Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy most of my families clothes secondhand

168 replies

Rowrowboat · 14/11/2019 12:28

I am very thrifty when it comes to clothing as I feel it’s obviously better for the environment and you can usually get much better quality clothes for much cheaper. It’s always been the way I’ve shopped and I’ve never really thought much of it. I’m by no means poor but I’d rather have the money in the bank or spend it on something else.

In the last couple of weeks I’ve had several negative comments about this. Firstly when I mentioned I’d brought 5 babygrows for £1 from a local charity shop for my youngest about how yucky it was that other babies would have worn them any maybe got poo in them!

Secondly when I was complimented on my secondhand but hardly used DMs, the person said they didn’t know how I could wear shoes that have been on other people’s smelly feet. And just now, my colleague saying they’d spent £100 on a Christmas Day outfit for their toddler granddaughter. When I said I couldn’t bring myself to spend that kind of money on clothes and that mine would be wearing her sisters hand me down, didn’t I want to buy something new for her instead of putting her in all of her older sisters clothes, which were probably secondhand when I brought them anyway? It felt like a real dig at me and that it was obviously something my colleagues had discussed previously.

I’d like to point out that me and my family are always well turned out and clean and it got me thinking, do people genuinely look down on people who buy second hand? And why do so many people think that just because somethings been worn or used by someone else, it’s in some way gross!?

OP posts:
londonrach · 15/11/2019 06:47

Everyone buys mixture of secondhand and new i know so vv common. Dont worry just do what works for you

Millie2013 · 15/11/2019 07:17

I don’t judge those who choose to spend £££ on a toddler outfit and I’ve splashed out on such outfits (albeit never to the tune of £100), but I do get a buzz from finding a charity shop bargain

Probably the best was an immaculate ski jacket, which was part of the 5 items for £1, in a local shop, at the end of winter. That 20p jacket saw DD through one winter at nursery, it’s currently making its way through 2xDD of a close friend and will then be passed onto another mutual friend’s DD for playing at the stables

And the £3.99 John Smith wax jacket I picked up for DD, which was almost £200 RRP

I’ve found jojo maman, joules, frugi, boden etc. They all wash well and you’d never know. Now DD is at school, she doesn’t need as many clothes, but I still can’t resist a peek in charity shops on the way past

ItIsWhatItIsInnit · 15/11/2019 07:23

I love second hand, and have only worn second hand or self-made for the past few years. If you watch documentaries like The True Cost, there is no way in hell you could support the modern fashion industry with the immense pollution and slave labour they produce. The clothes nowadays are shite too, I don't want to wear floral dark green cold-shoulder ruffles polyester dresses like literally every other person.

I do like in a MC town though, which means the charity shops have nice stuff in. In student towns, the charity shops are full of cheap shite from Boohoo.

BeanBag7 · 15/11/2019 07:27

I'm with you OP. However I've never had much luck with childrens clothing in charity shops - they usually have one or two items in each size and I've never found anything from a decent brand.

I tend to buy baby clothes second hand on facebook selling sites or ebay. It means I can afford brands I really like, such as Frugi, which I wouldnt be able to buy brand new. DD always gets lots if compliments and I feel I have to say it was second hand as I don't want people to think I spent £100 on an outfit!

thebadcop · 15/11/2019 07:29

I am not from the UK but from Germany.

It's pretty standard there to pass esp children's clothes around.

I find that many people (not all) in the UK are extreme snobs when it comes to second hand/hand me down clothes.

We use a lot of second hand clothes (charity shop, eBay and hand me downs). My kids are very well dressed. I just don't tell people anymore as I too often the the bumface response...

EntropyRising · 15/11/2019 07:36

I can't think of anything thats screams cheap more than dressing a brand new baby in some old baby grow you found in a charity shop that's probably been covered in all sorts of bodily fluids and all scratchy through multiple washes....what a welcome to the world that is!

Unhinged. A hot wash is all you need.

PineappleDanish · 15/11/2019 07:36

As a charity shop volunteer a lot of the children's clothes we get aren't worth selling on. If we put out stuff which is stained, torn, misshapen or faded on the knees it just doesn't sell so we send it straight for recycling.

The stuff worth selling is the smart clothes, party dresses, formal shirts, coats, jackets, things like Brownie hoodies or Cub polo shirts, fancy dress.. We also get quite a lot of never-worn kids stuff still with the tags on either direct from a retailer or from a donor, that usually sells a bit better.

LucaFritz · 15/11/2019 07:41

There loss OP i can't fathom people who think this way and are all the more poorer for it Hmm i have a relative who thinks like this and is aghast at anything 2nd hand they have the mentatily of "i can afford to buy new everything so i will" yes love but you'd be even richer if you got 2nd hand stuff Hmm mind boggling. Ah well more bargains for us to have Grin

Myshinynewname · 15/11/2019 08:02

I don’t have much time to shop in charity shops but we were lucky enough to have a lot of clothes and toys handed down for our children and we passed on what we could when we had finished with it. I like to buy each of them some of their own clothes as well, so that they can choose for themselves. Very often hand me downs become their firm favourites because they belonged to their big cousin or friend first and they want to look like them!

woodhill · 15/11/2019 08:41

I think there are nappy libraries set up now?

Butchyrestingface · 15/11/2019 09:22

My posh, rich colleague is a charity shop superfan. Whenever we travel to some new town for work, her colleagues are off exploring the sights and she’s sifting her way through the local charity stores. She is always immaculately turned out and can smell a bargain at 💯 paces. And she is proper posh.

That said, I think OP may simply need to learn to say “thank you” in response to any compliments about her attire and simply leave it at that. And definitely desist from the ”I couldn’t bring myself to...” comments. They sound as judgey as fuck.

aprilanne · 15/11/2019 10:04

I remember reading a piece and they said that middle class buy more second hand things if they can because they like bit money in bank and less well off would not be seen dead in them because they see it as a sign of poverty
My parents were just normal working class people but would have cringed to go to charity shops .I love a rummage but have never for my children just shows it sticks how you were brought up

BeautifulTrauma1 · 15/11/2019 10:22

I think as well with the rise of apps such as depop it's made it cool to buy vintage or second hand.

I've been in charity shops before but it's the smell in there that puts me off and I've never actually bought anything, however get me on depop and there is loads of great things, usually never worn. My best ever buy was a brand new Jack Wills shirt I'd wanted when it was originally out for sale but sold out, for £8 including postage instead of the £54.95 I'd have paid in store!

All of my clothes growing up and now are brand new other than the depop items, but I do buy clothes from the top end of the high street so they tend to last a lot longer.

theruffles · 15/11/2019 10:30

YANBU! A lot of my DD's clothes are second hand, brought from charity shops or eBay. It pains me to pay full price when they wear them for such a short space of time before growing out of them. I love finding things for her at a fraction of the cost but which come from brands where I trust the quality (John Lewis, Boden, M&S). It lets us stretch quite a small budget further.

Some things that I know she won't wear very often - things like puddle suits or rain macs - I always buy second hand. If it looks in good condition and is washed, I don't see the problem in buying them preloved. If people have looked down on me for it, I don't care!

I have started to think about it more in terms of our environmental impact too. I'm becoming less comfortable buying clothes new from stores and think it's better to try and re-use things if possible. I've recently had a lovely wool coat from a charity shop which is very warm for colder days.

gingergiraffe · 15/11/2019 11:16

My daughter, now grown up, has always been much smaller than her peers. She loved getting hand me downs from her friends as they obviously had the seal of approval! Even now her friends often pass clothes onto her though some are not her style, but they are usually more expensive clothes that have hardly been worn. Nothing wrong with second hand.

gingergiraffe · 15/11/2019 11:20

Modern charity shops, well the ones I visit don’t seem to smell a bit off anymore. Quite up market. Charity shops in more affluent areas sell real bargains these days. No shame there.

Skyejuly · 15/11/2019 11:20

I'd rather buy good quality second hand then cheap new. I buy 90% of our clothes second hand.

Thestrangestthing · 15/11/2019 11:29

I don't know where people find these clothes in charity shops. The ones around here have nothing.
I don't mind second hand things, charity shops however all have that old horrible musty smell and apart from the odd toy, I don't buy anything from them.
I do give all our old clothes to charity though.

Thehop · 15/11/2019 11:31

We have mainly second hand clothes. The stuff we buy new is because I know I can pass it down to younger brothers.

Divebar · 15/11/2019 12:26

I don't know where people find these clothes in charity shops

I live in a nice area and find lots of good brands - although lots are not in my size obviously. When I’ve looked in my home town though (which is in a less affluent area) I’ve seriously been unable to find anything I would buy. My aim is nice quality and lightly used and I think it’s probably worth a trip to a neighbouring area. If you don’t have any success locally you could look on eBay or Depop - although the downside is you obviously don’t get to try things on.

Skyejuly · 15/11/2019 12:52

I mainly use ebay or the pre owned kids shops here tTher than charity shops x

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 15/11/2019 13:27

I'm not sure I'd want a pre-owned kid, @Skyejuly! WinkGrin

Skyejuly · 15/11/2019 13:34
Halloween Grin
OverthinkingThis · 15/11/2019 14:45

I can't think of anything thats screams cheap more than dressing a brand new baby in some old baby grow you found in a charity shop that's probably been covered in all sorts of bodily fluids and all scratchy through multiple washes....what a welcome to the world that is!

... aaaand that's pretty much exactly why I'm prefectly happy to dress DC in second hand clothes but I don't tend to bring it up in conversation!

DangerClose · 15/11/2019 14:47

I can't think of anything thats screams cheap more than dressing a brand new baby in some old baby grow you found in a charity shop

I can't think of anything that screams pathetic more than making a post like this.