Nemo's post sums it up really, I think. You've had great advice on this thread and I've learned a lost myself too.
It's really easy to treat weight loss as "Tomorrow and from then on, I'm going to be spot on, perfect" - and then up until that point, actively cram in as much as you can because today is not the day to be perfect. You have an arbitrary 'starting gun' in your head and until it goes off, you are just preparing. But, we're not perfect. We fall and falter... and actually, that's ok. It doesn't mean we've failed, just that we chose differently for that day.
It's a job that will never be 'done' as such because we're living, breathing, being-machines. Every day is about being and moving. What we eat should reflect what we need to do that. Some days might be more 'hungry' days and some days are more 'take it or leave it' days. It all balances out really, if we can hold off gaining mindlessly.
That last point for me is about Wotsits. I had a terrible and uncontrollable Mini Cheddars habit. I couldn't be around them, could easily polish off a bag of 12 packs in one day. I would then think, "Shit, that's awful. That's 1200 calories in one go, all that fat, all that salt..." and then not eat anything else all day, leaving my body dehydrated and craving proper food. The best thing I could have done is write that off, have a bowl of soup or boiled egg/omelette, something with nutrition in it. Yet my guilt made me forego the nutrition for that day and punish myself chock full of Mini Cheddars.
I then made a decision to stop eating Mini Cheddars - and it worked. Never touched one since. I did though switch to Wotsits and those are even worse. I have no control over those cheese-dust little fuckers. I don't have them in the house, it's that bad.
I have a house full of chocolate as husband eats loads of it. I don't touch it, don't like it so not an issue for me.
Many of us have struggles with food, different things trigger us and different things help. For me, my 'best' foods are these:
- Scrambled eggs
- Yorkshire Provender Roast Chicken Soup
- Yorkshire Provender Spinach, Pea and Mint Soup
Those fill me up, every time. I keep those soups in the fridge, even freeze them and they're delicious and filling. I tell myself I can have something else after if I want, but I don't feel like it then, I have a whole pot to myself as nobody else likes them.
Best tips from my cock-ups would be:
- Steer clear of sugars if you can and that includes artificial sugars.
- Plan what you're going to eat for the day, put it all in a drawer in the fridge just for you if it gives you comfort.
- Full fat yoghurts are more satisfying than 'low fat/fake sugar' versions that leave you wanting something else.
- Fruit is a waste of time for me, I don't have a sweet tooth. I will eat satsumas or the occasional banana but mostly it's vegetables. I like most of them and don't bother eating the ones I don't.
- I won't eat donuts (because I don't love them) BUT I will eat a croissant now and again because I do. I won't waste my calories on something (a treat) that I don't really love and actively choose.
I really agree with what Nemo said about distractions... these activities are fine in and of themselves but if they take too much attention away from what you're wanting to be doing then they're not helpful.
You are not, ever, a failure. You're living and breathing and that is what you were made to do. Everything else is supporting that, supporting you, not the other way around. Your weight/height is what you are, it doesn't define who you are though.
I hope that reading of other posters' experiences makes you feel a bit less alone. I certainly relate to so many things that you've said OP, and what others have said too. You're not alone. 