Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why accidental pregnancies are so common?

552 replies

Change17 · 12/08/2020 19:00

I’m probably going to get a lot of negative feedback for this. But I’m in my 5th week of lockdown in Melbourne and my mind is asking all sorts of questions.

I’ve honestly never fully understood how so many women find themselves accidentally pregnant. I’m not talking here about contraception not working. I’m aware condoms can break and the pill isn’t always a 100% guarantee.

But if you’re not taking any precautions against getting pregnant, how is it such a shock when the tests come back positive?
I admit I’ve only had sex with a man once when I was 17. Wasn’t long after that that I realised I was gay so I’m not as knowledgable as I could be when it comes to having sex with men, but they always know when ejaculation is imminent yes? As in, there’s a warning period and time to pull out? (Sorry to be blunt.)

As I say I totally understand contraception is not always completely reliable and in all honesty the reason I even started to think about this was watching Desperate Housewives which I’m currently doing a re-run or for the first time in years. Lynette always talks about how she only wanted one child but kept getting pregnant and was “surprised” each time.
I can’t count the amount of times at uni I’d go with friends to get the morning after pill or pregnancy tests and I’d never say anything but was always low key thinking “how does this happen so often???” If you’re not using a condom or on the pill or another form of contraception... then why not do everything else possible to avoid the risk?
I’m fully prepared to be told I’m being way too black and white about this or whether else is coming my way.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 01:09

I also can't understand how even a naive person would imagine that this (awesome sounding, but as far as I can see not yet available) option of a 'reversible vasectomy' would assist with this.

The thread has focused on women getting pregnant when not using contraception (although there is a man there too who could use a condom/ decline PIV and do something else, and there have been plenty of posts that it's men who push for unprotected sex pretty often...)

Anyway. If the men aren't putting a condom on I can't see how the availability of a reversible treatment to cause infertility would help. Specifically in the sort of situations op mentions. Uni students going to get map (surely that's responsible?).

A lot of things on this thread I think show that your ideas are confused op, as you said yourself, as you have v little experience of het relationships and the dynamics.

Why not read a load of threads on here about this topic and see what they say?

Change17 · 13/08/2020 01:10

indeoestmeafiducia I think you need to reread what I posted... I never said anything about you being disrespectful I actually said the exact opposite ?

OP posts:
winerack19 · 13/08/2020 01:13

NiceGerbil

I've been following this thread closely and you are coming across as a bully now. Interesting how you chose to ignore my previous post in which I tagged you.
When I found myself knocked up at 19, through being reckless and "risking it" with my boyfriend, I absolutely took the bollocking i got from my sisters on the chin and wasn't in the least bit offended when my best friend said something along the lines of "you idiot why didn't he wrap it up!!" Because guess what? She was right. As were my sisters.

Do you think that any responsibility should be taken at all ? Because it doesn't sound like it. You're poking and poking and poking and honestly it makes for uncomfortable reading

KeepingPlain · 13/08/2020 01:17

Even the map can fail, it wouldn't be the first time.

People can blame men too for pushing for unprotected sex, but you can say no. If he persists, that's rape and you've got more problems sadly than just pregnancy. That's when you need more help.

There are loads of women though who happily use the pull out method. There was a thread a while back of a woman using the pull out method with a guy she had known for mere weeks. Everyone was in uproar about it. Now suddenly its fine and a surprise? Confused

Change17 · 13/08/2020 01:19

nicegerbil
Are you deliberately misinterpreting what I’m saying here? I feel you must be because surely after all this time there’s no way you still don’t get it.

The majority of the women who have posted about their accidental and surprise pregnancies have been because of things like, they didn’t think they could get pregnant, assumed they were too old, had mishaps with their pill
And the few who have commented saying they got pregnant through chancing it (knowing they’re both completely fertile) have basically said that they don’t consider it to be a surprise because they knew that sex with no precaution = good chance of pregnancy.

You’re the one who is repeatedly trying to make it seem like I’m saying something that I’m not. That any woman who finds herself pregnant despite trying to avoid it is an absolutely awful sinful disgrace of a person. Just stop with this narrative it’s so tiring and as I say I feel you are being deliberately very obtuse at this point.

OP posts:
Osirus · 13/08/2020 01:31

It’s not down to lack of sex education. Every consenting adult knows how babies are made.

In my experience, it’s either because one party deep down actually wants to get pregnant, and the other reason is just down to basic biology. We are mammals after all, and we do, whether you like it or not, respond to and are led by our very basic instincts. I’m guilty of this myself. During my fertile period, sex is ALL I can think about. It drives me to distraction. A condom wouldn’t even cross my mind; I just want sex.

We’ve been having unprotected sex for about 10 years. Used withdrawal prior to that for a few years. Never been pregnant naturally- we had IVF.

If it happens, it happens.

lyralalala · 13/08/2020 01:34

It’s not down to lack of sex education. Every consenting adult knows how babies are made.

It can be down to a lack of education about contraceptions. For example, a good number of women don't realise the MAP doesn't work if you've already ovulated, or that an emergency coil is actually more effective than the MAP.

Pinkbunny2811 · 13/08/2020 01:37

@Osirus sorry but I don't agree. I think it is often a lack of education. You wouldn't believe some of the things I have heard over the years working with pregnant women. And it works both ways. I once heard of someone who couldn't get pregnant and then turns out they weren't having penetrative sex because, culturally, no one had taught them and they never found out any other way.

P.s sorry you had to go through ivf. We are just starting our journey.

winerack19 · 13/08/2020 01:39

Osirus I agree with this. And I don't understand why so many pregnancies are referred to as an 'accident'. As you say, we all know how babies are made.
There are of course exceptions to this. For example say a couple who have very old school value parents and would disprove of a pregnancy before marriage, then saying it was an "accident" probably softens the blow and won't cause quite so much disappointment!

But finding yourself pregnant when having done nothing to prevent it should not come as a shock and somehow it so often does. Admittedly you see this more often in tv shows and soap operas- a lady staring in disbelief at the pregnancy test because how on earth could she possibly be pregnant when no contraception/withdraw was used.

NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:03

My first post on this thread:

'What a strange thread.

People get accidentally pregnant through:
Contraceptive failure
MAP failure
Hoping for the best with withdrawal
Getting to the point and having no condoms and thinking fuckit
Being a bit pissed/ drugged and thinking fuckit
Not having much choice (coercion etc)
Being young naive and trusting

Etc etc

Then of course some people people will say it was an accident if they decide to keep it when they know they would be judged

Eg
Too young
Too old
Too large an age gap or too small an age gap to existing kids
Not financially secure
Single
Got a few kids already

And so on

Is it really honestly that baffling to what seems to be a lot of posters :/'

I can't see anything wrong with that?

OP has mentioned

Taking her uni friends to get map and not understanding why they need it (really? And that's a method to prevent pregnancy surely?)

How reversible vasectomies are a great solution (providing no links. I looked it up. I don't think it's on the market yet but op has not confirmed or said where she found the videos about it she watched). Even though lots of people were ??? about the whole thing.

Highlighted women getting pregnant on purpose. (Why? Not provided an aim).

Talked about women 'crying into' positive tests.

And on and on.

She has really upset at least one poster on here and not acknowledged it.

Nothing has touched a nerve with me. I'm responding to my reading of ops posts. Which are not pleasant reading, to me.

Bananabread8 · 13/08/2020 02:08

I think you have a good point OP. I think maybe some people think they won’t fall on that particular time then do it does happen when you least expect.

Change17 · 13/08/2020 02:15

NiceGerbil why are you ONCEagain having a go at me about the damn Vasectomy think. Let it go!! I admitted

Yo I hadn’t done enough research and naively took it to be a good idea when hearing a it. I also have stated maybe 3 times now that I PERSONALLY don’t think it’s a great idea, but that I’ve seen it mentioned as a possible method of precaution since so many men are more than happy to not use condoms and then get angry at a woman for deciding she doesn’t want to keep the baby.

You have continually chosen to completely ignore what I’ve written, put words in my mouth, twist things I’ve said to suit your agenda (as we can see with the vasectomy topic)

If I’ve upset someone for wondering why when zero methods of contraception are used, women are shocked to find they’re pregnant then, that’s frankly odd. If I’ve upset someone because they’ve chosen to twist my words and make it seem like I’m suggesting things that I’m not, then no I’m not sorry and that’s on them not me.

Not sure where I once stayed not understanding the use of the morning after pill. Again your own bizarre twist on my words to fulfil a bizarre agenda. You honestly just come across as mean, vindictive, petty and frankly very manipulative in the way you’ve tried to twist my words time and time again. I wonder when you’ll give up. It’s not a good look.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:19

Quit the personal attacks please. I am responding to your posts.

'so many men are more than happy to not use condoms and then get angry at a woman for deciding she doesn’t want to keep the baby.'

I don't think this is common? Where's do you get that idea? Most men who have irresponsible sex resulting in pregnancy want the girl/ woman to have an abortion.

Where do you get the idea that most fathers of unexpected pregnancies want to keep the baby?

winerack19 · 13/08/2020 02:20

NiceGerbil

The fact that you have not picked apart a single comment from another poster, despite some of them being far harsher in opinion and said with a far more judgemental tone than OP's, says a lot about you and how you seem utterly insistent on vilifying OP.

You have also refused to comment on my own messages that I have tagged you in as it goes against what you are saying.
As someone who at 19 did in fact "cry into a positive pregnancy test", I take full responsibility for my recklessness and as I said, took the bollockings from my sister and friends on the chin. I am not in the least bit offended by the idea that being dismayed and horrified at being pregnant when no contraception was used, is rather silly.

As I said you are really coming across as a bully in the way you are targeting OP yet the numerous "because people are stupid" and similar comments have slipped under your radar.
Ease up a little. Next you'll be asking for a photo of OP to throw darts at.

NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:21

You said in your op you don't understand why women can get pregnant by accident.

Then later you said you couldn't believe the number of times you accompanied uni friends to get map.

If they are getting map they are being responsible. They are looking to prevent a possible pregnancy.

NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:22

She's the op.

Of course I'm responding to her :/

Change17 · 13/08/2020 02:23

nicegerbil you cannot be serious. You don’t think this happens? What kind of bizarre world do you live in.

Honestly you’re just being unreasonable now and it’s like you’re deliberately saying ridiculous things to upset or anger me. What are you getting from this? Is it fun for you?

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:24

They haven't slipped under my radar.

It's not usual to address every single post you disagree with on a thread.

Op started the thread and said she knew it would be contraversial.

I'm responding to her.

And I don't check my mail every 2 secs, and it's considered bad manners to tag a poster on a thread where they are actively posting.

NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:25

What do I don't think happens? You need to be more specific.

Change17 · 13/08/2020 02:29

nicegerbil oh stop it. The more this continues the more I think you’re some sort of troll. You know exactly what I was referring to as I was replying to your post which you tagged me in so it’s obvious where my response was directed. You’re relentless how are you not bored yet of this.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:34

Have I tagged you? I don't usually tag people. Sorry about that if I did..

You're still not answering any of my questions. At all.

And troll hunting is banned on MN fyi. If you suspect a troll the thing to do is report.

NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 02:35

Most recent one.

What do you think, I think, doesn't happen.

I can't answer if you don't tell me what you're referring to.

Change17 · 13/08/2020 02:44

NiceGerbil honestly, you’ve worn me down. You’ve twisted my words from the start. Implied that I myself am implying things which I’m not. Completely manipulated things I’ve said. Been horribly dismissive about things I’ve admitted I don’t have a huge amount of education on. Done your absolute best to condescend me. Picked apart every little thing I’ve said yet not responded to a single comment anyone else has made. Refused to acknowledge anyone who has disputed some of the crap you’ve said. Been deliberately obtuse on a number of occasions about the ways in which some women fall pregnant. Do you chose someone every day to target and just wear down until they give in? Because this is me waving my white flag. I truly can’t be bothered anymore so, you win. That’s what you’ve wanted to hear from the start of this vitriol I assume ? Congratulations.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 13/08/2020 03:10

Well, no.

I have responded in good faith to your posts.

If you feel attacked by that then I'm sorry. What did you want to get out of this thread? You said in your op that you knew it would be a tricky topic.

My best advice is to

Read lots of relevant threads on here. Consider the situations of the women. And all the different sorts of responses.

Consider that a het sex dynamic may be a piece that you need to give more consideration to.

And if you post a thread again on this, maybe don't do it in AIBU and engage with points eg women say it as they know they will be judged otherwise.

I personally am really uncomfortable with your quick acceptance that women do it accidentally on purpose a lot, but that's probably another thread.

Graphista · 13/08/2020 04:08

Your OWN understanding of heterosexual sex and conception is fairly dubious too!

So quite honestly being disparaging when you don't understand it yourself is a bit of a cheek!

So you're right there are a lot of people who aren't knowledgable enough and you're one of them.

I had an accidental pregnancy at 18 while on the combined pill and taking it completely properly, none missed, none late, no stomach upsets, no antibiotics, nothing that I would have reasonably expected to have affected the efficacy. But I was having a lot of sex at the time and every method has a failure rate, plus that age is particularly fertile as was the man I was dating at the time - he now has 4 dc with his wife and she fell pregnant quickly each time.

Since then when not actively ttc I've used 2 methods of contraception at all times, 1 hormonal and condoms.

The 2 pregnancies I've had since were both planned.

Out of the people I know very very few have had GENUINELY accidental pregnancies but a good number have had either "accidental" pregnancies due to not understanding conception/contraception properly, and a couple where quite honestly the man didn't know the woman wasn't on the pill! Shocking, disappointing and rare but it DOES happen!

Mostly it's due to people, women mainly not understanding how conception and contraception work.

Not entirely their fault there's so much misinformation and so many myths and I've also found an awful lot of gps/nurses assume that patients are knowledgable without checking with them!

Certainly I had to at one stage point out to dd that diarrhoea can interfere with the pill, no hcp had told her and she had a horrible upset stomach once about 6 months after starting on the pill and ended up bleeding unexpectedly. She couldn't understand why.

The MAP only works if taken at a certain stage in the woman's cycle and even then there's no real "proof" that it works as a pregnancy may not have occurred anyway.

I also knew one poor woman who tried many different methods and kept getting pregnant - inc after her husbands vasectomy and yes after the check up that it had worked. He doubted the paternity on that occasion and was proven wrong it was definitely his child. She was then sterilised herself and that seemed to work...for 2.5 years and then pregnant again! Admittedly different chap by this point but still! Just bonkers!

Men need to be MUCH better at taking responsibility for their own fertility and sexual health.

I "came of age" in terms of age of consent at the height of the "aids crisis" and I personally think a lot of people are VERY complacent about such things now.

I think it's very irresponsible that sexual health isn't being taught in the same way as it was then.

I was also a single mum following split from ex and while it's good that the stigma has been reduced I think it's possibly become too acceptable?

Certainly we need men to take more responsibility for the children they create as at the moment it's STILL women bearing the brunt of the financial, practical and emotional responsibility of child rearing.

That makes it difficult for me to understand why women take the risks they do, we even see posts on here about women considering "trapping" men by stopping hormonal contraception without telling their sexual partner.

While the man should of course take responsibility for his own fertility I can understand the feeling of betrayal.

I think as well as contraception and sexual health the facts of life re child maintenance and the costs of raising a child should also be taught

There also seem to be a lot of medics who don't understand biology given the number of women, particularly on MN, who were 'told by a doctor they were infertile'

@InDeoEstMeaFiducia You're quite right.

While this is possible I've generally found drs tend NOT to talk in definites but patients misunderstand - the onus is still on the drs to be clear but barring certain conditions and surgeries there's really no such thing as INfertility but more reduced fertility. Few people are completely infertile.

"I would certainly have done my research" but people do...or think they do and are misled by misinformation everywhere.

On here I've noticed a significant increase in people advocating the rhythm method claiming that certain apps make it as effective as the pill! Which is utter nonsense frankly!

I've seen at least 3 posts on this thread alone that have mentioned they were breastfeeding - breastfeeding is NOT a contraceptive method!

And that's all WITHOUT the factor of coercion/rape within relationship and even men tampering with contraception which I am also aware of having happened in real life.

There's a dreadful amount of women and girls trapped in situations where they have no choice in the matter.

What surprises me is when people say "i got pregnant 3 times whilst taking the pill". I would have thought after getting pregnant the first time you'd choose a different method of contraception

I would agree with that - after my first unplanned pregnancy I no longer trusted the pill and doubled up, seemed a natural reaction to me.

@LakieLady He is still responsible for his own fertility I honestly couldn't be with a man that didn't parent and support his child no matter the circumstances of conception.

Op - NOBODY is saying you shouldn't take an interest - but you SHOULD lose the smug attitude given:

1 You've little personal experience of hetero sex inc the pressures women are put under by men

2 Your own knowledge on the subject is clearly lacking

3 you've made unnecessarily nasty remarks on the subject

It's possible to discuss without looking down your nose at people when if you weren't a lesbian, based on your own knowledge gaps you'd have likely been one of us! And even if you'd done everything "correctly" you could have had an unplanned pregnancy - and that applies to all the smug people on the thread!

Vasectomy is NOT always reversible, it is explained to men that while it can RARELY be successfully reversed that it should be considered a permanent contraception. Likewise female sterilisation.

You've basically spat the dummy because you were called out on your smug prejudice and started trying to play the "homophobia" card - not on!

Btw I'm speaking as a bisexual woman with many lesbian friends.

A woman who is TRULY passionate about women's rights DOES NOT use an issue central to womanhood to put other women down!

could you please point me in the direction of where I said I would not make the same mistakes? numerous posts where you've said you would "educate yourself better" take more of an interest if it affected you directly etc that's the same implication!

You HAVE been goody and confrontational throughout. You've made several comments admitting you're judgmental towards women who've experienced an unplanned pregnancy or even a scare inc your own friends - well supposedly friends. I very much doubt you'd still have them as friends if they knew what you really thought of them.