Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm sorry but boarding school at 8...

451 replies

TheVanguardSix · 23/09/2017 13:36

I just don't get it.
Not in this day and age.
I don't mean to come across as antagonistic but as I watch DD's best friend prepare to leave next year for boarding school at the age of 8, it just feels sad. It's amazing how the dynamics of their friendship have changed already. And I can't help but assume it has to do with her knowing that she's leaving... preparing to board (she will only come back for Christmas/Easter/Summer hols... not even half-term. Her parents will visit her over half-term).
Don't get me wrong. I'm not against boarding school at all even if it's not in our plans. I get why people send their older kids to boarding school. We know lots of our older DC's friends who started boarding school at 11 and 13. But 8... it just seems so young.
There must be something positive about it. Otherwise, why would people choose to send a young child to boarding school?

OP posts:
Ceto · 23/09/2017 22:52

OP, I don't understand why the plan is for the family to visit this child at half term rather than her coming home. Half term is likely to be for at least a week, possibly two. What on earth is the logic in the family travelling to stay near the school rather than the child just coming back home?

JigglyTuff · 23/09/2017 22:53

@gillybeanz - I'm curious as to how your DD knew about this school that was so right for her that she demanded to be home-schooled. I'm guessing ballet.

Actually though we're on the same side. I don't have a problem with 11 year olds boarding at all. I think it can be brilliant and some of my family have boarded at that age and later and it's been brilliant.

But that's not what this thread is about. It's about 8 year olds boarding. Which isn't what your DD did.

mathanxiety · 23/09/2017 22:55

No matter how well intentioned the school or the parents may be, the issue is that all boarding children have to learn to cope alone, Gilly.

This post expresses really well the situation 8 year old boarders are asked to shoulder:
The issue for me is do you really want your 8 year old to learn how to 'get over' being away from home and missing their Mum, Dad, siblings, pets and so on?

Taking a young child out of their family and teaching them how to cope seems rather cruel - and I know from my own experience how quickly you learn to be resilient. How quickly you learn that people want you to be happy, that your parents want to hear that you've settled in, that you don't want people to worry about you or feel that you're causing problems.
LazyDailyMailJournos

The last century ended only 17 years ago.

Carouselfish · 23/09/2017 23:06

Talking about other people's lives and choices is 98% of this website. What would we do if we weren't airing our opinions on them? Always find it hilarious when people say myob here.
OP, imo 8 is too young and I would say it suggests there's a lack of bond between parent and child. If there isn't, it'll probably create one.

JigglyTuff · 23/09/2017 23:16

Totally agree with you Math. A primary school aged child is too young to decide to want to be away from their parents. And while I had a horrible shuffling about expat life, I'm glad I was moved about. My schooling went a bit to pot but I had my mum.

SingingMySong · 23/09/2017 23:29

LazyDailyMailJournos excellent post.

Bit of a tangent, and maybe this too has changed, but I do wonder if the stability of boarding is a bit overstated. For us it was having to pack your life into 2 suitcases, clear the pinboard, wipe out the drawers, and move to a new bed in a new dorm every term. It seems quite a transitory existence really.

gillybeanz · 23/09/2017 23:32

Jiggly

I know my dd was 11 and not 8, we decided not to let her try at 8 as I don't believe she was ready then. However, the thread developed into no age is right to board, from some posters.
I do think some are ready, at her school anyway, I can't speak for others.

To answer your question she saw a programme about the children/school on CBBC and asked if we had enough money to go, or if she would need to apply for funding. Shock
She was already talking about school getting in the way of her career.
We have constantly been open mouthed with the things she has come out with over the years. We have raised her the same as the others, they have normal jobs aren't particularly career driven or ambitious beyond the odd promotion, no grand plan so to speak. I work in a call centre Grin
However, dd just knew what she wanted and told us she was leaving school to concentrate on her career. She worked hard, had lots of opportunities whilst H.ed and then tried for the school. She went to the open day and all the kids were like dd, I know that may sound daft, but it's true.
We thought maybe gain some feedback and they offered her a place.
She is thriving and it fits her like a glove, she knows where she wants to study after this school and has plans to do her PG qual in America.
She isn't a normal child, and that isn't a stealth boast as it has it's downside too. She isn't very academic and struggles, she will be lucky to scrape a few GCSE's together but is outside the box? Gifted.
I miss her but she is so happy and still pinches herself at her luck, can't believe she's there.
I know our story isn't representative of all children who board, but as I said upthread there are several of these/similar schools throughout the uk. Their catchment is the world, this just happens to be 40 mins away from us.
It hurts me that people assume that you don't love your children if they board, or you've sent them away. It's also worrying that parents can think this of other parents.
I do know it doesn't work for everybody but ime parents think long and hard before deciding on boarding, even dd friends and peers who want to be there and ask to go. Their parents report going through what me and dh went through.

mathanxiety · 24/09/2017 00:14

That is a very different sort of boarding school from the ones most people are talking about, though, Gilly, and your DD as you acknowledge yourself, 'isn't a normal child'. And she is also 11.

Openup41 · 24/09/2017 00:42

I would not consider boarding school until my children were at least 15. Children go through all sorts of emotions and traumas during the school day - coming home to an environment where they are loved makes a difference.

What if a child is being bullied, isolated? They have to stay in the same environment day and night. I was bullied as a teenager and I used to picture my life outside of school in order to maintain a slither of happiness. If I had been at boarding school I would have ended my life.

blahdyblahblah · 24/09/2017 00:44

I know a girl of 8 that's just gone and it will be the saving of her. Awful home life, she'll get far more love and structure at school.

Greenday90 · 24/09/2017 01:01

What's the point in having children :(

mathanxiety · 24/09/2017 01:03

That is not really a ringing endorsement of boarding school, Blahdyblahblah.

blahdyblahblah · 24/09/2017 01:18

Well it'll be a much better option than staying at home. I think for a lot of children it's a godsend.

I'm sorry but boarding school at 8...
blahdyblahblah · 24/09/2017 01:18

Not sure what the weird black picture I attached is!! Confused

blahdyblahblah · 24/09/2017 01:21

I used to beg my parents to send me to boarding school. (Mallory Towers, St Claire's Grin).

I'm snivelling about sending ds to pre school for 2 hours a day and have no intention of letting him leave for college/uni ever. Grin

therealpippi · 24/09/2017 01:22

The first few minutes of this documentary say it all

m.youtube.com/watch?v=T2HUBT_oyaA

The "home from home" and "it's fun but home it's better" are chilling comments.

Seeing young children living off a suitcase is heartbreaking.

therealpippi · 24/09/2017 01:26

If children want to go I'd question my family dynamic.

I wanted to go. I now know why.

(I Am not referring to families in the forces or particular cases)

A good book on this is this one www.google.co.uk/search?q=stiff+upper+lips+book&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&hl=en-gb&client=safari#imgrc=953SWwFvogKHqM:

TooManyNames · 24/09/2017 06:42

I went to boarding school (parents travelled a lot for work) and I loved it! BUT I was 13 and honestly even that was pushing it. I wasn't 'ripe' emotionally and didn't really know how to stand up for myself. I only settled in around 15 YO. So yeah, 8 IMO is very young. To each his own... xxx

sashh · 24/09/2017 07:20

It depends on the child, it depends on the school and family circumstances.

This

I would have loved boarding at 8, my brother would have hated it. It's possible I have ASD, I have a lot of traits and loved going to stay with relatives who had an actual routine, a time to get up, at time to eat.

China do boarding from 3!

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-24624427

orlantina · 24/09/2017 08:29

When you were a teenager, did you like your own space? Just to hide from the world and relax knowing no one would invade it?

Imagine never having that at all. (I know some teenagers who live at home don't have that but at boarding school, it's usually shared dorms). People can easily access your stuff if you're not there. No privacy.

And routines. Bloody routines. For 7 years. Breakfast at a certain time, lunch, tea, prep and the same at the weekend. All decided for you. You have zero control over decisions. At least at home, a teenager can exercise some control. You just have to accept it.

I think boarding school explains a lot about my personality.

MarshaBrady · 24/09/2017 08:43

It was a fairly friendly place way back then. I bet skype etc doesn't change it that much.

You're still not at home, where you get your own time, your own stuff, family.

thegreylady · 24/09/2017 08:43

My lovely son in law and his brother went to boarding school and loved it. However, dsil and dd wouldn't send their two boys because a) it would put a strain on finances b) there are excellent local state schools and, most importantly, c) they love their times as a family at weekends etc. Each to their own I think.

GerdaLovesLili · 24/09/2017 08:49

I know I've told this story before, but Big Son was asked to leave his local primary school (in the days before Aspergers was routinely diagnosed) They couldn't cope with him, he was disrupting the other children's education and we did have the energy and resources to homeschool him. So we did, hoping to get him into a secondary school that would suit him better. Unfortunately when the time came he was one of 17 children in the borough for whom no secondary place could be found, and we sent him to a school in a neighbouring borough that had been re-branded, re-opened without the parents and children that had caused the complete break-down of the school and given a "superhead" who was keen to try out alternative educational strategies which seemed a good fit for our son.

All went well until the banished parents and children demanded that they should be allowed back, the local council changed and stopped the special funding that the school had been receiving, and DS1 was mugged twice, one at knife-point for his Pokemon cards of all things.

We were very fortunate that he passed the entrance exam for one of the very well regarded 13+ entry state grammar boarding school. We scrimped, and saved and remortgaged to afford the boarding fees, but it absolutely saved him. He felt safe, they provided an education that was aimed at his level of intelligence rather than making him feel like a freak, and the pastoral care was perfectly tailored for his needs.

He either came home or we visited him at every possible opportunity, and he was a short train-ride from one set of grandparents which meant we spent a lot of time there with him. We did not abandon him, he had all his educational and pastoral needs met and as there was no school locally to us that could do this or had space for him what other option did we have?

Having said that, I would not have sent him at 7 or 8 when we first started to home-ed him, neither he nor I could have coped emotionally.

therealpippi · 24/09/2017 09:05

Orlantina that's my point. No privacy. No time for one self. No hiding from the world. No confort during puberty. No safe place to feel a baby at times.

My 9 yo has gone theough a few weeks od wanting to eep
With me on and off. Worried about stuff. How would she havd dealt with is at BS? By keeping it in and toughening up.

BertramTheWalrus · 24/09/2017 09:07

Or are we suggesting that people who do these jobs should be denied a family life?

They don't have a family life though do they? I don't understand why anyone would have children and then send them off to boarding school - it means delegating nearly all decisions to the school, and hardly ever seeing them. It's daily life that creates a bond, not spending "quality time" together occasionally.