@GreenTulips I accept that might be your experience, but it isn't the same in the school I'm in.
The play - yes those that want a speaking part, will get a speaking part. We choose plays that we are able to do that with, splitting parts/lines if necessary to accommodate it. Those that don't want a speaking part, can create props, help with scene painting, design the programme, lighting, etc. A production isn't just about the actors after all.
The celebration isn't about trophies, it's about the fact they have progressed as people since they have been with us. We don't do awards like you've suggested at our school.
We are led by what the children have said they want. After all, we don't have to do the play etc, we can quite easily do other lessons instead, if that's what the children would prefer. I can't imagine a worse hell than trying to force Yr6's to do a play they don't want to do.
Some people may find it all a bit mawkish, but as I said before, it's not about you, it's about the kids. If in your school the children don't want to do it, then that's fine.