Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to do a drastic diet?

222 replies

Sunshinemakesmehappie · 27/05/2018 07:23

I have gained huge amounts of weight over the last two years and am now nearly 15stone.

At my height, that’s pretty large and I’m very depressed.

Wondering about doing a liquid/shake diet. Any views?

OP posts:
IJustHadToNameChange · 27/05/2018 10:15

These rapid weight loss diets are good as an initial boost, but slow and steady is better for you.

If you don't learn to adjust your diet gradually and lose 3 stones in 3 months, you may just end up going back to your old eating habits and gaining the weight again.

Yo-yo dieting is not good for you and wreaks havoc with your metabolism.

Bumblebee2302 · 27/05/2018 10:21

Another suggestion from me - since everything else has been dismissed - would be the virtual gastric band hypnosis. You just listen to the sessions morning and night and it trains you into thinking you have a gastric band fitted. You follow certain guidelines - you just eat what you would normally eat but you are trained into stopping when you begin to feel full. You are encourged to drink lots of water. People have lost large amounts of weight doing it and haven't felt deprived as they still eat as normal but just not in the quantities they would have before.

You just download the app for your phone (about £5 I think) and the hypnosis sessions are on it. Might be useful for the OP if she isn't keen on actual diets. There is a closed Facebook support group as well where you can see people's progress and success stories.

MinaPaws · 27/05/2018 10:25

@FATEdestiny that is SO impressive. Congratulations. I love your no-nonsense approach and your goal setting. Did you just sort yourself out or go anywhere for inspiration?

MaMisled · 27/05/2018 10:26

Regarding slow and steady. .....if you're very overweight, Slimming world, weight watchers or your own diet combining exercise and calorie control, will cause large losses for the first few months before slowing to one or two pound a week. You won't need to wait until the weight has all gone to feel great. After a few good weeks you'll feel great! You'll feel in control and energised !

Bumblebee2302 · 27/05/2018 10:27

Sorry, it's called Easyloss

CiderwithBuda · 27/05/2018 10:29

I came back to mention you FATE and here you are! I loved your approach to exercise on the thread about losing four stone. And it has inspired me to follow a similar plan.

I have been gradually increasing how much exercise I do but it’s been a bit hit and miss.

PostNotInHaste · 27/05/2018 10:35

My view for what it’s worth having read most of the weight loss threads on here is I can see doing VLCD for say 3 weeks as a starter to get you started and to take the pressure off working how to eat in a sustainable way at the beginning possibly makes sense for some people (done a huge u turn on my thinking on this).

But we all focus on weight loss when it’s weight maintenance we need to think about. Most of us can lose weight but how many on here have yoyo dieted for years ? It’s maintaining your weight that’s the hard bit. I think those of us who have been morbidly obese look at our think friends and think well it’s easy for you, it comes naturally. But having spoken to them at length it seems that most of them do actually work at it. Maybe that’s specific to my friendship circle but I doubt it.

It’s not too bad being obese when you’re you’re younger for a lot of people but time creeps by and more and more health problems creep in. The profile for gallstones is female, fair, fat and fertile and they hurt like nothing you have ever experienced. Perimenopause can be hard on even the fittest person, lot of luck involved. But the night sweats, joint pain flushes, lethargy, anxiety are generally all worse when you’re fat.

There’s something in the US called somelike the National Weight loss register. Can’t remember the exact details but they follow people who have lost more than 30lbs and kept it off for over 5 years I think. They found it didn’t really matter how people lost weight, it was the ones that made life style changes and walking for an hour a day, every day that kept it off.

Walking is hugely underrated . If you don’t want to go out use some Leslie Sansone YouTube videos to get started . The 5 min one great for boiling the kettle, the 15 min whilst boiling rice. Fitness levels do improve very quickly. Walking outside even better after a bit. Download running music, headphones on and ignore any obnoxious wankers who comment. There’s research in the field of Horticultural Therapy that talks about a nature disconnect that modern lifestyles have resulted in. If you walk outside you get the benefits of fresh air , the endorphins from exercise but become more connected to the seasons and their rhythms which used to play a huge part of our lives.

Get support from those around you, those that have at least 3 people supporting them have been found to be more successful. As you get fitter you can build in more activities into socialising which will help.

Channel the anger you’re probably feeling from reading this thread and do something today to change something - doesn’t matter what, just start.

Anyone reading who has a lot to lose and would like to talk to others in similar situations please feel free to come over to the lose 100lb thread in the weightloss section, we’re all at different stages. Good luck OP.

samandpoppysmummy · 27/05/2018 10:40

I've been doing Exante for a month and have gone from 11st 6 to 10st 5. I've got another stone to lose (hopefully before my 50th birthday party in July). I plan to stay on Exante until I get to my goal then introduce proper meals gradually. I don't have any of the Exante shakes or 'meals', just three different bars a day and a lot of water. I don't do any exercise. It's good value for money compared to other VLCDs and I have found it easy to stick to. I have been surprised how little I miss eating normal food, despite cooking for my family every day.

Emmageddon · 27/05/2018 10:48

I'm not sure if the OP is still reading the thread but there's no quick fix to lose weight, otherwise no-one would be fat. I lost 4 stone in 6 months with Slimming World last year, and have kept the weight off by following the basic principles of low fat, high protein, limited carbs, lots and lots of veg. Oh and joining a cycling club has helped tone everything up.

Oliversmumsarmy · 27/05/2018 17:12

I have never lost anything more than a couple of pounds eating low calorie and only after being on a diet for 2 weeks. Or in the past few years 6 weeks before any weight comes off.

It means I cannot go anywhere because if I went out to eat out despite going for the lousy calorie thing on the menu I can out on a months weight loss overnight.

Thats why juicing works for me.

MrsHappyAndMrCool · 27/05/2018 17:18

There is the OMAD (One Meal A Day Diet)

Or

You could try the Apple fast cleanse, I do it once a month for 5 days not to lose weight but to cleanse the body, I lose 9lbs-11lbs during that time, I really wouldn’t recommend it for long term weight loss.

Urbanbeetler · 27/05/2018 18:42

This thread is so interesting - thank you to everyone who has contributed. Even if it didn’t match the op’s expectations, I’m sure I’m not the only one who has been inspired by the stories and informed by the different approaches.

DrowningEveryDay · 27/05/2018 22:05

Urbanbeetler

Word.

Armchairanarchist · 27/05/2018 22:19

I lost my stomach to avoid Cancer and now have a liquid diet. It slows your metabolism and I can maintain my weight now on 700 calories a day. If I ate normally now I'd pile weight on and so will you if you go on a liquid, hugely restrictive diet. Slow and steady is the way if you want to keep it off and want to be able to eat normally in the future.

trojanpony · 27/05/2018 22:39

*I have done a vlcd twice now.

Both times I lost weight, both times I put it back on and more.

I am now the heaviest I have ever been.*

This is more common than you would think I lost a lot of weight with vlcd, it was one of the worst things I’ve did.
The gall stones is not something had but I did develop abnormal liver function in my early 20s Confused not ideal....

I cannot advise against vlcds strongly enough

specialsubject · 27/05/2018 22:42

no healthy body needs cleanse or detox, you have liver and kidneys. use of these words indicates lies , stupidity , a con or all three.

Fatball · 28/05/2018 08:03

Amen Specialsubject.

Cleansing/detoxing - nonsense.

ppeatfruit · 28/05/2018 09:08

specialsubject How many of us have healthy bodies though? The majority of people eat and drink (esp. drink) liver rotting rubbish.

Mominatrix · 28/05/2018 09:20

ppeatfruit, ironically it is usually the group which tend to have better than average diets who do "cleanses". The people who live in food poverty with the crappiest diets are not the ones who will be doing juice/apple/whatever "cleanses". Even for those who do have less than ideal diets, doing a week long detox will not suddenly rest the body and put it into optimum health - only permanent change in habits will do that. For the vast majority of people, our kidneys, livers, sweat glands, colons are doing a good job of detoxing our bodies.

ppeatfruit · 28/05/2018 09:30

Not that many sadly Mom The vast majority drink to much alcohol and those brown high sugar\chemically sweetened fizzy drinks, also too many caffeinated drinks. and deep fat fry everything. They live on fast foods or crisps and chox.

There wouldn't be soo much ill health and so many people in hospitals if we all ate and drank more thoughtfully .

specialsubject · 28/05/2018 09:36

detox and cleanse are still bollocks. if you have liver or kidney failure you will know about it and will be very ill or dead, not dicking about with foolish regimes.

the human body deals with anything put into it that isnt actually poisonous. doesnt mean fizzy pop,cigarettes,cereal bars, smoothies, meal replacements and unnecessary supplements are a good idea of course.

remember Paltrow is a limited actress making cash from fools, not a doctor.

Mominatrix · 28/05/2018 09:49

Not that many sadly Mom The vast majority drink to much alcohol and those brown high sugar\chemically sweetened fizzy drinks, also too many caffeinated drinks. and deep fat fry everything. They live on fast foods or crisps and chox.

Really? The vast majority of people in the UK? data?

ppeatfruit · 28/05/2018 09:55

Well how would you explain all the myriad of chronic illnesses there are special?

The many people with gout, arthritis, diabetes, asthma, IBS etc etc….. they're not killers but they don't make life enjoyable.

I do eat a thoughtfully and am not ill at all . Not Paltrow but at least she tries.

CiderwithBuda · 28/05/2018 09:55

I’ve done a couple of cleanses/detoxes but only ones based on eating actual food. No alcohol, sugar, wheat, caffeine, dairy or processed foods. So basically a week or ten days of basic healthy eating. I know there is no science behind And that it’s not necessary but I figure it is good to have periods when I don’t eat crap.

Mominatrix · 28/05/2018 09:59

People like Gwyneth Paltrow are not innocuous - they are doing a great disservice by spreading disinformation and legitimising charlatans.