Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD thinks I'm v v v U. DH thinks I'm a bit U. I'm interested in your views

275 replies

chastenedButStillSmiling · 24/03/2017 23:59

DD is 15, and I start her bedtime process at 9 (to be clear, her bedtime process is private and involves only her - we don't bath her any more! But 9 is when I tell her it's bedtime). It takes her about 3/4 hour to be in the bathroom at night (5 mins in the mornings!), so the time she goes to bed is regularly about 9:45 pm.

She has sporting activities on both weekend days, which require her to be at the site, breakfasted and in kit at 7:45 (Saturday am) and 9:00 (Sunday am). She LOVES these activities.

But because she has to be there so early, I keep her w/end bedtime similar to her weekday one.

I should also say, DH (bless him!) doesn't drive, so I have to facilitate all these activities. (don't turn on DH... he's an amazing dad in a gazillion ways. He just hasn't got a driving licence. But he does LOADS, including most of the cooking for her, and he makes up the lack of his driving to me where he can)

DD thinks it's outrageous I tell her to go to bed so early during the week and she's beyond furious I also do it at weekends.

But she gets really, really tired. And she leads a very physical life. She does LOTS of sport.

On the other hand, I also facilitate everything for her... I take her and collect her to EVERYTHING and usually stay to watch and cheer her on (DH often comes along to do this too). And I facilitate her social life massively (partly because she's an only child, so I don't have to split my time). So a typical conversation on a Saturday day might be
Her I'm going into town but don't know whether to cycle or take the bus
Me why don't you cycle and if you need a lift home [because it's dark and you've got not lights/would be cycling alone], call me and I'll put your bike in the back of the car

I'm also very generous about lifts for her friends. She has a new-ish set of friends, so it's different to when they were all at primary and all the mums stood together on the playground. Back then, the kids would come out saying things like "we can join guides!" or "here's a leaflet about a hockey club, and I really want to do it" and all the mums would have a quick conflab, and lift-shares would be organised in the twinkling of an eye and it was always pretty fair.
Now she's got a new set of friends, who don't all live as locally and I don't know the parents (very well). Plus in her group of around 6, 2 of them are single mums due to bereavement of their DH's (which seems like a high statistic to me, but is the actual fact) or have other siblings which means that they can't leave them home alone.
So I do a LOT of driving her 'crew' home after parties/events during holidays and stuff and it's late. 10, 11, after midnight. And I'm generous about welcoming children who need a lift and dropping them at their doors. DD appreciates these moments when they happen, but doesn't retain that gratitude or bank it for later!

When she's not got to get up, I don't send her to bed. And when she can, she'll sleep for 12 hours plus (for day after day). I understand that teenagers do need to sleep, so when I'm sending her to bed, I'm not the bitch she thinks I am... I'm just trying to facilitate the rest I know think she needs.

She thinks I'm V U to tell her to go to bed. And not respecting her age and stage.
My DH kind-of agrees with her. And points out to me that other parents don't send their kids to bed. I point out that (a) if I don't tell her to go, she never makes the adult decision that "oh, I'm tired... I should go to bed now" or "I need an early night" and (b) other kids don't have to be up as early as her on weekends. So they have opportunities to catch up on their sleep that my DD doesn't have except in school holidays.

I think she needs the sleep. And I think I demonstrate over and over again that I help her do the things she wants to do.

The backstory (so as not to dripfeed) is that DD was an early riser from birth. Once she slept through, she woke up early. Really bloody early. (we read books, we tried methods.... nothing trained her out of it) but she slept the MOMENT her head hit that pillow. And it used to get to a particular point in the evenings, and you'd just see the tiredness sweeping over her... she'd go white, get black shadows under her eyes, be all weepy and not able to cope. Her waking gradually got later and later over the years (from regularly at 4 am to us being pleased she didn't wake until 5 and then didn't wake until nearly six [that phase lasted a good couple of years] and finally she learned to sleep in til around 7). At 10 she finally learned the art of sleeping in.... I think she learned to drop off again, rather than waking up and being all "I IS AWAAAAAKE". So to an extent, I carry that history with me.

So, should I back off? And let her choose her bedtime? She's on her GCSE course, so she needs to be alert in school.

but I will take your guidance.

Thanks for listening, and sorry it's long.

OP posts:
TheGaleanthropist · 25/03/2017 15:01

You're not the only one who has made observations based on actually teaching university students FourEyesAre.

user1476961324 · 25/03/2017 15:04

"DD is 15, and I start her bedtime process at 9"

Ha ha! Oh dear OP. I'm sure you are well meaning but YABU.

She's almost an adult - if she's tired, she will learn to go to bed earlier.

Is there any other areas in which she thinks you are controlling? Because it sounds like she may be correct Hmm

LittleMissMarker · 25/03/2017 15:08

I should also say, DH (bless him!) doesn't drive, so I have to facilitate all these activities. (don't turn on DH... he's an amazing dad in a gazillion ways. He just hasn't got a driving licence. But he does LOADS, including most of the cooking for her, and he makes up the lack of his driving to me where he can)

Actually... if my DH had ever said anything like that about me I'd be very offended. What activities your DD can do should be a family decision which takes into account the fact that your DH doesn't drive. It's not something that you decide and then expect him to make up to you.

Her I'm going into town but don't know whether to cycle or take the bus
Me why don't you cycle and if you need a lift home [because it's dark and you've got not lights/would be cycling alone], call me and I'll put your bike in the back of the car

How the conversation could have gone is: "You can't ride without lights so if you don't want to come home before dark you'd better get the bus". She had a safe legal way to get home without you jumping in. She didn't ask you to drive her home, she just failed to come up with a reason why you shouldn't do it, so why would she feel grateful?

I'm also very generous about lifts for her friends.

Stop martyring yourself. The way to make it clear to your DD that these lifts are privileges is to say no when it doesn't suit you.

Bedtime is only one of the things you need to start backing out of! Let your DD develop independence and make life easier on yourself.

DebiNewberry · 25/03/2017 15:16

I haven't read beyond the first few pages so perhaps the pile on has reversed. I definitely don't think you are being u. Week bedtime def fine maybe try a later one on the Saturday but it seems as tho she has occasional late nights anyway. You know your child and if she needs a whole heap of sleep, that's what she needs. I'm 37 years old and a couple of nights a week I'm in bed by 9.30. Some of these bedtimes mentioned in the thread seem way too late for me, we're not all the same. Mn posters sometimes seem to have an odd hands off attitude to teens whilst proclaiming the need for boundaries.

chastenedButStillSmiling · 25/03/2017 15:22

it swung back and forth, Debi

Wow. 11 pages. Thanks for the comments. I asked and certainly got given very clear messages. Lots of interesting points n stuff to ponder.

Have already told DD that I'm backing off. She was actually quite cross Confused
Turns out that when they're having bitching sessions about parents, this is what she always brings up.

Thank you almost- all for taking the time and sharing your experiences.

OP posts:
Vegansnake · 25/03/2017 15:36

Fucking hell...mine would disown me if I behaved like that..your her mum not her manager..back off let her breathe...if this is real...I suspect not..l left home at 18 and a day,never went back..stood on my own two feet ever since,I predict you have 3 yrs before she does the same .

Medeci · 25/03/2017 16:00

Good grief! I left home at 16 and sometimes partied most of the night and still managed to work the next day.
Let her sort out her own sleep.

ZombieApocalips · 25/03/2017 16:20

I have a son the same age. He's allowed to go to bed when he's ready but he's not allowed to be noisy after 9pm when his brother goes to sleep and he must be on time in the morning.

In 3 years she'll be at uni and free to go to sleep whenever anyway. It's best that she learns now than later. If that means she's bleary eyed the next day then so be it. She will hopefully come to the same conclusion as you. (Btw I'm surprised that you know that she falls asleep as soon as her head hits the pillow at age 15)

ICancelledTheCheque · 25/03/2017 16:31

I think you did the right thing in backing off, OP.

My 10 and 11 YOs go to bed at 9. They do swimming 2-3 times a week and football practice twice a week, plus a gym class with me and their usual PE, so quite active.

When I was 15 I didn't have a bedtime at weekends and I would sleep at around half ten on school nights.

She does still need some boundaries though - my parents pretty much didn't know what to do with me so left me to it and I have to say that was not the right thing to do at all - you just have to pick age appropriate boundaries and a 9pm bedtime isn't one of them Smile

andshewillbeloved · 25/03/2017 16:40

She will move out at the first opportunity she gets. I know I would.

ddssdd · 25/03/2017 16:43

littlemissmarker spot on!

OP, you sound a little odd. All the things you have described that you do for your child, is nothing more than being a Parent Hmm.

HiMyNameIsUnknown · 25/03/2017 16:49

OP I really wish people would RTFT. You've taken on people's comments and implemented a change, well done!

LorLorr2 · 25/03/2017 18:27

You are the parent and she will thank you when she's older for guiding to sleep enough. :)

mathanxiety · 26/03/2017 06:09

LimitedEdition:
OP, I hope you find some sort of middle ground so your DD starts to feel a sense of accomplishment in being more independent, but please don't swing too far towards the other way because I bet anything your DD is known to her teachers at school for being a well-disciplined, pleasant and sunny student

There is a difference between regimented and well disciplined. A regimented student may not cause problems in a classroom, but may have problems even without acting out. It is a mistake for teachers to assume from compliant school behaviour that a student is on the right track or emotionally healthy or living in a home where she is happy.

Discipline comes from within. This young woman is living in an extremely structured environment. Her time is very much accounted for with school and her sports, and homework.

I suggest that the truth about how disciplined she is will emerge when she finds herself in an environment where the way she fills her days and nights is completely up to her.

WicksEnd · 27/03/2017 18:16

Hi it's me, 'Drop feed accuser' Grin coined the term all on my own
Well, good on you for taking all the comments on board.

Don't worry your DD will soon find something else to whinge to her friends about now that the bedtime routine has been lifted.

Was she a zombie or full of the joys of spring this morning?

Amaried · 27/03/2017 20:50

Definitely back off....
Shock

amusedbush · 27/03/2017 20:58

Fuck me, I had an 11pm curfew at 15 and by 17 I could pretty much do whatever I wanted so long as I let my mum know when to expect me. You seriously need to back off.

chastenedButStillSmiling · 27/03/2017 23:48

Love it "Wicks" - going to steal it from now on!

On Saturday night she had to be up extra early on Sunday am (and the clocks were changing) and I was trying REALLY hard not to be looking at the clock. I think she saw me trying not to look!

Bloody DH went to tell her tonight (as it's a school night) and I was all "no... no... no... I've promised her she can set the time from now on" and he was cross with me as well "I only meant on weekends!"
I think I've annoyed everyone!
She came up at 20 past 9. And was - as many of you suggested - in the bathroom for less time.

I'm awarding myself 3 MN points, and giving her a Star

OP posts:
CouldntMakeThisShitUp · 28/03/2017 02:04

So you're a helicopter parent then, OP?

How is she supposed to learn to take responsibility for herself if YOU are doing all the 'facilitating' for her?
I take it she has enough brain cells to know she needs decent sleep/calories and self discipline if she wants to live an independent life?

I think you should start concentrating on your own life outside the home,OP.

OlennasWimple · 28/03/2017 02:13

RTFT, peeps!

HiMyNameIsUnknown · 28/03/2017 02:36

Well done OPStar

user1471545174 · 28/03/2017 05:58

She's almost an adult, what the hell happened to the world in the past 20 years?

pilates · 28/03/2017 18:20

FGS Couldn't Op has taken on board the comments and made changes!

Dixiestamp · 29/03/2017 03:11

I used to go after the 10 o'clock news at 15, I seem to remember. My 9 yr old starts getting ready about 9 (but a real 'non sleeper') so I can see why she thinks you are being u.

Dixiestamp · 29/03/2017 03:14

Pressed enter too soon! I can imagine it will work out better now if you at try things - fingers crossed it works out for both of you.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread