But BDo83 why are the two things not comparable? At the point where she asked you to choke her first time, presumably you’d never been in a situation like that before, because it was the first time, so if there was a first time for one thing, why would there not be a first time that someone you cared about asked you to punch them? I know it’s unlikely, but it’s unlikely that someone actually enojoys being strangled, so why would you strangle a woman in the bedroom if asked, but not thump someone in the face if asked?