1 is a lot bigger. The second bedroom in 2 is small and squashed, and 1 has a third bedroom.
2 has no dining area in kitchen or living room, 1 does.
1 the lounge looks a lot bigger
I don't think 1 needa gutting, you don't HAVE to replace the bathroom etc. most of it is paper and paint to fix.
I really dislike the furniture etc in no1, which I think makes it hard to look past in photos to see what you could make of it.
the only thing about 2 is the living room is snug with woodburner.