Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what a perfect Mil would be like?

116 replies

Bluelady · 18/01/2018 15:30

As I'm about to become one and see them getting so much flak here, please tell me how I should behave so I don't piss my dil off. Serious question.

OP posts:
TrinitySquirrel · 18/01/2018 15:31

How do you get on with her now?

OuchBollocks · 18/01/2018 15:31

Surely that depends on your DIL? Seeing as how women aren't one big hive mind.

maras2 · 18/01/2018 15:32

Me.I'm a great MIL Halo

PricillaQueenOfTheDesert · 18/01/2018 15:36

As far as I can work it out, whatever you do, it will probably be wrong. If you give advice you’ll be interfering and telling your Dillon fashioned ways. If you don’t ask or give advice you’re ignoring her.
If you visit, it will be unwelcomed, if you stay one night it will like you can’t get away quick enough and if you don’t visit you’ll be ignoring her.

Just be yourself, at least that way you’ll be happy.

MrTrebus · 18/01/2018 15:38

Be involved and helpful and happy but not interfering, over opinionated or cheeky fuckerish. Simples Grin

Gingernaut · 18/01/2018 15:43

A feminist whose son knows how to do the housework, can iron his own shirts and doesn't expect to be waited on hand, foot and finger.

Offers copies of her favourite recipes, but doesn't make passive aggressive comments about not feeding him right, if the offer is turned down.

When visiting doesn't make comments about the state of the place or offer to show your DDIL how to do things 'properly', unless she says she's having trouble with something.

Saysomethingnice · 18/01/2018 15:43

Treat your dils with the same respect as you would a dear friend friend.
Ie you wouldn't cutting your dearest friends child's hair without asking them first. You wouldn't route through your df underwear draws, letters yourself into the or houses... Re arrange their houses, critises them over everything as well as dc... Etc etc.
Not expect your df to be with you every Christmas and so on. Not hard.

tabbywabby · 18/01/2018 15:45

Advice I would give to any parents in law.

If they have children, let them parent their children. Don't get bent out of shape because they don't want your advice, and FGS don't go behind their back. Be the grandparent. You had your turn at being the parent.

Boundaries!

Lovely333 · 18/01/2018 15:46

Be kind and welcoming.

AnnieOH1 · 18/01/2018 15:47

My biggest advice would be that, whatever your personal beliefs and convictions are, please don't try and force those onto the couple. Speaking from bitter experience as a DIL.

Voiceforreason · 18/01/2018 15:55

I am a mil and have been for many years. Respect boundaries and have an open house is my advice. Understand that we are all the product of our upbringing and families are very different. Embrace differences. Sadly, sometimes, the dil/sil really doesn't want the relationship to work. Some people become very possessive of their partner. If this happens and you see your son/daughter losing contact with you, keep well clear of the situation but quietly let them know the door is always open. It happened to one of my children and they were quite alienated from the famiky for a few years. We kept well clear. Ultimately the marriage ended and contact with the family re established. People have to learn and grow together within tbeir own mzrriagr, or not, as the case may be. You may need the patirnce of a saint and the wisdom of Solomon but never forget 'least said, soonest mended'!

Quartz2208 · 18/01/2018 15:56

Support them being a parent

Bluelady · 18/01/2018 15:57

If I made any comments about the state of the place it would be awestruck admiration at how immaculate it was.

OP posts:
missyB1 · 18/01/2018 15:58

I became one a few months ago.
I help out when I'm asked
I dont ever comment on their house
I did disapprove on them getting a puppy but showed enthusiasm when they went ahead and did it anyway!
I keep in touch and pop over if I'm invited but I dont crowd them or turn up unannounced.

I hope when they have kids that I'm allowed to have a close relationship with my grandchildren. I will certainly offer to help out - like I do with the puppy.

MilkTwoSugarsThanks · 18/01/2018 15:58

Ad far as I can tell from the countless threads on here you have to be a complete doormat, kowtow to whatever DIL demands, forget that you are your son's mum and have become an unnecessary irritation in his wife's life. Drop everything to provide free childcare at a moment's notice. Do not speak unless spoken to.

missyB1 · 18/01/2018 15:59

I became one a few months ago.
I help out when I'm asked
I dont ever comment on their house
I did disapprove on them getting a puppy but showed enthusiasm when they went ahead and did it anyway!
I keep in touch and pop over if I'm invited but I dont crowd them or turn up unannounced.

I hope when they have kids that I'm allowed to have a close relationship with my grandchildren. I will certainly offer to help out - like I do with the puppy.

TroubleinDaFamily · 18/01/2018 16:00

My MIL is great, absolutely no trouble since 2000.

Dead mind you, but no trouble for the last seventeen years.

Grin
MyBrilliantDisguise · 18/01/2018 16:03
Grin
GreatDuckCookery6211 · 18/01/2018 16:08

Pretty spot on there Milk.

pallisers · 18/01/2018 16:10

Like mine.

Lovely, interesting woman with many outside interests and friends. Great to have a chat with.

Always speaks well of my family.

Genuinely likes all of her daughters in law and is delighted her sons found happiness. A wonderful grandmother and step grandmother (although she doesn't differentiate there).

Always tells me that I am doing a wonderful job as a mother. Tells my dh he is lucky. Thanks me for the gifts we give her knowing full-well I probably chose them.

When I needed help badly after ds was born, she dropped everything and got on a plane. She would make me breakfast in the morning and take the baby so I could go back to sleep. Would wait until I finished the feeds in the middle of the night and then come out of her bedroom and say "would you like me to get him back to sleep". Kept me company, didn't intrude, told me I was doing great. Helped when a blocked duct meant I had to try feeding ds from different angles (I think she may have held him upside down or at least didn't look disapproving when dh did it)

I love her. All of her family, including DILs love her. She can annoy the shit out of me too, mind you

Saysomethingnice · 18/01/2018 16:11

Arf milk!

Nope just treat dil like you would a friend.

Notasperfectasallothermners · 18/01/2018 16:11

I was a brilliant mil until she took the piss.
(exdil) just see dgs through ds now.

lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:22

My MIL doesn't think the sun shines out of her son's arse. She doesn't make clear that she thinks he could do better. She has taken time to get to know me (so when we have dinner at hers there are no carrots on my plate because she knows I hate them - little things).

She'll give suggestions and opinions, but never makes any comment if we don't take them up (not even when an 'I told you so was quite warranted'). She and FIL very much believed they had their chance at parenting so they respected it was our turn, in fact the "you will get things wrong, you'll change the way you do it because you baby hasn't read the same manual as you. We all fucked up sometimes, but you get through it" from her was one of the best bits of advice I had. If she didn't agree, like she struggled with BLW because she was scared of choking, she researched it and either stayed quiet or actually said "btw I looked into that and I wish they'd had that when mine were wee" or something similar.

She also made it clear when we met that if she was too over the top or was annoying I was just to say. And she meant it. We once had a very frank, but polite and civil, chat about the fact my habit of tapping my foot constantly annoyed the shit out of her and she made me a deal that she'd stop whistling if I stopped tapping.

We're not rivals for DH's attention and she fully expects his loyalties to be with me and the kids first and foremost, rather than to her and FIL.

Basically she treats me like she'd like to be treated. Today she's done the school run so I don't have to take the little uns out in the snow. she didn't have too, but just offered.

I think the little things are the big things a lot of the time.

lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:22

My MIL doesn't think the sun shines out of her son's arse. She doesn't make clear that she thinks he could do better. She has taken time to get to know me (so when we have dinner at hers there are no carrots on my plate because she knows I hate them - little things).

She'll give suggestions and opinions, but never makes any comment if we don't take them up (not even when an 'I told you so was quite warranted'). She and FIL very much believed they had their chance at parenting so they respected it was our turn, in fact the "you will get things wrong, you'll change the way you do it because you baby hasn't read the same manual as you. We all fucked up sometimes, but you get through it" from her was one of the best bits of advice I had. If she didn't agree, like she struggled with BLW because she was scared of choking, she researched it and either stayed quiet or actually said "btw I looked into that and I wish they'd had that when mine were wee" or something similar.

She also made it clear when we met that if she was too over the top or was annoying I was just to say. And she meant it. We once had a very frank, but polite and civil, chat about the fact my habit of tapping my foot constantly annoyed the shit out of her and she made me a deal that she'd stop whistling if I stopped tapping.

We're not rivals for DH's attention and she fully expects his loyalties to be with me and the kids first and foremost, rather than to her and FIL.

Basically she treats me like she'd like to be treated. Today she's done the school run so I don't have to take the little uns out in the snow. she didn't have too, but just offered.

I think the little things are the big things a lot of the time.

AppleAndBlackberry · 18/01/2018 16:22

My MIL is lovely. She has never interferes or criticizes, she brought us meals and chocolate brownies when I had our DDs, she's interested in our children and helps out but isn't overbearing. She's easygoing when we spend time together and a lot of what we do is focused on the children. FIL is lovely too but you asked specifically about MILs. I wish they would phone DH a bit more often (almost never) and it would be nice if they offered to have our children to stay (they will if we ask but we don't like to ask too often) but other than that they are perfect.