Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be furious husband has complained about my weight

148 replies

Caerus · 31/08/2019 23:15

So I’ve put on a stone or so in the last year or so.. previously got down to a size 10 after a few years of being personally unhappy with post-babies weight gain. But I’ve never been super slim, I love food & find dieting dull. I exercise a lot and frankly I’m a size 14 now & (apart from c-section tummy) I’m not too bothered about a little bit of excess weight. Husband meantime is bordering obsessive with gym & his diet. As a result he looks great. But he has total intolerance for overweight people.. me, his wife included it would appear. He’s said a couple times now me being overweight impacts our relationship. Leaving me feeling increasingly shit about myself & undesired. In all other ways he’s actually a really nice person but I’m furious & hurt that I feel so bad about myself as a result of what someone who should be my supporter has said. He claims it’s because he cares & feels we shouldn’t ‘let ourselves go’ but jeez I’m hardly obese..

OP posts:
Booboostwo · 01/09/2019 08:34

I think you need to talk to him about how it's impacting your relationship and see where you go from there. He is trying to tell you something, maybe he is a knob, maybe he is unhappy, maybe he is worried about you...you won't know until you speak with him and then go from there.

WhoKnewBeefStew · 01/09/2019 08:35

Sounds like you both have different opinions on this, the biggest difference is that he's happy to make you feel shit about your choice - that's what would bother me the most.

Your appearance doesn't change who you are as a person, but your DH seems to put more importance on appearance than personality. Which would bother me.

Did he say 'why' it affected your relationship?

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2019 08:38

Bickering over what is/isn't overweight is kind of irrelevant when the tiniest bit of common sense says that clothes sizes are inconsistent and people carry weight differently and have different frames.

I'm not surprised that the thread has largely been telling the OP She's not really overweight and her DH must have an eating disorder because it's a defence mechanism in society for weight discussions (e.g. I've had larger friends comment about why I'm exercising in pregancy still because I don't need to worry about weight gain. It's not about numbers on a scale, it's about an attitude to health and wellbeing and my midwife agrees).

Whether the DH is wrong or not depends on a lot of contextual factors. For example, if my DH knew I got to a place that left me feeling rubbish about myself, felt happier and was on my way back to the place I felt rubbish then I would expect him to give me a nudge back in the right direction. If I was complaining about weight gain but then doing nothing about it and eating unhealthy sugar snacks regularly then it wouldn't annoy me to joke "you're hardly going to lose the weight you're on about if you eat a share bag of harribo in one sitting".

If he stopped out if the blue seeing me eat a biscuit with my cuppa and took that moment to tell me I look big and unattractive then he'd be an arse.

People do change through relationships, but there is a physical element. Sexual attraction is a mix of physical attraction and attitudes etc. If DH gained weight due to something beyond his control then I might think he looks a bit larger than ideal, but his attitude wouldn't have changed. If he gained weight and his attitude changed then that package would be less attractive.

HangryPants · 01/09/2019 08:38

This really issues me off. When his body has grown and birthed another human then he can talk about physical fucking excellence.

Off to RTF thread now.

Blamangeme · 01/09/2019 08:39

Well going by the comments here OP you are going to split up! Because of course in your marraige vows it says if you put on weight then I shall leave you not in sickness and in health. He's been insensitive yes. If you feel you want to lose weight/tone up etc then do it for yourself. THEN go and find yourself someone who's kinder. Otherwise I know someone who has a Well at the bottom of their garden and planning to fill it in soon. These thin wispy people often blow away and fall down these things in the wind..... Grin

sheshootssheimplores · 01/09/2019 08:41

Suggest to him that being obsessive about health/weight is a real turn off and he’s basically a killjoy with a six pack.

AdrenalinBrush · 01/09/2019 08:43

I've had this over the years but have only ever done something about it when I want to. My DH is obsessed with his own weight and fitness, but no matter what he does, he is still overweight.

I've been on diets and people have told me I look too thin and he still thought I could go an extra stone lighter. I used to live somewhere hot and spent every Sunday round a pool. Once a friend told me her DH was moaning she had lost too much weight after taking up running and complained that women should look like me (curvy). Apparently his mates all thought I had a great figure! Meanwhile my DH was telling me I am fat. At my slimmest I am a size 10 with 32G boobs and a round bum. Apparently at that size I am still fat!

I also know someone whose DH booked and paid for a boob job and told her the her boobs were too small and affecting their relationship. She did it. I would have kicked him to there and then.

Point is, if you are unhappy with your weight then do something about it for YOU. Where does it end if he dictates your weight. What's next, surgery for saggy boobs, a tummy tuck? TBH there is nothing worse than an ageing, vain man.

feelingverylazytoday · 01/09/2019 08:45

He has an eating disorder by the sounds of it
FFS, no he doesn't. Training and eating a healthy diet is not having an eating disorder. The OP said he 'looks great', that indicates he is healthy and doing it properly. Some people who train extensively weigh their food out and calculate their macros, I'm guessing the OP's husband does that. It's not being disordered, just wanting to get the maximum benefit from training.
What's he going do when you hit the menopause and balloon? Everyone does
No everyone doesn't. Some of us lose weight through our menopause, and get way fitter. And no MsTSwift I'm not gaunt either, both my face and arse look good, thanks very much.

WaterOffaDucksCrack · 01/09/2019 08:46

Love does not bother about size it is unconditional love between partners is not unconditional at all otherwise divorce rates would be lower!

Tell him that he needs to earn three times as much to pay for a nanny, nutritionist and personal trainer why would he need to pay for that? Is the op not capable of contributing to finances because she's q woman? Is he not capable of looking after the children on his own because he's a man?

Also, I lost weight after my son was born as a single parent working full time in a busy job and had none of those things. It isn't rocket science it's mainly down to diet. You don't need a nutritionist to tell you what foods to eat or avoid to lose weight.
People can also excercise at home or run etc for free, the husband could do the same. Or they could have specific times they each go to excercise if they like. That's for fitness though not weight loss.

Myriade · 01/09/2019 08:49

Except @LolaSmiles, the OP is HAPPY with her weight and was never extra slim when they met (so the physical element shouldn’t be part of the issue)
So HE has changed the goal posts and IS being an arse with his comments (as they aren’t about her health etc...).

@Caerus, I would want to know what sort of impact your weight has on your relationship. Has he expanded on that?
And I have to say I would also want to know where you will find the time and the energy to do the same than him. Is he willing to actually take on all the housework, parenting the dcs and all the mental load you deal with everyday? Or even half of it? Because somehow I doubt it, esp if it impacts just a little bit of his exercise regime.....

MorrisZapp · 01/09/2019 08:51

As far as I can see the op posted once and hasn't acknowledged any replies. I don't think she's going to answer these questions.

Myriade · 01/09/2019 08:52

@feelingverylazytoday it seems that some comments have touched a raw nerve for you..... you sound quite defensive.

Myriade · 01/09/2019 08:53

@MorrisZapp, or she has just gone to bed? Her OP was done at 11.00pm after all.

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2019 08:53

WaterOffaDucksCrack
I never get why the go to argument is "get him to pay for a personal trainer and nutritionist" like it's some winning argument.

It's so patronising as if women couldn't possibly manage to work their own food out a little, cut the snacks and do some exercise.

If there's some specific training needs then a personal trainer can be good (I had one taking up long distances again after an injury), but for general health and fitness there's really no need unless you're the type of person who'll make excuses to get out of training and the incentive of having paid for the session gives you the nudge.

Having a dig at people who are interested in health/fitness on weight threads and suggesting people have eating disorders is nothing more than typical deflection and defensiveness (and also trivialises actual eating disorders, which is annoying).

Nextphonewontbesamsung · 01/09/2019 08:53

You sound like such a fun person SuperSara.

tobedtoMNandfart · 01/09/2019 08:55

I would be very VERY concerned about how he transmits his obsession with weight/exercise to your children as time goes on.

In the meantime you need to work out whether he has your best interests at heart or whether his reasons are purely self-centred.

Ohflippineck · 01/09/2019 08:58

He’s being honest and I wouldn’t be angry about that. Presumably he’s always felt that way.

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2019 08:58

Myriade
But if she was happier when she was the smaller size compared to now then that doesn't automatically make him an arse.
If, for example, she complains about her body now but isn't doing anything about it, then he isn't automatically being an arse. I'm not saying she is doing that, but for example I work with people who tell me I'm so lucky to be really skinny and eat what I want. I'm the lower end of normal range and happy. But there's always some who are complaining about their weight, but tuck into biscuits, complain about their mum tum but have take away at least once a week. As it's work I would never say anything because it's rude, but I would mention it if DH did it.

All I'm meaning is that commenting on weight doesn't always make someone an arsehole. It can do, but not always.

Not that I think OP will be back

alittleprivacy · 01/09/2019 09:16

Its true though. For many people as they age if they are underweight their faces look gaunt. What’s misogynistic about that? Why is that worse than saying size 14 is obese? My bottom half is size 14 I am certainly not obese.

It's not even a little bit true. I'm in my 40s and a muscular, athletic size UK6 and I don't look gaunt or aged. At a size 14, I'd be heading squarely towards the morbidly obese category. What the actual fuck makes you think that the OP's husband is out of line for telling her he isn't as attracted to her anymore but that it's ok for you to be a complete and total nasty arse to women your age who are fit and healthy?

TBH the idea that female bodies have more body fat than male might need to be a thing he hasn't even thought about.
WTF kind of pseudo-science is this? He doesn't need to consider it because we naturally have more body fat and that suits our bodies. A woman with 25% body fat will look quite slim and athletic. A man with 25% body fat will look reasonably overweight. Having more body fat doesn't mean that women look overweight compared to men, it just means that we have different body composition.

When he’s the one that’s given birth to kids and has to deal with fluctuating hormones and a changing metabolism, he can have a moan. Otherwise he needs to shut the hell up. You are not fat. You are not unhealthy.
Can we please, please, please stop infantilising mothers like this. Pregnancy, breastfeeding, etc can cause visible, sometimes irreparable damage to our bodies. But it's not inevitable that we're some sort of slave to our hormones now and can't make choices about how our bodies look and function. It's not helpful and takes our power and autonomy away from us. My stomach was destroyed following a series of surgeries, followed by a monster pregnancy that stretched out the unhealed scars and a c-section. Right from the moment my son was born, I looked at the absolute wreck of my stomach and told myself that was that. It was how it was and only surgery that I'd never have would fix it, so I had to get on with accepting it. I spent years 'being alright' with my stomach, which involved joking about it and actually thinking being over-weight was better for it, as I filled the stretch marks a bit. As it turns out, most of the loose skin was actually fat and being a healthy weight makes my stomach look significantly better. My abs do a pretty fantastic job of filling in excesses skin and my whole c-section pooch is almost completely gone and doesn't overhang at all anymore. All of that time I spent making myself accept my stomach could have been spent having a stomach I was actually, genuinely happy with. I wouldn't now be on the road to have a stomach that doesn't make me wince to look at, I'd have had it for years. Telling women that having damaged unhealthy bodies is inevitable hurts women far, far, far more than it helps. Be honest. Tell us that while pregnancy can leave it's mark in the majority of cases that mark is actually quite minimal and there are lots and lots of very real ways to keep that damage minimal. Stop making out that it's some sort of inevitability that we are a bit broken now and should just lean into it. And that men are mean if they won't go along with this collective delusion.

SimonJT · 01/09/2019 09:17

You really can’t control who/what you find sexually attractive.

My ex put on a lot of weight and ended up in 38 inch trousers, a 38 inch waist is very big and significantly increases a persons chance of cancer, heart disease, bowel disease, circulation problems, liver damage and type two diabetes. We weighed about the same, but his was body fat and mine was muscle, so he insisted he was fine as we had a similar BMI. He has a blood disorder which is closely monitored, not long before our relationship ended he was diagnosed with both a fatty liver and type two diabetes. He had been overweight for about two years and was 29 at the time, so not a significant amount of time being over weight, not old and he also isn’t in an at risk ethnic group etc.

As someone who has type one diabetes I wouldn’t wish it on anyone, I saw ex three weeks ago to sort a joint mortgage issue, he is still significantly over weight and still failing to control his type two diabetes, thankfully he said his liver had recovered a small amount.

Someone destroying their health isn’t sexually attractive, no matter how they’re destroying their health. But, only that individual can help themselves, I used to tell ex that I was worried for his health, he insisted he would be fine.

Vulpine · 01/09/2019 09:23

I always feel a bit conflicted about this. I wouldn't fancy my dh if he put on too much weight and likewise I've always maintained my weight roughly. The fitter i am the more energy i have for family life!

LolaSmiles · 01/09/2019 09:30

What the actual fuck makes you think that the OP's husband is out of line for telling her he isn't as attracted to her anymore but that it's ok for you to be a complete and total nasty arse to women your age who are fit and healthy?
It's defensive. It's easier to attack people who do manage it to justify not doing anything. It's almost always a knee jerk response from those who are insecure about themselves but don't really want to do anything about it.
We have women from size 4-20ish in our running club. There's none of this sort of attitude because it's people who are focusing on their health and fitness (not moping about clothes size).

Can we please, please, please stop infantilising mothers like this. Pregnancy, breastfeeding, etc can cause visible, sometimes irreparable damage to our bodies. But it's not inevitable that we're some sort of slave to our hormones now and can't make choices about how our bodies look and function. It's not helpful and takes our power and autonomy away from us
This.
By all means get to a point of "I'm happy at my size and I do not wish to gain/lose weight" or "I don't wish to exercise". That's personal choice and whilst I think showing no concern for health/ fitness is a problem, I'll respect the choice.
But don't patronise half of humanity as being hormonal bundles who have no agency or autonomy.

Tchalla · 01/09/2019 10:01

My DH is like this but worse I suppose. I was never slim always struggled with my weight. Was a size 16 when we met now an 18/20 after 3 boys. He said he loved my body size for 3 years then started to change overnight and put me down when I had shrunk to a size 12/14.

I have always been a healthy eater but struggle with shifting weight and my activity level differs. I listened to his advice initially but after a while I realised he was gas lighting me. He has even tried to book me in for weightloss surgery. I refused.
I was in bed breastfeeding DS3 in bed and he said looking at me was disgusting and affecting (he won't take pictures of me and the boys in case someone sees and mocks him, I don't even have a picture of me and DS3 (8months) at the hospital after I gave birth as he refused to take one because of my weight.

I loved gym and swimming but DH won't let me go and wants me to run which I hate instead as it's free. He won't let me choose my own eating plan and cuts out food groups which is unsustainable for me. In short he complains but sabotages me at every point and insists he isn't. He is a controlling, abusive cunt and I have showed him the door many times but he won't leave my home which I paid for, and he doesn't contribute a penny to in bills or otherwise. He refuses to work or help around the house so everything falls on me and he has plenty of time to jog. I don't care anymore. I have listed the house and will sell it from underneath him and will move myself and DSs out so he is not welcome. I have sent divorce papers. I would be slimmer and happier on my own without his controlling and abuse. I would actually have time to do things and exercise as I am already a single parent anyway. He adds zero value to my life. He even tried to make me quit my highly technical niche engineering career to become a carer on minimum wage or study to be a nurse. Nothing against those noble professions but they aren't mine and I have a high paying successful career, why quit? Again something he said he loved about me then changed like a crazy person. Cunt

Rant over

Be careful OP my DH started like this, weight criticism can be valid, but he shouldn't put you down. I do know my situation is extreme and has other issues. You are a healthy size

rookiemere · 01/09/2019 10:08

Tchalla your H is an abusive arse, I hope you get away soon Sad.

I wish I'd never posted or read this thread. I've struggled with my weight all my life. I have broad shoulders and hips and I - not necessarily anyone else - would look gaunt if I was a size 10.

OPs H is not being nice to her and that remains a fact regardless if some posters are a size 8 and have perfectly flat stomachs - good for you , well done.

Caerus · 01/09/2019 10:19

Wow.. woke up this morning to all these responses! Thank you everybody.
So after reading all this & a good nights sleep I’m less emotional about the situation. I’m still hurt but I know my husband is a good man so all the ‘bastard’ ‘gaslighting’ responses are dismissed - with sadness for you ladies who clearly are with/ have been with bastards.
So an important factor here in our situation is he is in recovery with AA.. 5 years sober.. turned his life round..so this underpins his approach to life’s problems.. work hard, take action. Our marriage & family were on the line.. he made some monumental changes in his life for that. He can’t see the big deal with me cutting out the treats & doing the same. He’s a man & very level headed.. but he just doesn’t get emotional eating etc.. this infuriated me more than anything. He stressed he still loved me..
We are 11 yrs married. Kids 9&11.. I have plenty of time (term time!) to exercise..& I do.. he gives me as much time as I need for me- very encouraging of any activity I do & does his fair share at home & a fantastic dad. I do eat too much.. partly out of boredom (I don’t work) partly as part of fun social life & partly just because I love food! I should keep a lid on that or I will continue putting weight on to a level I am unhappy & unhealthy. I guess to hear it from him & framed in a way that I now feel he isn’t attracted to me, is the tough bit. How do we move on... do I not touch him til I’m 9 stone.. will that be slim enough??!! I asked him last night how he felt about wrinkles & saggy boobs.. the menopause is not far off for me.. he doesn’t have an issue with that.. lucky me!!!!??! Anyway this morning he’s being super nice - he knows he’s said stuff that can’t be taken back.. we have other niggly issues that I’m sure every long term relationship goes through. But we’re not throwing in the towel over all this. Who would??? You’d be pretty vain to break up a family over weight. We’ve agreed to get some counselling. But thank you.. all your comments really helped give me some perspective.. & chuckles too! Love women’s support. You all rock xxxx

OP posts: