Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be severely annoyed at DD?

303 replies

worriedmother1929 · 11/09/2016 16:50

Last night DD17 went to an 18th birthday party. Myself and DH said she could drink a bit, but asked her not to get too drunk as her half dithers and their partners & children were coming over for a BBQ today, and we didn't want her to be hungover for a family occasion, and this would be her first time drinking alcohol in any large volume. She texted me this morning to ask if I could bring paracetamol and water to her when I went to pick her up (she slept over) and she was hungover beyond belief when I got her. I asked her what she had drank and she said nearly an entire bottle of some sort of strawberry drink, with a pretty high % of alcohol.
She's come home with a smashed phone (thankfully only her screen protector), multitudes of bruises on her legs from bumping into things and falling over, and has possibly re-injured her ankle which she sprained in April.
I'm disappointed in her for ignoring what DH and I said, as she was a mess at the BBQ and put a dampener on the entire afternoon, but I'm also disappointed that she didn't even think about what she was drinking and just seemed to fill up on whatever was at hand. I'm also disappointed that she has put herself at risk, and damaged something my husband and I bought for her. I understand teenagers drink, and do sometimes go OTT, but when I asked her to reign it in she ignored me and did something I had explicitly asked her not to.
AIBU to be annoyed with her?

OP posts:
DeathStare · 11/09/2016 19:41

i also think you were an absolute battle axe making her sit through dinner. That's harsh and has more to do with your attitude. It's a totally fake consequence, which is massively inappropriate for that age group. More like mind games

Couldn't agree more.

DeadGood · 11/09/2016 19:45

Oh FGS OP, I just read your updates. You sound awful - why exactly did you post on AIBU? Because you don't seem to be taking on the overwhelming "you ARE being unreasonable" verdict on board.

Italiangreyhound · 11/09/2016 19:46

GeorgeTheThird 'a safe place with parents present' take a look at the article I linked to.

worriedmother1929 I think the safest thing is for kids to learn to drink safely and not to aim to get wasted. To respect their bodies enough not to want to poison them.

Before anyone shouts how unreasonable this is - please take a moment to consider smoking. Because i started at 12, with my friend, and smoked to 30. It is a foul, dangerous and expensive habit and I was totally hooked. It was thought to be cool and grown up even though it made your teeth go yellow and made you smell like an ashtray.

Now, smoking is not seen as so cool. And my dd (who is nearly 12) is very anti-smoking.

I do think it is possible to educate young people to drink safely and to show them how drinking can be harmful - if to excess, for a variety of reasons (and especially for girls in terms of consent issues).

EdmundCleverClogs re "For goodness sake, Italiangreyhound, I would like to meet one teen who's been put off by silly scare tactics over drinking. Yes of course it can go too far, but luckily it's very few teens who die from alcohol poisoning."

Do you think some mild scare tactics do harm?

Re "Young people will drink, better to have that 'ok that's my limit' moment early on." I could not agree more, Good idea. But for goodness sake, EdmundCleverClogs Grin there is nothing wrong with telling them what might happen! Don't we all tell our kids when they start crossing the road alone, be careful, you might be hit by a car! they might be, we can be honest with them! And although alcoholic poisoning may be rare, I think think being in an accident, being assaulted etc, when drunk, is less rare.

Good luck OP. Smile

Birdsgottafly · 11/09/2016 19:49

""She knew about the family arrangement. She got herself into this situation, so she has to sit through the BBQ, as she would if she had chosen to stay up all night and complain that day.""

She had a party to go to, she's becoming an Adult, she gets to decide if she wants to attend a family get-together.

Likewise, if she's got a valid reason for staying up all night, she then gets to decide if she gets up the next day.

You need to start to respect her and her right to a life seperate from you.

MaQueen · 11/09/2016 19:50

Gawd, you sound dour and pious. She is 17. So, guess what...? She is going to act like a 17 year old. Not like some fusty spinster having a token sip of sherry at Xmas.

I'm positively middle aged, but still occasionally manage to drink too much, and suffer the consequences because I like to kick back and have a good time

Seems to me, that you were hoping to present a perfect facade in front of your family/friends, and

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/09/2016 19:52

Op sounds a bit like my mother. I'm low contact with her because she's a nasty, controlling bitch. Be careful what you sow op.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/09/2016 19:56

"She knew about the arrangement". And you knew about the 18th birthday party. Your DD deserves as much respect as you. Family/friends gatherings and get togethers can happen a lot more frequently than 18th birthdays. You only get one chance at an 18th birthday party. It's normally a big event and rite of passage.

SharonfromEON · 11/09/2016 19:57

summary

OP - AIBU...
Majority of posters - Yes
Op - I am not

not sure the point of the post.

Discobabe · 11/09/2016 20:00

I hope she didn't do what I used to. Get drunk, throw up, feel sober, drink some moreGrin

EdmundCleverClogs · 11/09/2016 20:03

Italiangreyhound, talking sensibly about what might happen (or, in an adult conversation, how to keep safe) is normal though. 'Don't get too pissed, a girl died' is dramatic and over the top. As for 'but this, that and the other could have happened', this does not seem to be the case. Teen went to party with booze, teen got drunk, teen hungover and yet was for some reason expected to attend Hyacinth Bucket's barbecue, with manners and no vomiting. Wasn't going to happen, was it.

APlaceOnTheCouch · 11/09/2016 20:07

YABU. If you were so concerned about her ability to drink alcohol and attend the barbeque, you should have collected her from the party last night then at least you could have made her drink copious amounts of water in the hope of combating the worse of the hangover.
You are also being unreasonable to expect her to know her limits when this is the first time she's drunk alcohol in any large volume.

gingercat02 · 11/09/2016 20:08

I'm 47 and massively hungover cos I drank too much wine at a party last night. Some people never learn! Give her a break OP Wine

Kenworthington · 11/09/2016 20:11

Huh. I've been reading the whole thread thinking 'hmm I wonder if it was ds's party' OPs dd was at. Also an 18th at our house.

RestlessTraveller · 11/09/2016 20:15

I remember when I was 17 my mum coming home from a night shift on A&E in tears. A 15 year old boy had been brought in. It transpired that he had rather strict parents, there had been a party that night and he had begged them to be allowed to go. They eventually agreed but gave him a massive lecture about not touching one drop of alcohol. Of course he got blindingly drunk got home went straight to his room passed out and threw up. He choked on his own vomit and was brought in to A&E being ventilated. They switched him off just before the end of my mum's shift.

My mum told me this and then explained that is why I had been allowed to drink moderately in the house since I was 14. So it wasn't a novelty and I knew my limits.

CatNip2 · 11/09/2016 20:16

Same as most other posters. She is no different to most teenagers, having two DC age 22 and 19 I have seen more than my fair share of drunk teenagers, she will learn in time and when she gets to 40 and has teens of her own will post on here and say "dh and I rarely drink".

DD age 19 has finally learnt her limits, if she has two much and knows it, she drinks a pint of water, takes two painkillers and has a bowl of tomato and basil soup before bed, strange combination but says she wakes up feeling great.

I must try it, it took me until 45 to know that I can't drink any more than 1 bottle of wine, ever.

Mummyoflittledragon · 11/09/2016 20:18

Restless. That is so sad.

Sunshineonacloudyday · 11/09/2016 20:19

I agree with the other posters YANU to be upset. You have to remember you are telling a 17 year old not to drink to much when she has never drank before. That night you let her of the reins and alcohol was present she will drink when she is thirsty.

spidey66 · 11/09/2016 20:22

I don't have kids but have nieces and nephews a similar age....if I'd turned up at a family bbq and they were hungover, I'd tease them in a light hearted way for a couple of minutes and then forget it. It's a rite of passage, we've all been there.

perrita · 11/09/2016 20:24

I think YABU. She's 17 and I think you're under estimating how strong peer pressure can be.

bigTillyMint · 11/09/2016 20:24

Hahaha! She did what 17yo's do. You are overreacting.

Your user name is totally appropriate Grin

nooka · 11/09/2016 20:27

The OP is also missing that she too has suffered from natural consequences today. she forced her very hungover daughter to attend a very formal BBQ and is pissed that she had to put up with her being snappy. Personally I'd be really worried if my daughter got so drunk that many hours later she was still repeatedly throwing up, but perhaps that was more to do with being forced to eat the BBQ.

Would it really not have been better for everyone at the BBQ to leave the dd in bed for the morning? You can surely punish her later?

I have a 17 year old and a 16 year old and both have already got a good idea of their limits and watched enough friends getting drunk to know that the consequences can be ugly sometimes. ds is a very melancholy drunk so tends to stop quite quickly and dd has already learned that alcopops are dangerous and so prefers alcoholic drinks things that obviously taste alcoholic. These are things you have to learn through experience though. Alcohol reduces inhibitions, so very easy to have a drink or two, not realise that your thinking is impaired and have a few more and suddenly find yourself very drunk indeed. For a teenager that is likely to happen on not even that much booze as tolerance will be very low.

DoreenLethal · 11/09/2016 20:28

17 year old gets pissed and has hangover.

What a shocker. In other news...the sun will come up tomorrow morning and the birds will fly to warmer climes for the winter.

QuimReaper · 11/09/2016 20:30

When I was younger than that I had friends over for my brithday, and they brought wine.

It ended with me lying on the sofa puking into my own hair.

My mum gave me an aspirin, washed the sofa cushions and never brought it up again. I've never been so grateful for anything!

(I didn't drink for a looooong time after that...)

Marmalade85 · 11/09/2016 20:31

YABU to make her sit through the BBQ.

Italiangreyhound · 11/09/2016 20:34

Edmund I am a massive fan of how to keep safe.

I have had plenty of drunken nights out, falling down stairs, being dunked in the sea, throwing up, tripping up and tipping a large bowl of BBQ sauce over my head, getting on a stranger's motorbike at midnight.

I'm not proud of it, nor do I think you have to be blotto to have fun!

I also think adults often get pissed in safer situations than youngsters, which is why extra caution, not less caution, is needed for young people.

And once again Mumsnett feels the need to attack an poster with insulting comments rather than advice. How original.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread