Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sister calls her new baby ex name

131 replies

Whattimes · 07/11/2020 06:58

My sister recently had a baby boy her 1st child. I was overjoyed and elated. She has called him the same name as my sons father who has caused a lot of stress disappointment and trauma both to me and to my son by his absence and other behaviour, mainly absence and not being involved (does not make contact on my sons Birthday, Christmas or provide any financial support). Now this name is shared with her husbands late father so I understand the sentimental value for them of this name. But I do nonetheless feel blindsided and I would have greatly appreciated if she was to forewarn me of their decision instead of making a public announcement. Perhaps it was a genuine oversight in the excitement of a new baby but seemingly they had decided upon the name some months before she said it felt right for them in the months before the birth. This sister was my birth partner and was heavily involved in my sons early years when his father was not around. I hope we can get back to where we were in our relationship. And I want to feel that close relationship to her boy also. Not to feel constantly reminded of these hurt feelings by my ex/sons father. I am concerned it may impact upon my son but acknowledge he is their son and the naming is essentially their choice. It's done now so I need to adapt and get used to this being my nephews name. She and her husband are to be my sons guardians in the unlikely and unfortunate event of me being unable to take care of him.

OP posts:
FeedMeSantiago · 07/11/2020 09:03

If it's a common name e.g. Thomas, James, Edward etc. OP's sister may not have made the connection and therefore didn't think to give her a heads up.

If it's an unusual name like Quentin or Ptolemy then it would have been more likely that OP's sister would have made the connection.

I suspect the name is reasonably common and the sister just didn't consciously think 'oh that's the same name as DN's father'.

emilybrontescorsett · 07/11/2020 09:04

Sounds like the dad chose the name. I feel for you ok but you will just have to put a brave face on it.

nanbread · 07/11/2020 09:04

My cousin divorced her abusive ex then a few years later married someone with the same name!

Can you come up with a nickname for your nephew?

RainingBatsAndFrogs · 07/11/2020 09:07

It sounds as if your ex left / disappeared quite a while ago.

I can understand it would have given you a bit of a jolt, but you are clearly still chewing and stewing about a man who is long gone.

This isn’t your DSis’s problem, and even less so her DH’s.

Look forwards: the name will quickly become associated with your darling nephew and seem like his name and his alone.

And it won’t impact your Dc AT ALL unless you stir it up.

Honestly; you will see the name as associated with your nephew, just as your DSis and BIL see it as her FIL’s name. Not your long departed ex.

Enjoy being an aunty Smile

Al1langdownthecleghole · 07/11/2020 09:08

@Kcar

I am sorry but husband’s late father definitely trumps your ex.

Imagine how her husband feels knowing that his dad will never get to know his child.

It’s not about you for them at all. Nor should it be

This.

And while I appreciate you are upset, I think your suggestion that they could have used a name that means a lot to them as a middle name is pretty outrageous.

OVienna · 07/11/2020 09:10

Normally I sympathise with the OP on these threads. However it is certainly not "inconsiderate" for your sister in law to name the baby after her own father! Blimey. I am not surprised she didn't ask because frankly had your response been "yes, I mind" it wouldn't have achieved anything for her to know that, if she knew she'd do it anyway.

I do think if it is a parent's name she is well within her rights.

AllsortsofAwkward · 07/11/2020 09:10

Youre making youre sisters new additional about you let it ago youre being unfair and silly.

OVienna · 07/11/2020 09:11

Sorry I meant her husband's father.

Cocolapew · 07/11/2020 09:13

Are people being obtuse on purpose? The op knows the baby is named after the the late FIL, but there was no reason for her DSis not to mention it in advance to her. For those saying that she probably wasn't thinking of the ex when choosing the name, that may be so, but who has a named a baby without thinking of anyone else they know with the name?

dottiedodah · 07/11/2020 09:13

I see that you probably feel hurt by this.However I think you are overthinking things somewhat TBH. Your DS and BIL have named him after his DGF. Not your unpleasant ex! just an unfortunate coincidence. There are many names that belong to good people, also sadly shared by prisoners/murderers .Just a name is all .Say his name is William for example .look up famous people with that name, many good and bad I think!

workhomesleeprepeat · 07/11/2020 09:14

With kindness, you are taking this far too personally. Unless the name is very unique surely you have come across other people with this name.

drinkstoomuchwine · 07/11/2020 09:15

OP I understand - your feelings are valid. I can’t understand how anyone could dismiss it so breezily. Of course no one ‘owns’ a name but doesn’t mean we all go around acting like our naming decisions won’t impact others. Your (close) sister was insensitive not to have talked to you about this - least so you could be prepared. Echo other posters that hopefully in time and the frequent use of saying the name in context of your lovely new nephew will lessen the hurt and positive associations will come from it.

OrangeCinnamon1 · 07/11/2020 09:15

@FeedMeSantiago

If it's a common name e.g. Thomas, James, Edward etc. OP's sister may not have made the connection and therefore didn't think to give her a heads up.

If it's an unusual name like Quentin or Ptolemy then it would have been more likely that OP's sister would have made the connection.

I suspect the name is reasonably common and the sister just didn't consciously think 'oh that's the same name as DN's father'.

This👆
gottakeeponmovin · 07/11/2020 09:20

I honestly think you should consider therapy if his name is a trigger - it sounds like it's a common name and so you will hear it everywhere. Your sister probably didn't even consider it - and really why should she. The baby is named for his grandfather not your ex.

Scarlettpixie · 07/11/2020 09:21

Your son thinks if his dad as dad and not by his first name. Let him know why the name was chosen and leave it as that. Once you get to know baby you will develop a positive association with the name. Give it time.

Fouroclockonamarblemorning · 07/11/2020 09:26

It will only impact on your son if he sees you letting it impact on you. The baby was named after a loved family member who was presumably born way before your ex partner. You are thinking way too much into this.

Please don’t let this spoil what should be a happy time for you all. 💐

Twylar · 07/11/2020 09:27

Hi OP, hope you are ok. I think this shows how much distress your ex has caused you for you to have a reaction like this.
Try to remember it was the person though and not the name. As others have said you will have positive connection to the name now and that will trump the negative because you will have a lovely relationship with your nephew.

I think you are putting into perspective already because you know he is named for the other relative and that's good so hold on to that.

Don't mention this to your sister. Not worth impacting your relationship with her which seems close. I know it seems as if she has been insensitive but she obviously really likes the name and it is just a name really and i would think she would never have thought about it having this type of impact on you. (Not minimising your feelings because obviously you have been very hurt by this person and therefore it's a normal reaction in that sense).

Enjoy your nephew x

Cocolapew · 07/11/2020 09:29

Hearing the name outside the home isn't the ops problem though, it's her sister blindsiding her by calling her son it. A quick conversation to let the op knows and to say it was after her BILs dad wouldn't have been hard to do.

PDof · 07/11/2020 09:32

@Whattimes

On a side note. I am new to this. Please can someone tell me what is the meaning of OP? Is it opinion? Thanks.
Haha how cute?

Someone under 50 who doesn't know what OP means. Uravvinalaf

pinkyredrose · 07/11/2020 09:40

Maybe she put off telling you because you're a drama queen and she couldn't be bothered with the fallout spoiling a happy time. 'Blindsided'? Ffs get a grip on yourself, do you honestly expect them not to use a name they've set their hearts on because it's the same as your loser ex? Hmm

pinkyredrose · 07/11/2020 09:43

. I hope we can get back to where we were in our relationship

What do you mean by this, have you fallen out with your sister?

and I would have greatly appreciated if she was to forewarn me of their decision instead of making a public announcement you're rather full of your own importance.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 07/11/2020 09:47

She was your birth partner and a huge support to you throughout the early years of your sons life.

Are you possibly a bit jealous that she has her own family to focus on now and need a tangible reason to be angry about that?

I guess this boils down to - is your love for your sister and nephew greater than your hate for your exes name?

Rhine · 07/11/2020 09:49

@scubadive

It’s absolutely outrageous and the people in here saying otherwise obvious havnt been through a painful divorce.

My ex’s name makes me tense if ever .i hear it and immediately a whole chest of very unhappy memories are bought back.

It is incredibly insensitive your sister to choose that name and to not tell you in advance shows tga5 she new this.

I couldn’t be close to a child with my ex’s name I think of all the names to choose from this is an unforgivable hateful thing for your sister to do.

I restate, people who havnt spent years of suffering with someone are in no position to say it’s only a name.

Seriously? You sound like hard work. Get a fucking grip.
JammyGem · 07/11/2020 09:51

Sorry OP, YABVU. I understand how the reminder may be upsetting but honestly as a new mother it wouldn't occur to me to change my preferred baby name just because its shared with my sister's ex - especially if it has sentimental meaning.

S00LA · 07/11/2020 09:54

@Northernparent68

It’s just a name, you are likely to meet many people with your ex-partners name.

Maybe your nephew will help you associate the name with positive feelings.

It’d be a mistake to let this damage your relationship with your sister.

This is excellent advice.

Please think about getting some therapy to help you move on.