Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD thinks I'm v v v U. DH thinks I'm a bit U. I'm interested in your views

275 replies

chastenedButStillSmiling · 24/03/2017 23:59

DD is 15, and I start her bedtime process at 9 (to be clear, her bedtime process is private and involves only her - we don't bath her any more! But 9 is when I tell her it's bedtime). It takes her about 3/4 hour to be in the bathroom at night (5 mins in the mornings!), so the time she goes to bed is regularly about 9:45 pm.

She has sporting activities on both weekend days, which require her to be at the site, breakfasted and in kit at 7:45 (Saturday am) and 9:00 (Sunday am). She LOVES these activities.

But because she has to be there so early, I keep her w/end bedtime similar to her weekday one.

I should also say, DH (bless him!) doesn't drive, so I have to facilitate all these activities. (don't turn on DH... he's an amazing dad in a gazillion ways. He just hasn't got a driving licence. But he does LOADS, including most of the cooking for her, and he makes up the lack of his driving to me where he can)

DD thinks it's outrageous I tell her to go to bed so early during the week and she's beyond furious I also do it at weekends.

But she gets really, really tired. And she leads a very physical life. She does LOTS of sport.

On the other hand, I also facilitate everything for her... I take her and collect her to EVERYTHING and usually stay to watch and cheer her on (DH often comes along to do this too). And I facilitate her social life massively (partly because she's an only child, so I don't have to split my time). So a typical conversation on a Saturday day might be
Her I'm going into town but don't know whether to cycle or take the bus
Me why don't you cycle and if you need a lift home [because it's dark and you've got not lights/would be cycling alone], call me and I'll put your bike in the back of the car

I'm also very generous about lifts for her friends. She has a new-ish set of friends, so it's different to when they were all at primary and all the mums stood together on the playground. Back then, the kids would come out saying things like "we can join guides!" or "here's a leaflet about a hockey club, and I really want to do it" and all the mums would have a quick conflab, and lift-shares would be organised in the twinkling of an eye and it was always pretty fair.
Now she's got a new set of friends, who don't all live as locally and I don't know the parents (very well). Plus in her group of around 6, 2 of them are single mums due to bereavement of their DH's (which seems like a high statistic to me, but is the actual fact) or have other siblings which means that they can't leave them home alone.
So I do a LOT of driving her 'crew' home after parties/events during holidays and stuff and it's late. 10, 11, after midnight. And I'm generous about welcoming children who need a lift and dropping them at their doors. DD appreciates these moments when they happen, but doesn't retain that gratitude or bank it for later!

When she's not got to get up, I don't send her to bed. And when she can, she'll sleep for 12 hours plus (for day after day). I understand that teenagers do need to sleep, so when I'm sending her to bed, I'm not the bitch she thinks I am... I'm just trying to facilitate the rest I know think she needs.

She thinks I'm V U to tell her to go to bed. And not respecting her age and stage.
My DH kind-of agrees with her. And points out to me that other parents don't send their kids to bed. I point out that (a) if I don't tell her to go, she never makes the adult decision that "oh, I'm tired... I should go to bed now" or "I need an early night" and (b) other kids don't have to be up as early as her on weekends. So they have opportunities to catch up on their sleep that my DD doesn't have except in school holidays.

I think she needs the sleep. And I think I demonstrate over and over again that I help her do the things she wants to do.

The backstory (so as not to dripfeed) is that DD was an early riser from birth. Once she slept through, she woke up early. Really bloody early. (we read books, we tried methods.... nothing trained her out of it) but she slept the MOMENT her head hit that pillow. And it used to get to a particular point in the evenings, and you'd just see the tiredness sweeping over her... she'd go white, get black shadows under her eyes, be all weepy and not able to cope. Her waking gradually got later and later over the years (from regularly at 4 am to us being pleased she didn't wake until 5 and then didn't wake until nearly six [that phase lasted a good couple of years] and finally she learned to sleep in til around 7). At 10 she finally learned the art of sleeping in.... I think she learned to drop off again, rather than waking up and being all "I IS AWAAAAAKE". So to an extent, I carry that history with me.

So, should I back off? And let her choose her bedtime? She's on her GCSE course, so she needs to be alert in school.

but I will take your guidance.

Thanks for listening, and sorry it's long.

OP posts:
Therealjudgejudy · 25/03/2017 08:37

Yes you abu. You sound controlling to be honest...

Maybe get a hobby Smile

MoreCrackThanHarlem · 25/03/2017 08:37

My 15yo goes to bed at 10.15. Sometimes earlier if she's tired (voluntarily). If I didn't set this as the latest time she'd be up watching Grey's Anatomy box sets until some ungodly hour.

Yanbu. I work with teenagers and see tired, grumpy sods unable to learn and moody as hell every day.

However I would relax on a weekend. I don't set Friday or Saturday bedtimes and actually dd is generally in bed by 10.30 as her weekends are full of physical activity like your dd.

Ignore all the competitive posts where 12 year olds are up at 11pm playing computer games. Not healthy and not enough sleep.

winobaglady · 25/03/2017 08:38

Let her get herself to bed and up in the mornings for school and weekend activities.
If she's not up when you'd need to drive her, she doesn't go.

treaclesoda · 25/03/2017 08:42

When I was 15 there is no way I would even have had my homework finished by 9pm never mind be ready for bed. My parents were fairly strict in a lot of ways, but there is no way they were setting my bedtime when I was 15.

Relax a bit, she will be fine, honest.

Woollymammoth63 · 25/03/2017 08:45

My DS is 15 we get up at 6.30 and he does lots of sport and long days.
I start his ' bedtime process' at ten, I do shoe him along then to be asleep by 10.30 though it's often 11 due to faffing. He boards at a school 4 days a week and they start the ' bedtime process' at ten . K
Lights out it settled by 10.15
It's too early, give her some space. I went to bed at ten from the age of 11 or so. Didn't sleep till much later due to reading. You are treating her like a young child.

Buck3t · 25/03/2017 08:47

OP I know we come to MN for a different point of view. And I'm not saying to not take on board some comments about how you do it. But sleep is important. You are not unreasonable.

I did the test last year when my son was 13 before a big match the next day. He failed miserably. Think popcorn, Jurassic park, 3.30am. The thing is I knew he would fail the test. How? Because I know my son. But I'm one of those that believe he has to learn for himself.

He's still growing and I feel if his dad still needs 9-10 hours and I need 6.5, then he at the very least needs 8 (very scientific in my reasoning Hmm)

SadMumma · 25/03/2017 08:48

My 13yo DD does an awful lot of sport (13 hours a week); puts herself to bed when tired - sometimes 8.30, sometimes 10.30.

She sets her alarm for 6.30 weekdays and at whatever time she is needed for a match or competition at weekends.

How will your DD grow up if you are still controlling her to this level? She will be one who will rush off to university or college as soon as she can and she won't be coming home many weekends...... just saying.

Beelands · 25/03/2017 08:48

Your OP has really made me LOL. Bless you! You are a lovely mum. All those words about one 15 year olds bedtime, it's clear how fascinating you find her and how much you treasure her.

No advice really, but your OP was touching and funny.

llangennith · 25/03/2017 08:49

OP didn't say she felt she was owed something in return for giving DD and her friends numerous regular lifts, she implied that her DD's gratitude and appreciation didn't last long. Which is typical teenage behaviour. They think you're the best mum in the world one minute, the mother from hell the next.
I sent my teenagers up to their rooms at 10 telling them they'd better be asleep before 11.
I don't think you're being that U as your DD has a full-on schedule but she has to find out for herself that she may have to drop some of her activities if she doesn't get enough sleep.
Despite your rows you and your DD sound very close.

yoohooitsme · 25/03/2017 09:01

15?

Yes explain to her your reasoning and leave her to decide what happens, to get it wrong - don't we all sometimes? - and to work out if she prefers to be well rested or tired

I hope she has autonomy over other normaly personal things by now.

Are you enabling her to get other important life skills like cooking meals, nutrition money management, and friendships. Please don't Molly coddle or over care for her. At some point this becomes interfering and is not pretty. My mum did too much for me and I was 30 odd before I considered how to manage a fridge and cook good meals. Don't get me started on the damage she did to my finances. It killed our relationship.

Said with kindness.

TealStar · 25/03/2017 09:02

My friend and her ex-dh share equal parenting. When the kids are with her, it's lights out and their gadgets are regulated. He however is Disney Dad Hmm. When they come back from three nights at his they are like zombies, and she says it takes nearly all the time back at hers to 'reset' them back into bright, alert teenagers. I feel for her, it's a struggle enough to guide them as it is.

TealStar · 25/03/2017 09:02

*i don't mean 'them' as her kids in partic, just kids generically

25bottles · 25/03/2017 09:04

At 15 I was getting drunk in the park at 9 o'clock lol.
10-11pm is a better bed time.

GTS · 25/03/2017 09:10

well that escalated quickly!

I'm not going to offer you any advice as you've had lots of sensible suggestions, I just wanted to say that you have been very reasonable and dignified in your responses OP, despite the absolute bashing you have received from some PP's.

I think you sound lovely for what it's worth.

GreenGlassLove · 25/03/2017 09:11

When my boys were 15 they never had a bedtime. They went to bed whenever they wanted but they knew when they had to leave the house to get to school and if they were late or tired that was their problem. They learnt to get early nights on weekdays fairly quickly.

Chewbecca · 25/03/2017 09:12

What I am a bit confused about is that presumably you get up at the same time as your DD but don't go to bed at the same time.

Agree with other posters that it is time to allow her to work it out for herself & to start to grow up a little.

My DS is 13 and we often all go to bed at 10. If he is staying up until 10 on a school night, I do ensure he has got ready for bed before 10 so at 10, he actually goes to bed.

Good luck with trying it out, you sound like a very caring mum.

MrsJBaptiste · 25/03/2017 09:14

I can't believe so many of you abandon bedtimes at 11 or 12, my nearly 13 year old still gets told when it's time to head up to bed which is generally 9ish or 10pm after activities. Not weekends though, he stays up / goes on his tablet in bed until he's tired which is generally around 11pm.

Some kids just need more sleep though. My son can go up at 9pm, be asleep by 9.15 and have to be prised out of bed at 7am. Weekends he's wake at 9ish so seems to need around 10 hours sleep. But would he get used to having less if he always went to bed later and got up early?

randomer · 25/03/2017 09:14

in a couple of years timme she may be at Uni or working. How's that going to work?

LagunaBubbles · 25/03/2017 09:15

I mean this in the nicest possible way but do you have anything else to occupy your time with OP apart from being anxuiys about your DD?

LagunaBubbles · 25/03/2017 09:15

Anxious!!

elodie2000 · 25/03/2017 09:25

in a couple of years timme she may be at Uni or working. How's that going to work?

I imagine OP's DD will be just fine. She's been taught early on that it's important to look after herself and balance social life with work/ other activities with rest/ sleep. Loads of teenagers/ young adults 'burn out' and haven't any idea why.

Quartz2208 · 25/03/2017 09:26

Bless you you sound like a highly anxious person (why would we turn for example on your DH because he doesnt drive) who wants everything to turn out ok for your daughter so does everything for her.

The thing is that does not prepare them for adulthood, giving them rules and boundaries (stopping electronics at a certain time) is different to trying to micro manage them. Set out rules by all means - no electronics from 9pm for example no phones upstairs.

Let her start making her own decisions - if she says I dont know whether to cycle or take the bus, let her decide.

Facilitating letting her make her own decisions is important and its important to remember that these decisions may well fail her to begin with but allowing her to learn from her mistakes is such an important part of growing up. Making her mistakes now is far better than letting her older when it could get more out of control. The only way you can learn the adult decision of going to bed is learning what happens when you dont

RitaMills · 25/03/2017 09:33

Gosh obviously YABU, I'm glad you've taken on board what people have said though.

I can't actually believe you had to mention the fact you don't bathe a 15 year old, at first I thought your OP was about a child with a life limiting disability, my jaw dropped a bit as I read further.

Borntorunfast · 25/03/2017 09:37

Blimey there's a lot of grumpy people on here. Maybe they're all tired...Wink

OP I needed a LOT of sleep as a kid, as a teen and funnily enough as an adult. I'm in bed for 10 mostly. But I always put myself to bed, from a very young age. Anyway, you've been very dignified so ignore the legions of grumpy, snappy, sleep deprived comments on here and good luck.

Foureyesarebetterthantwo · 25/03/2017 09:42

I teach university students and I think it's a myth that the ones left to their own devices so they can 'self-regulate' do really well at adulthood. I have too many friends who have had, especially their male teens at 14/15, are self-regulate by smoking cannabis lots and stay up til 2/3am, then fail their GCSEs and already are struggling to find their way. They fall behind quite quickly at this age and all teens are not good self-regulators at all, in fact many do very stupid things if left to their own devices. You have to get to the stage of being a successful adult to enjoy that freedom, and having messed up your exams which is a real consequence of poor sleep/loss of motivation isn't a great way to find out how the world works.

I also find the language of 'she's nearly an adult', 'leaving home' ' at uni' quite funny, because if the OP had posted something like her 15 year old was dating a 20 year old, everyone would have been piling in saying 'she's just a child', 'she's so vulnerable', 'you are still the adult in the situation, parent!'- whether a 15 year old has much autonomy and needs parental boundaries seems to depend on the issue!