The more I think about that Guardian article, the more cross I get. The author listed 5 myths where exercise and restricting calories came up at the top and the genes and naturally high appetite at the bottom. This is absolutely the wrong way around. This is exactly why people with weight problems fail repeatedly, they lose weight through diet and exercise and put it straight back on as soon as they slack off. It feels hopeless, defeatist.
Now take a person who has never had a weight problem. They don’t bother exercising, they eat whatever, any old rubbish. And they do not put on weight! Because eating too much or not exercising is not the cause of obesity. If they were, we won’t have the situation where two people have the same meal, one burns it off, the othe one stores it as fat. Big appetite is a symptom, too much body fat is a visible symptom, lower activity levels are a consequence. None of these cause obesity! It is a metabolic problem and you can’t hold the poor sufferer responsible for it. They didn’t cause it.
This is what annoys me when all these PT go on about diet and exercise. Yes, you may lose weight short term. How long can you keep the punishing exercise regime and severe calory restriction for? Not for too long, as vast experience shows. The problem is keeping the weight off. That’s the moment of truth. As soon as you stop your mad exercising efforts, the weight’s back! Because exercise and cutting calories is not a solution to obesity problem. Short term weight loss yes, it’s brilliant for that, but not solving obesity. You are treating the symptom (too much fat) without addressing the cause - the ‘naturally high appetite’ and permanent fat storing mode the body is in caused by high insulin levels. Until you actually address the cause, you have little chance of lasting success. If the person is fighting the symptoms without dealing with the cause, they are but setting themselves up to fail.
It is most unfair to lay blame for their health condition at the obese person’s feet. They didn’t choose to be insulin resistant, to have the draconian appetite and for their body to store every last bit of their meal as fat even if that meal is salad. It is the same as blaming a person born with a heart defect for their health problem. Maybe if they exercised more and watched their calory intake, their heart defect will be cured. Mad? Just as mad to blame the obese for the way their body works. Help them work with it, support them, give them the tools to keep their condition (insulin resistance) at bay. Only then do we have any chance of success.
Ladies, please don’t blame yourselves for something you haven’t done or had no say over. Love yourselves, look after yourselves, treat your propensity to gain weight as a health condition it is. It is not your laziness, or gluttony or whatever rubbish the society will have you believe. Otherwise all lazy people will be fat (and they are not) and all people who eat cake will be corpulent (and they are certainly not).
Happy New Year to everyone. Let it be a year we love ourselves and take care of ourselves💐