My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To be irritated that MIL gives men 2-3 times more food than women?

153 replies

Ladyboluna · 10/05/2016 09:03

Last week we went to MIL's for Sunday lunch. We had gammon and I made a big thing about saying its my favourite and how hungry I was. All the men (OH, BIL, FIL) got about 6-7 slices Envy. While I and the women get 2 small slices (wouldn't cover a slice of bread). I even got a smaller portion of potatoes and veg. What really didn't help is that my FIL didn't even finish his! Sad

When I went home I had to cook myself something to eat! I'm pregnant and they always make jokes about what my appetites been like recently Wink (good-natured ones). My MIL and SIL hardly eat anything, so I wonder if its that, or an old-fashioned thing.

I know it isn't a big deal, and I have a great relationship with her, so it really isn't worth falling out about. But it happens every time I go round! Thoughts?

OP posts:
Report
Aquiver · 10/05/2016 11:57

I find that this is very much an older generation custom (and I don't mean every older person whatsoever!!!). Also, in some cultures (e.g. some Asian cultures), the expectation is that menfolk are provided with food first or larger portions, while women take a 'second sitting' and smaller portions.

Makes me cringe now and I do not follow this in my household!

Report
MrsJayy · 10/05/2016 12:03

Mum always mentions what she doesn't eat this thread just made me realise she said the other day her and step dad were out at a garden centre dad had some lunch she just had coffee though why would she even mention she didn't eat ?

Report
TheNotoriousPMT · 10/05/2016 12:07

Tinkly
Order a starter, a starter and a dessert. Much tastier than just a main, and it means you don't get stuck with nothing while others are eating.

As for the OPs MIL, there isn't much to be done without being rude/provoking a rude response. Eat heartily before you go.

Report
MovingOnUpMovingOnOut · 10/05/2016 12:08

I often have two starters just because that's what I would prefer :)

Report
Pinkheart5915 · 10/05/2016 12:08

Politely ask for seconds?

I think it is a generation thing my grandma does it

Report
WorraLiberty · 10/05/2016 12:20

And oh yes performance eaters. MIL is one of those. If she has her granddaughter she says oh you don't have time to eat when you have kids while looking at me. And I'm size 16. And she's size 10. Point taken. Thanks.

Are you sure she was making a point though? Could she have simply been talking from her own experience?

Unless she's quite tall, I wouldn't necessarily describe a size 10 woman as very very slim as you did in your second post.

I think your MIL's behaviour in serving up food is probably just a learned one, and that your are (possibly) wrongly thinking it has something to do with your weight.

Unless she gives other females the same amount as the men?

Report
Bluebolt · 10/05/2016 12:20

Have been thinking of my own plating up routine, I do give the men/ boys more. If my teenage DD ate the same as DS1 (a year apart but a foot difference in height) she would have problems. Buffet seems to create a race to the bottom of the bowl.

Report
Foodefafa · 10/05/2016 12:20

This is so interesting.

My mother is tiny, seems to exist on coffee and air and bitching and does the same thing with men/women portions. Oh and she's always cold.

If we go out to eat she gets visibly angry if anyone orders a starter or a dessert. In her mind one course is enough and anything else is sheer gluttony.

Also once dinner is over (at 6 bastarding PM) she puts the kitchen on 'lock down'. No-one is allowed in and God forbid anyone attempts to start making a snack. Then they get the snide comments and slamming of cupboard doors. She even tries to do this in MY HOUSE Shock.

I love her but her attitudes to food are fucked up.

Report
TinklyLittleLaugh · 10/05/2016 12:21

Yes having a starter or two starters is probably the way to go. I would probably feel a bit embarrassed but I think I need to just get over it. I hate the idea of someone thinking I'm dieting or have an eating disorder or something though.

I also have this little Puritan voice in my head that says, "you shouldn't have a dessert unless you ate every last scrap of your main". Definitely need to get over that one.

Report
Alisvolatpropiis · 10/05/2016 12:25

She sounds old fashioned but not unkind. At a size 10 she's slim but not very. Unless 5'11 plus

All things being equal men do tend to need more calories. Pregnant women need the extra calorie equivalent of a pice of peanut butter on toast, in that last trimester.

Report
Ladyboluna · 10/05/2016 12:27

Worra - I did say in my OP that all the women got small portions.

I've tried to lose weight before and she's encouraged me to. And she's talked about how you never have time to eat with a kid about 2838383933 times. While eating only half a sandwich and said kid is content and happy.

OP posts:
Report
Foodefafa · 10/05/2016 12:28

Oh and she does the splitting a sandwich thing with my sister. I just laugh at her when she suggested I share one with her.

She genuinely thinks that eating a normal sandwich at 12 noon will render one so full they're unable to eat dinner at 6pm.

Report
MrsCeee · 10/05/2016 12:33

My MIL does this too but then she serves herself the same Huge portions. She will happily comment on anyone's slight weight gain despite being severely obese herself. I'm not a big eater and I'm sick to death of comments about how I "don't eat" from FIL and MIL. I'm one comment away from losing from shit, to be honest.

I wouldn't take it personally though, OP. Just eat before you see them.

Report
WorraLiberty · 10/05/2016 12:37

Ahh sorry OP, I missed the all women thing.

I do think it's more about her and her old fashioned attitude than her opinion of your weight though.

It sounds as though she would have the same attitude even if she was a size 16 too.

Either way, if it's getting to you, can you ask your DH to have a quiet word?

Report
KitKatCustard · 10/05/2016 12:39

My ex MIL used to do this. I used to take a stack of emergency Mars Bars when we went to stay. It is really annoying and not always possible to ask for more if something has been divvied up completely.

Report
NewLife4Me · 10/05/2016 12:44

I give more to the men in our family except skinny ds2 because they have bigger appetites than me and can eat more.
My dh is 6ft 4 and me 4ft 10.5. there's no way I could eat the same amount. I struggle to keep up with dd who is 5ft 3. Grin

So, I suppose I do this out of habit as men do tend to eat more than omen in general.

Report
NewLife4Me · 10/05/2016 12:44

women, not omen Grin

Report
TyneTeas · 10/05/2016 12:51

There was an interesting thread about men getting served more a couple of months ago

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/2575470-Re-The-sharing-out-of-meat?pg=1&order=

Report
MiffleTheIntrovert · 10/05/2016 12:53

Tinkly I am small and sedentary due to a disability too. I also don't have an appetite (only due to meds, I was a big greedy guts before BlushGrin) but luckily DH is very very tall and does an active job. He needs well over 2500/3000 calories a day, definitely more than double what I need/eat. Whenever we go out I order a starter and a normal main but shovel half my main onto DH's (or the teenagers' Wink) plate. Could you do something like this? It works well for us. Don't worry about ordering two starters though if this works, I also do this and have been known to order a DC a child's meal and swapped them.

I have to say, having my eating habits change (albeit not deliberately so I'm not judging or performing or anything ) has made me realise how big portions are these days. I think 6 or 7 slices of gammon is a lot - your MIL should find a happy medium for everyone!

Report
EponasWildDaughter · 10/05/2016 12:59

And she's talked about how you never have time to eat with a kid about 2838383933 times.

Oh gosh this is my MIL too. A kid. One grandson. She'll tell me this even though i have 4 of my own and am not skinny. She'll tell me how fat she's getting and how her and FIL are going to the gym because they're getting soooooooooooo chubby. This woman is super skinny.

Maybe she doesn't do it to make a point, perhaps it's all to do with her own body image but i don't think so.

Report
suspiciousofgoldfish · 10/05/2016 13:17

To give an example when I go out to lunch with them my MIL and SIL will share a sandwich. 

^^ that's a divorce right there for me.

Report
Ladyboluna · 10/05/2016 15:06

Ah so glad it's not an isolated thing! Going to look at that thread.

I get you don't have as much time to snack and stuff when you've got a baby but to go on about how she doesn't eat cause it's a time thing then when she does have time she doesn't eat...

One time we went to pizza Hut and she talked about how "oh I find it hard to eat a whole pizza it's too filling the bread is bloating don't you think so?"

To me, who has already put away 3/4 of a large pizza...

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

EponasWildDaughter · 10/05/2016 15:23

My MIL (i like her, i really do, this is my only beef with her) once looked at the bread i had buttered ready for DHs sandwiches (tall, builder, not fat) and said ''Oh ..... All that animal fat ...... ''.

Yes, i said cheerfully, he likes plenty of butter, and slapped a bit more on Grin

(i'm not going to moan about her anymore because she is nice)

Report
OurBlanche · 10/05/2016 15:31

Ha! Not in our family, we are all horrendously polite and good at sharing equally.

But DHs family are different!

MIL used to serve the veg in hot bowls and handed out hot plates with slices of meat on, and the order to 'tuck in'... which we all did as she would grab her plate, the next bottle of wine or whatever and join us.

.. but she always handed BIL a piled up plate. I always wondered why, there was no obvious reason for it. Then, one day, she handed out the plates and he got a plate with only meat on it, like the rest of us. He poured gravy on it, inhaled it and held his plate op for a refill... before she had even sat down. She gave him her plate of meat, which this time he piled high with veg and tucked in, slurpily (did I mention he east like and Alsation, literally chasing the food down to the plate, even licking the gravy up?). She managed to carve some remaining bits off the already depleted joint onto his dirty plate for herself to eat.

By the time she finished that he had almost emptied the veg bowls and she got very, very little to eat. No one said anything, I wanted to but, given his PFB status, was too scared I'd start WWIII.

When she came to us I sat her next to the roasties, gave her a plate, with slices of meat on, and poured her a glass of wine, before returning to the other plates... BIL was visibly agitated, watching his mum help herself to the best of the veg - and yes, I was childish enough to give him his plate last, well, at the same time as I sat down (again closest to the roasties) Smile

My prize for that was that MIL would hide a good bottle or two of red behind my chair, putting 'other' bottles on the table. Then she would refill our glasses from the good bottles Grin

Report
Ladyboluna · 10/05/2016 15:38

Oh I'd like to say I really do like my MIL too. My only beef with her relates to food! Pun completely intended and I refuse to apologise for it.

OP posts:
Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.