And no-one has answered the question about official visitors; doctor, mortgage broker, insurance assessor, workman, district nurse?
A man from trading standards came round to view some damage to our upstairs. He saw the stair carpet and said 'I see you have a new carpet. Would you like me to take my shoes off?'.
Workmen generally bring dust sheets when they're doing work. Most other workment we've had in the house (we've had a lot in the house over the last year) ask if they should taken their shoes off.
Anyone else, who wants to keep their shoes on will be confined to the kitchen/dining room. We don't allow shoes on the living room carpet nor on the engineered oak in the family room. The family room floor has UFH so doesn't get cold at all. The whole point of the UFH is that you put your feet on it without shoes on.
You wouldn't put your feet on a chair on the bus/tube/train because someone will have to sit there, so why wipe them all over the carpet where the owner's may walk barefoot, babies crawl, and children sit?
This exactly.
A Lithuanian man recently came round to our house to buy our old car. While filling in the documentation in our dining room he asked if he could smoke. We said no. He looked surprised. He probably felt the same way some MNers do about being asked to remove shoes.
I'm standing by 'my house my rules'. It's not an unreasonable request (medical reasons aside).
If I was having a big party, I'd pay to have the carpets professionally cleaned afterwards.