Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Discussion on inheritance - is it sometimes ok to give children different amounts.

522 replies

Whattheactual20201 · 21/11/2020 12:16

Was talking to parents the other day and then DB
We are a family of 3 siblings, I am the youngest at 28 then the eldest is 36.
I have 2 children soon to be 3, my own house with a very small mortgage and not much left to pay. We survive and have luxuries. I do have savings
DB who is a few years older has 1 child but they are trying for number 2 and has a house with an affordable mortgage and a great income.
Eldest is DS who has one child and one on the way. She has always worked as hard as us but does earn a lot less and rents has no savings and lives a bit more day to day than we do.

My parents have always told us the grandkids will have their own “ pot “ which will be equal.

However us as their children will get different amounts due to circumstances.
They would want to leave the house to sister
With w smaller cash inheritance
Then a bigger cash inheritance to me and DB ( it wouldn’t be as much as what the house is worth by any stretch )

I am ok with this and see their point in a way however DB feels a bit hurt they would leave the house to only one of us ?

OP posts:
Whattheactual20201 · 21/11/2020 14:35

I also don’t know the in and outside of financial cost for each of us as in how much was spent on DB education / extra curriculum in will do a guess at a heck of a lot more than us.

OP posts:
LoveMyKidsAndCats · 21/11/2020 14:36

Sounds like your brother has been left out alot. No wonder he is not happy.

AnotherEmma · 21/11/2020 14:36

So what you're effectively saying is that having a sick child trumps being a single parent?

While it makes sense to help out a child going through a difficult time, it should also be evened out. Of course none of you are going to be in the exact same situation. You can either split money equally or try and judge how much each child needs or "deserve" based on their specific circumstances - but I think that's a total minefield.

ancientgran · 21/11/2020 14:37

They haven't, though, have they? They only gave you £50k and haven't done the same for your brother or sister. Because circumstances were what they were, her brother and sister didn't have a child that was critically ill. What if the parents only had £50k, the OP needed that because of what was happening with their child, do you think the parents should have said, "Oh we have to be fair, we will give each of them £16,666." Might not have been enough to help OP and the siblings presumably didn't urgently need it.

I think all this, "It has to be fair" is rather childish.

I've read it so often on here, I've even heard of people going through late parents finances and working out what another sibling has been given and being annoyed about it. I've thought about it alot and I think I am going to regularly change bank/savings accounts and destroy details of the old accounts so no one can forensically go through my expenses and decide if how I spent my money or who I gave money to was OK with them.

ancientgran · 21/11/2020 14:38

No she's saying having a child with a high possibility of dying before their next birthday trumps pretty much everything.

ancientgran · 21/11/2020 14:40

I also don’t know the in and outside of financial cost for each of us as in how much was spent on DB education / extra curriculum in will do a guess at a heck of a lot more than us. I wondered about that, if you dropped out early and he was academic and has a wonderful career I suspect he was supported in education for longer than you?

Whattheactual20201 · 21/11/2020 14:40

I am not saying having a sick child trunks being a single parent
Which I have also raised both my child alone for 7 years.
I am saying at the time I was living on take out foods, trying to provide stability for an elder DC, getting daughter the right treatment.
I am the one saying that taking the 50 k out of my inheritance is fair and that my sister could do with assistance :/

OP posts:
Sarahandco · 21/11/2020 14:40

I think inheritance should be practical - if one is renting and the others almost own their properties then why not allow the sister the house if she would live in it. (assuming it is not a 10 bedroom place and you own a studio flat)

Sorry if this as already been covered. But you said you have 3 children and sister has one - if all children get an equal amount then there is an inequality there. Not saying all grandchildren should not get the same but pointing out that in reality things are rarely equal.

If the house is sold and divided in three you will all really loose out a bit.

AnotherEmma · 21/11/2020 14:40

"What if the parents only had £50k, the OP needed that because of what was happening with their child, do you think the parents should have said, "Oh we have to be fair, we will give each of them £16,666." Might not have been enough to help OP and the siblings presumably didn't urgently need it."

I guess you didn't read my post at 13.54, in which I wrote:
It was kind of them to give you the £50k when you needed it. But in their position I would have tried to redress the balance by offering your siblings money too - not necessarily immediately if they couldn't afford to give you all the money at once, but certainly as soon as possible afterwards.

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 21/11/2020 14:41

Above all, I really like that your parents are having this conversation openly now!

I think it’s a difficult one (putting aside scenarios involving disabilities). It’s all fine and good to have guiding principles about different careers paying differently in spite of equal efforts/skills/societal importance etc, and about life experiences until that point, but it’s not always that straightforward. I suspect my sibling regards it as largely luck that my salary is 2x hers, and certainly I don’t dispute that she works hard and some of the disparity is luck, but it’s also true that I am 10 years older, have a MSc whereas she has a level 3 qualification, and routinely work well over my hours! At the minute, I’m a single parent with a heavy mortgage and she has a partner and rents, so right now I’m very stretched and she has a much easier day to day quality of life, so tbh an unequal split in her favour right now would be tricky to stomach. 10 years down the line, with a much bigger dent in my mortgage, i think it would feel very different. (In practice, I don’t think there’ll be much/any of an inheritance for us anyway, which makes life simpler I guess...)
Adult DC make life choices, including which job to do, based on all sorts of things. I love my job but if money was no object, it isn’t exactly the one I’d choose. In relative terms that’s a lucky position to be in, but again comparing to my sister, she chose exactly the job she wanted to do. I wonder if your DB is coming a bit from this angle, that it wasn’t as straightforward as ‘his vocation was more lucrative than DSis’s vocation’ and an unequal inheritance sort of upsets his own balance there, in that he feels he compromised for pragmatic reasons and DSis has been able to truly ‘have it all’? I don’t think that’s exactly fair (I wouldn’t feel this way about my own DSis) but it’s one perspective.

I think also, looking at my wider family and others I know, that non-inheritance stuff is also often unfairly divided (some siblings benefiting from more help with childcare or living with family while saving up or whatever - sometimes because of favouritism, sometimes because the timing or geography worked out that way). It’s very difficult to make everything the same for all siblings, I guess the temptation can be to try to compensate for other things via an unequal inheritance but I think as soon as you introduce that element of comparison and judgment about ‘the right amount’, it becomes really fraught. For this reason I think I’d choose to split it equally between my DC.

Finally (too much to say Grin) I think that usually when families become resentful about inheritance, they’re mostly acting out resentments that were already there. If everyone feels valued and loved and genuinely likes their siblings, I can’t imagine how this sort of bitterness can fester (or how they can let money take centre stage in the context of parental death!). Not generally judging the adult DC in that scenario, I think it’s often symptomatic of wider dynamics they didn’t create, but I often think this gets overlooked in theoretical discussions about what makes for a “fair” inheritance.

Clymene · 21/11/2020 14:42

I think you owe it to your children to treat them fairly financially @ancientgran .

Everybody's lives work out differently - one sibling might marry someone super rich, another might have bought a property just before the market crashed, another might have had a sick child like the OP.

But rewarding (or otherwise) life choices and chances seems like you are putting monetary value on those things. There is still quite a lot of sibling rivalry in many families, even as adults. It seems a bit bizarre to really cement those feelings between your children after death by doling out your money unevenly.

Gwenhwyfar · 21/11/2020 14:42

"She has always worked as hard as us but does earn a lot less and rents has no savings

Meritocracy is a myth - she could be working just as hard and just be on a lower income due to circumstance."

Exactly. You see the right wingers come out on this thread, don't you.
The fairer way is to give to each child what they need. DB should get over himself as he's already lucky in life.

Whattheactual20201 · 21/11/2020 14:42

@ancientgran oh gosh he did all sorts I was more artistic in my bedroom kind of girl
He went to a very good university and never ever went without in that time.
They are all good people, have different strengths.

OP posts:
Charleyhorses · 21/11/2020 14:42

Well it's a dilemma and I can see why your brother feels that way.i can also see that your parents want to leave the planet knowing that their children are secure.
In our case, my parents were strict about leaving it equally between us. Me and dsis are mortgage free. Dbro hasn't got on the property ladder and is too old now.
Dmum is 80 and prob most of her money will go on care. Wish she had just given him a lump sum when it would have made a difference tbh.

movingonup20 · 21/11/2020 14:43

My parents are splitting the house equally by the savings are split differently, im the only one with kids so dm checked with my siblings and they wanted the cash and investments split 5 ways

TableFlowerss · 21/11/2020 14:44

Unless there’s a disability then I think it’s poor form to give more to one child over the other. I

Nothing divides a family like money. I think it could (and probably will) cause a rift that will be never be healed upon the parents.

On the back of that knowledge I would make it equal

randomer · 21/11/2020 14:44

Factor in that inheritance comes with grief.

CheltenhamLady · 21/11/2020 14:44

I think money left should always be split equally (barring disability) if the children have had the same opportunities. The fact that they chose different paths which affected earning capacity is irrelevant IMO.

We have an issue in our extended family which means that MIL wants to leave money to her GC and GGC but that will mean her DD/DS gets less.

Her DD needs/will need the money, we don't.

I think MIL should think about that and not penalise her DD, but DH is of the opinion that as his DSis has never worked a day in her life and chose to live on benefits, it is up to his Mum how she splits the estate and if she wants to leave legacies for the GC and GGC children she should be able to do that.

TableFlowerss · 21/11/2020 14:44

Parents death

Whattheactual20201 · 21/11/2020 14:45

@NellWilsonsWhiteHair it’s weird you say that because I suppose each sibling will have their own views on the family household and see it from their own experience.

In my view - DB was “ golden “ child but in his view that might of mean - pressure.

OP posts:
Parky04 · 21/11/2020 14:45

Should be split equal. I have been in a reasonable paid job and I am more comfortably well off than my sister. I have now been made redundant and now looking at minimum wage jobs. Circumstances can change very quickly.

Regretsandregrets · 21/11/2020 14:47

Even if the parents distribute their inheritance equally there is no guarantee the siblings will get on well with each other.As a parent your instinct is to ensure your childern's well- being and comfort and you do what it takes to make it happen.Doesnt always mean you spend EQUAL time and effort to achieve that.Its need based and that instinct stays even when the kids are grown up.
Luckily, with only one daughter things are a lot simpler for me!!

canigooutyet · 21/11/2020 14:48

Mine have decided for themselves what happens when I'm gone. (Life limiting illness so it does crop up). If there's anything left they want it to go to one sibling. They'd rather I spend what I need to to enjoy my life now and my pension goes to that dc.
My will reflects this and everyone is happy.

I got written out of various wills long time ago. If I'm ever put back in it wouldn't be because of anything good for me.

ancientgran · 21/11/2020 14:49

oh gosh he did all sorts I was more artistic in my bedroom kind of girl
He went to a very good university and never ever went without in that time

They are all good people, have different strengths.

So things haven't always been equal have they, they have been appropriate. Your brother got lots of support with his education which has presumably given him the ability to be a high earner, you got support when your child was so ill (glad she is doing well, nothing makes up for what you go through with a sick child does it) and now it is your sister's turn. Seems perfectly reasonable to me.

I wonder if people think your brother shouldn't have had support you didn't get or that it was wrong to support you in your grimmest time.

I had a friend who got really upset as her husband gave alot of money to his daughter to support her through uni, her daughter didn't go and she said it was so unfair. I said to her that one day her daughter might need some help for whatever reason. A few years passed, her daughter decided to do her A levels and go to uni and she then got her share. All that angst about nothing.

newusername2009 · 21/11/2020 14:49

I would expect my parents to want to split according to need and would be happy with that. Of course we can all do with some help but some need it more than others.