Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD thinks I'm v v v U. DH thinks I'm a bit U. I'm interested in your views

275 replies

chastenedButStillSmiling · 24/03/2017 23:59

DD is 15, and I start her bedtime process at 9 (to be clear, her bedtime process is private and involves only her - we don't bath her any more! But 9 is when I tell her it's bedtime). It takes her about 3/4 hour to be in the bathroom at night (5 mins in the mornings!), so the time she goes to bed is regularly about 9:45 pm.

She has sporting activities on both weekend days, which require her to be at the site, breakfasted and in kit at 7:45 (Saturday am) and 9:00 (Sunday am). She LOVES these activities.

But because she has to be there so early, I keep her w/end bedtime similar to her weekday one.

I should also say, DH (bless him!) doesn't drive, so I have to facilitate all these activities. (don't turn on DH... he's an amazing dad in a gazillion ways. He just hasn't got a driving licence. But he does LOADS, including most of the cooking for her, and he makes up the lack of his driving to me where he can)

DD thinks it's outrageous I tell her to go to bed so early during the week and she's beyond furious I also do it at weekends.

But she gets really, really tired. And she leads a very physical life. She does LOTS of sport.

On the other hand, I also facilitate everything for her... I take her and collect her to EVERYTHING and usually stay to watch and cheer her on (DH often comes along to do this too). And I facilitate her social life massively (partly because she's an only child, so I don't have to split my time). So a typical conversation on a Saturday day might be
Her I'm going into town but don't know whether to cycle or take the bus
Me why don't you cycle and if you need a lift home [because it's dark and you've got not lights/would be cycling alone], call me and I'll put your bike in the back of the car

I'm also very generous about lifts for her friends. She has a new-ish set of friends, so it's different to when they were all at primary and all the mums stood together on the playground. Back then, the kids would come out saying things like "we can join guides!" or "here's a leaflet about a hockey club, and I really want to do it" and all the mums would have a quick conflab, and lift-shares would be organised in the twinkling of an eye and it was always pretty fair.
Now she's got a new set of friends, who don't all live as locally and I don't know the parents (very well). Plus in her group of around 6, 2 of them are single mums due to bereavement of their DH's (which seems like a high statistic to me, but is the actual fact) or have other siblings which means that they can't leave them home alone.
So I do a LOT of driving her 'crew' home after parties/events during holidays and stuff and it's late. 10, 11, after midnight. And I'm generous about welcoming children who need a lift and dropping them at their doors. DD appreciates these moments when they happen, but doesn't retain that gratitude or bank it for later!

When she's not got to get up, I don't send her to bed. And when she can, she'll sleep for 12 hours plus (for day after day). I understand that teenagers do need to sleep, so when I'm sending her to bed, I'm not the bitch she thinks I am... I'm just trying to facilitate the rest I know think she needs.

She thinks I'm V U to tell her to go to bed. And not respecting her age and stage.
My DH kind-of agrees with her. And points out to me that other parents don't send their kids to bed. I point out that (a) if I don't tell her to go, she never makes the adult decision that "oh, I'm tired... I should go to bed now" or "I need an early night" and (b) other kids don't have to be up as early as her on weekends. So they have opportunities to catch up on their sleep that my DD doesn't have except in school holidays.

I think she needs the sleep. And I think I demonstrate over and over again that I help her do the things she wants to do.

The backstory (so as not to dripfeed) is that DD was an early riser from birth. Once she slept through, she woke up early. Really bloody early. (we read books, we tried methods.... nothing trained her out of it) but she slept the MOMENT her head hit that pillow. And it used to get to a particular point in the evenings, and you'd just see the tiredness sweeping over her... she'd go white, get black shadows under her eyes, be all weepy and not able to cope. Her waking gradually got later and later over the years (from regularly at 4 am to us being pleased she didn't wake until 5 and then didn't wake until nearly six [that phase lasted a good couple of years] and finally she learned to sleep in til around 7). At 10 she finally learned the art of sleeping in.... I think she learned to drop off again, rather than waking up and being all "I IS AWAAAAAKE". So to an extent, I carry that history with me.

So, should I back off? And let her choose her bedtime? She's on her GCSE course, so she needs to be alert in school.

but I will take your guidance.

Thanks for listening, and sorry it's long.

OP posts:
londonrach · 25/03/2017 02:58

Slightly controlling for a 15 year old. She. Needs to learn herself. 9am is vvvv early anyway. Yabu

JonesyAndTheSalad · 25/03/2017 02:59

My TWELVE year old sorts herself out now OP! SHe's almost 13 and decides at about 9 that she will have her (LONG) shower...then by about 10 she goes to her room...watches a bit of Netflix and puts her own light out at about 11.

She is Busy with a capital B but she wakes up fine in the morning.

Katedotness1963 · 25/03/2017 03:05

Our kids don't have a bedtime, haven't for a few years. The 15 year old gets ready for bed about 10, the 17 year old about 11. They have to be up at 6 for school. At the weekends they can do what they want, the youngest stays up gaming with his friends and the eldest is usually out or has friends over.

JungleInTheRumble · 25/03/2017 03:15

I think the OP gets it guys! She asked whether she was BU, mumsnet said yes and she's taking it on board.

No one gives you a manual for these things...

Time to lay off?

Graphista · 25/03/2017 03:28

Yab ridiculous so U!

Her toddler sleep issues, lifts etc etc etc are NOTHING to do with the main issue!

You are FAR too involved in her life generally she must feel pure suffocated!

I'm 44, 30 years ago I went to bed on school nights of my own volition at 10pm (I swear I could use the theme tune of the equalizer as a sleep aid Grin)

Are you also insisting she bathes every night too? Or is she doing so as a pp suggests in order to not be going to bed even earlier?

You have GOT to loosen the apron strings!

A minor rebellion against bedtime could be the least of your worries if you continue this way.

I went back to uni as a mature student and noticed even more than my first time that the students with very strict/controlling parents were the ones that went wild. Partly as rebellion, partly as they couldn't cope with the sudden autonomy (attached to a big load of money at beginning of each term, cheap booze on the doorstep, cheap easily accessible drugs etc)

The ones who had been expected to help at home, budget, manage their time, school work and extra curricular activities themselves were far better equipped both emotionally and in practical skills to cope with the independance.

Our job as parents is to create self sufficient healthy adults.

KittyWindbag · 25/03/2017 04:15

OP you sound like a new CEO mum but I think it's very yellow by that keep referring to 'children'.

I mean, yes, technically she is a child. But she's a teenager on the verge of doing GCSEs. You're keeping her in babyhood. She needs to learn how to facilitate her own life a bit.

It may even be that it is just not possible to keep up all her extra curricular activities as she gets older, and maybe that's a realization she has to come to alone as well.

KittyWindbag · 25/03/2017 04:15

Ffs, you sound like a nice mum not a new CEO Hmm

Itwillbefine · 25/03/2017 05:38

I went to bed at 9 at that age, but it was my choice. I love my sleep, shame I'm a bit of an insomniac now.

Let her work it out herself now.

lorelairoryemily · 25/03/2017 05:43

That is the longest post about absolutely nothing that I've ever read.

ScarletFever · 25/03/2017 05:54

Bloody hell op is getting a full on bashing here... is no one reading the updates??

My DS is 15 and we send him up around 9ish on a weekday - it's not wrong it's not worth all the bashing the op is getting

And if one poster was out clubbing at 15 surely that's worse (illegal too probably? Drinking? ) than a child (yes 15 is a child) being looked after?

Don't think I would be giving all her friends a lift home though..

RubyRedRuby · 25/03/2017 05:56

Op - I think you've taken this very well given some of the overly aggressive responses!
Hope your dd finds her own sleep routine easily, tired teenagers are hell on wheels. I do think a cut off time for devices/internet is still a good idea - I wish someone would do it for me Grin

floraeasy · 25/03/2017 05:58

I think it may be time to let your DD start managing her own time.

She may overdo it at first and get too tired (pendulum effect) but then will start to adjust her times. She has to learn some time, doesn't she? So it's best she gets started now and she can feel more in control of her life.

TesticlesInTheBlender · 25/03/2017 06:04

Out of interest at what age do you start leaving them to decide their own bedtime? DS is 12 and wouldn't sleep until midnight if was given the choice. And then he wouldn't get up either...

squashytoes · 25/03/2017 06:07

I think some posters have been a little harsh in the way they have worded their responses. I hear what you are saying, but she really is too old to be told what time to go to bed, especially when that time is so early.

My three year old goes to bed at 7:30 so it does sound very very early to me for a 15 year old to be made to go just an hour and a half later!

I would just remind her she has to be up early, but leave her to decide when she wants to go to bed. If she starts sleeping in, missing activities, being late, struggling to perform, then remind her going to bed earlier would help. If she takes herself off to bed at a reasonable time and it doesn't affect her activities then just leave her be.

She is an adult in just three short years, she needs to learn to manage sleep herself

Limitededition7inch · 25/03/2017 06:17

OP, while I do think you sound a helicopter parent, I really dislike the MNetters who come out in force during these types of debates by saying "oh, my 5 year old goes at that time...." or "I never take my phone off them...", citing the fact that children have to be free to learn the consequences.

Some children, when all is said and done, do not learn the consequences and that's just the facts. It's our responsibility as adults to instill a bit of discipline in them. I wonder how many of you have the privilege of teaching 30 over-tired, truculent teenagers day in, day out? They have the attention span of a goldfish and it's pretty irritating to say the least. When we contact parents about bad behaviour and the like many of them say that they'll take phones off at night or Xbox etc out of their bedroom. As a teaching staff we're unanimous in believing they shouldn't be in there in the first place.

Based on what I read on here I classify myself as a very liberal and actually hands off parent, but bedtimes are pretty sacrosanct in our house.

OP, I actually agree with your stance on sleep, but the language you use when you talk about your DD is more concerning to me.

hesterton · 25/03/2017 06:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Tiptoethr0ughthetulips · 25/03/2017 06:25

OP you come across as well meaning and caring BUT my god you are unreasonable and overbearing. Back off now and you might stave off a rebellion. Your daughter is old enough to decide ( within reason) when she needs to go to bed and if she's not up for her activities at the weekend tough. If she likes the activities enough she'll take responsibility for making sure she's able to do them, if not then she'll knock them on the head.

At 15 I was out in night clubs ( behind parents backs), drinking and smoking. In pursuit of a boyfriend with a car. I know times have changed but you are lucky your daughter has towed the line thus far.

Universitychallenging · 25/03/2017 06:28

You need to let her go to sleep herself. She's 15. But you know and have acknowledged that.

More importantly what you do need to do is realise in your head that she's not that toddler anymore.

So when she says will I take my bike or get the bus don't offer her a solution let her work it out for herself.

That's what you're doing - you're managing her life.

If she's tired she can sleep in the afternoon. If she's tired she can figure it out herself. She's 15 and you're babying her.

Her sleep when she was a toddler isn't relevant to now. And that's damaging to keep referring back to that. My DD had horrific tantrum when she was 4. Really awful horrific ones. If I said, every time she was cross now, go to your room and stay there or otherwise threaten her anger now in the same way I had when she was 4, that would be wrong, infantilising and treating her inappropriately over her sleep.

Even the way you talk about the friends - her crew - makes me cringe a bit for you. And dropping them off and picking them up - lots of parents do that. You sound a teeny bit martyr with that.

And helping her do the things she wants to do - that's called being a parent. Your posts sounds a little like "go to bed at 9" and there's an implied threat of "or I won't take you".

Oh and if your DH can he should learn to drive.

And if the other parents don't stay to watch you shouldn't either.

TheRealKimmySchmidt63 · 25/03/2017 06:32

I would stick to what you're doing on nights before school and allow flexibility on a fri/sat - but talk with her about it

Universitychallenging · 25/03/2017 06:35

Another thing. (Sorry - this is long itself) there's an air of superiority in your posts. There's a faint I don't believe two friends are widowed, how feckless they are to have more than one child I'm amazing I can drive my DH can't. Even "her crew". Not just a bunch of mates but her crew - so what? She's in charge? She's the head of the bunch? The rest aren't her equals?

That would really irritate me in real life. I've had the jolly hockey mummy look down her nose at me and my inadequacy. It made me feel crap.

I do think you should look at your language and attitude in general and I hope you can take this as a positive criticism as I am not trying to have a go at you but just to hopefully be helpful.

Unihorn · 25/03/2017 06:37

Nice to see your reasonable replies OP but yes, a bedtime for a 15 year old is bizarre. I stopped having a bedtime at 11. By 15 I was often going to sleep between 11pm and midnight. If I was tired the next day it was my fault and I had to learn to get up. In a year's time she could legally have her own child and set their bedtime!!

Universitychallenging · 25/03/2017 06:39

legally have a child.. ouch. I hope you don't mean that how it comes across.

Blinkyblink · 25/03/2017 06:41

OP, my bedtime was the sane at 15.
Also incredibly sporty
Also has to be up early every day for long commute to school (bus left 7.20)
I was also a bit embarrassed and resentful
BUT
My friends would constantly moan how tired they were and I would actually PRETEND to be tired, when in actually fact I was never tired. I was fully rested. I have a vivid memory of looking at the dark shadows under my best friend's eyes as she told me she'd be listening to nirvana until gone 11.

So I go against the drain and say o don't think you're being unreasonable at all! Having said that, I do think that you can compromise, that's important to show that you listen to her. How about saying lights off by 10. And leave it at that. She then decides when she wants to start getting ready for bed etc. That's her business at 15. But lights of 10, period.

Blinkyblink · 25/03/2017 06:41

Grain

footballmum · 25/03/2017 06:44

FFS. The OP asked "and I being unreasonable?" The majority say "yes" and she says "ok I'll change. Thanks" But that's not good enough for many posters who go on and on and on with not only telling her she is unreasonable but that she's weird, controlling, superior! I swear some people like to kick people for the sake of it. So much for supporting other women eh? The OP has, in good humour, taken all of the comments on board without getting defensive but some of you still feel the need to hand her her arse on a plate. Hope it makes you feel better or even, dare I say it, "superior"!

I'm not even going to comment on whether you're being unreasonable OP because you've clearly reached that conclusion yourself and you don't need yet another person telling you that you are. If I were you I'd hide your thread and carry on having an unreasonably good relationship with your DD Flowers