dreading lockdown being over because at least she's stayed away (she's decided she's vulnerable and I'm fine with that - I mean technically she isn't but hey if it makes her happy to be 'special' and it keeps her out of my hair I'm OK with that)
phew - that was cathartic!

WhySoSensitive · 10/12/2020 14:44

But If you’re defending MILs then I could bet those Mils won’t tell there friends ‘oh I abused my DIL in today, it was hilarious making her cry because she couldn’t breast feed’

I repeat what I said earlier - some people are just horrible and also happen to be mother in laws.
I would never dream of telling my DIL that she’s such a ‘bad parent already’ because she can’t even breastfeed. So I’m already a better person than she is.

AngryBananaSund · 10/12/2020 14:48

There are good ones out there

Several years ago my wife’s parents came over for Christmas, things were ok but a little awkward as we’d never done this before. And then I was talking to MIL about our Sky TV (still a new thing at the time.) I had just finished explaining that channels came in packages and not individually. MIL thought about this for a moment and then said

‘Do you have a big package then?”

There was no awkwardness after that!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.