"FWIW I'm not at all comfortable about using human beings as some kind of bargaining chips, but looking at this rationally does it really make sense to start guaranteeing things for foreign nationals before we talk about what reciprocal arrangements will be in place for UK citizens?"
To those who find it acceptable for the government to use Eu citizens who are settled in in the UK as 'bargaining chips', please do remember that these people moved to the UK legally and in good faith. They study and work, they marry and have children, they love and engage with 'native' Brits who are their neighbours, PILs, spouses, children (!!!), many of these people have lived here for decades, own property and consider this country as their home. That has been their right and the UK has been more than happy for EU employees to pay into the system. and take advantage in myriad other ways.
Now, the government states these 3 million human beings cannot be sure of their future any longer. Our government has decided that the people that moved here and whose homes are here can no longer be sure that they still have a home here in 2 years and that they may have to leave behind all the social networks they have built over many years in the UK.
Imagine that. Just think about that. People scrambling for papers from 10, 20, 30 even 40 years ago, bank statements, health records and what not to ensure that they won't be kicked out.
And please, sit saying "that will never happen".
The government has publicly signalled that it is prepared for exactly this to happen.
Remember we are not talking about new EU citizens moving here post Brexit but about people whose homes are here.
And then just imagine it were you. and all you knew, loved and had worked for over decades was held up to the world as simply........... a bargaining chip.