Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what a perfect Mil would be like?

116 replies

Bluelady · 18/01/2018 15:30

As I'm about to become one and see them getting so much flak here, please tell me how I should behave so I don't piss my dil off. Serious question.

OP posts:
lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:22

My MIL doesn't think the sun shines out of her son's arse. She doesn't make clear that she thinks he could do better. She has taken time to get to know me (so when we have dinner at hers there are no carrots on my plate because she knows I hate them - little things). She'll give suggestions and opinions, but never makes any comment if we don't take them up (not even when an 'I told you so was quite warranted'). She and FIL very much believed they had their chance at parenting so they respected it was our turn, in fact the "you will get things wrong, you'll change the way you do it because you baby hasn't read the same manual as you. We all fucked up sometimes, but you get through it" from her was one of the best bits of advice I had. If she didn't agree, like she struggled with BLW because she was scared of choking, she researched it and either stayed quiet or actually said "btw I looked into that and I wish they'd had that when mine were wee" or something similar.

Basically she treats me like she'd like to be treated.

lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:22

My MIL doesn't think the sun shines out of her son's arse. She doesn't make clear that she thinks he could do better. She has taken time to get to know me (so when we have dinner at hers there are no carrots on my plate because she knows I hate them - little things).

She'll give suggestions and opinions, but never makes any comment if we don't take them up (not even when an 'I told you so was quite warranted'). She and FIL very much believed they had their chance at parenting so they respected it was our turn, in fact the "you will get things wrong, you'll change the way you do it because you baby hasn't read the same manual as you. We all fucked up sometimes, but you get through it" from her was one of the best bits of advice I had. If she didn't agree, like she struggled with BLW because she was scared of choking, she researched it and either stayed quiet or actually said "btw I looked into that and I wish they'd had that when mine were wee" or something similar.

She also made it clear when we met that if she was too over the top or was annoying I was just to say. And she meant it. We once had a very frank, but polite and civil, chat about the fact my habit of tapping my foot constantly annoyed the shit out of her and she made me a deal that she'd stop whistling if I stopped tapping.

We're not rivals for DH's attention and she fully expects his loyalties to be with me and the kids first and foremost, rather than to her and FIL.

Basically she treats me like she'd like to be treated. Today she's done the school run so I don't have to take the little uns out in the snow. she didn't have too, but just offered.

I think the little things are the big things a lot of the time.

AppleAndBlackberry · 18/01/2018 16:22

My MIL is lovely. She has never interferes or criticizes, she brought us meals and chocolate brownies when I had our DDs, she's interested in our children and helps out but isn't overbearing. She's easygoing when we spend time together and a lot of what we do is focused on the children. FIL is lovely too but you asked specifically about MILs. I wish they would phone DH a bit more often (almost never) and it would be nice if they offered to have our children to stay (they will if we ask but we don't like to ask too often) but other than that they are perfect.

lalalalyra · 18/01/2018 16:23

Oh ffs sorry for the multi-posts!

violetgrey · 18/01/2018 16:36

Be kind, treat your son and his wife as adults and take interest in their lives.

Don't act like a martyr when you don't get your way. Don't treat your DIL like an unwelcome person who has to be tolerated for the sake of your son.

Also, it's ok to have different opinions and disagree on things. Just make sure you talk things through instead of sulking and passive aggressive behaviour. You can just agree to disagree and move on.:-)

I wish my MIL was here to ask this question and listen. The fact that you are thinking about it and asking makes me think that you will do just fine.:-)

ziggiestardust · 18/01/2018 16:46

My MIL has had a hard time in life, and hasn’t always make the greatest decisions. As a result, my DH doesn’t really see her as a mum anymore, she’s just kind of there to him.

However; she has been and is an absolute lifesaver. She freely acknowledges that her parenting wasn’t always up to scratch, and doesn’t ask his forgiveness; only that she be able to try and make it up by being a good grandparent. She takes care of her GC for free and shares the care when we are working with my mum (they do 1.5 days a week each). She prepares dinners, scrubs the house to within an inch of its life, does the school run, doc appointments, dentist appointments, homework, and is generally available at the drop of a hat if we need her. She is an incredible help and I don’t know where I’d be without her. I make sure she knows this. She and I have a good relationship and have never fallen out. She is an excellent grandmother, and as long as she carries on being that; she will always have my respect.

ziggiestardust · 18/01/2018 16:46

My MIL has had a hard time in life, and hasn’t always make the greatest decisions. As a result, my DH doesn’t really see her as a mum anymore, she’s just kind of there to him.

However; she has been and is an absolute lifesaver. She freely acknowledges that her parenting wasn’t always up to scratch, and doesn’t ask his forgiveness; only that she be able to try and make it up by being a good grandparent. She takes care of her GC for free and shares the care when we are working with my mum (they do 1.5 days a week each). She prepares dinners, scrubs the house to within an inch of its life, does the school run, doc appointments, dentist appointments, homework, and is generally available at the drop of a hat if we need her. She is an incredible help and I don’t know where I’d be without her. I make sure she knows this. She and I have a good relationship and have never fallen out. She is an excellent grandmother, and as long as she carries on being that; she will always have my respect.

ziggiestardust · 18/01/2018 16:48

Yikes! Sorry for the double post; not sure what happened there!

MegBusset · 18/01/2018 16:50

My MIL is fab :) she is mad as a box of frogs, but funny and sweet. She spoils the DC rotten with sweets and pocket money, she has never interfered with our parenting or our marriage, and she's always happy to babysit.

She's 86 this year and I hope we have her for many years yet.

BertrandRussell · 18/01/2018 16:53

In order be a perfect Mil you have to be a perfect human being. No flaws. But also no opinions, feelings or life.

Rachie1973 · 18/01/2018 16:55

Me! I'm a great MIL I think lol

I learned from the best though. My own MIL was a diamond :)

I don't advise unless asked, I don't interfere unless death is imminent lol, I also go out on the lash with them lol

Kitty2018 · 18/01/2018 16:57

Don't play favourites with your DGC like my MIL does!

pallisers · 18/01/2018 17:02

In order be a perfect Mil you have to be a perfect human being. No flaws. But also no opinions, feelings or life.

My MIL is nothing like this and is a perfect MIL.

Badgerthebodger · 18/01/2018 17:05

My MIL is amazing. I love her to bits! She makes wonderful cakes, is very kind and very loving towards me. She doesn’t criticise but she will offer an opinion - however she will also respect mine especially when it comes to DS. She told me the other day that she sometimes wants to give DH a good kick in the arse Grin which frankly, so do I! We’re very different but we’ve both made an effort to build a relationship, and seven years on she is a fantastic granny and a much appreciated part of my life. She has taken so much care of me recently during a shitty long term pain thing and I really don’t think she could be any better.

OP just be yourself. She’s just a person, who is in love with your son. If you both start with wanting to be friends, you will build a fab relationship and never look back

Hippydippydoo · 18/01/2018 17:07

Treat your Dil as her own person, not just an extension of your son and the route to your future grandchildren.

Pay interest in her as a person, and if possible try to become genuine friends, not just smiles and nods because she is married to your son.

Pseudousername · 18/01/2018 17:10

OP just be yourself. She’s just a person, who is in love with your son. If you both start with wanting to be friends, you will build a fab relationship and never look back

This is spot on. I love my MIL and my mum is a great MIL too. Either of us can do time alone with MIL and I think that is key.
FIL on the other hand......

LyraPotter · 18/01/2018 17:12

Mine is pretty perfect. She engages with me as a person and not just as her son's wife (e.g. Invites me for coffee and lunch and stuff on my own). She respects our privacy and is never invasive, but she is interested in our lives in a nice way. She sees me as on her team because we both love her son. She offers advice if asked but not otherwise. I really got lucky because she's the dream.

OverTheParapet · 18/01/2018 17:16

I think arsehole MILs are just people who are arseholes who happen to be MILs. Same with DILs Grin

SallyLockhartsDog · 18/01/2018 17:17

My MIL was lovely.
She did offer unwanted opinions/advice etc however she treated me like a dear dear friend (as said by pp). She viewed me as a new friend and not (just) her son's partner.

And like with a new friendship she gave me space and didn't expect an automatic relationship.

I was closer to her than my own mum by the end and I really miss her.

blackwhitebrindle · 18/01/2018 17:17

My mum would make a great mil. She randomly takes the kids laundry baskets away, washes, dries, irons and then will put it all away when she’s babysitting.
She cleans our house (only downstairs as she doesn’t like to pry upstairs)
When I had a csection she cooked us 2 weeks of freezer meals.
She does childcare every week for us, spoils our kids and takes us on holiday.
She dog sits most weeks.
My mil has not once in 6 years phoned me or popped in (although she has to drive past every day)
She didn’t even offer to help after my csection despite living 10 minutes away.
She treats some grandchildren more favourably than others.
She treats some daughter in laws more favourably than others.
2 totally different people.

Lilmis · 18/01/2018 17:19

My mil isn't as angelic or easy going on me. These r what I would say not to do from a dil perspective.

Don't nit pick on things like how she iron, how she cleans or keeps her room/house etc tc

Offer advice/opinions but don't expect her to agree or take up ur advice.

Don't make plans with ur son and exclude her.

Don't expect her to always do thing your way.

Don't disregard her opinions.

Don't override her decisions when it comes to grandchildren.

Good luck.

bobstersmum · 18/01/2018 17:20

I wouldn't change my mil she is genuinely a friend, she sees the faults in her son and sticks up for me, she is kind and down to earth.
Unfortunately she has lung cancer but hopefully going to get through it!

Trinity66 · 18/01/2018 17:20

I don't think MiLs are that disliked in real life, I don't have one as my DHs mother died when he was young but he gets on great with my mom, they're very similar personality wise. My mom also gets on well with my 3 brothers partners, I think with each of them though she has a different kind of relationship from getting to know them and their different personalities etc. from what i see the mothers that seem to be disliked all have one thing in common though, they're pushy and interfering

Swipe left for the next trending thread