Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be hurt?

132 replies

Balders74 · 01/01/2016 23:16

This time last year I split from my stbxh. We had been together for 16 years, married for 10. He was a lazy bully & I had to make a change for the sake of our 2 DC.

STBXH is good friends with my sister's husband & there has been some tension because he (BiL) has taken STBXH's side in the split, even though he knows how awful things were but I suppose bro's stick together. The breakup has not been easy & my ex is being difficult.

Every year my sister holds a New Years party & this year they invited STBXH & I. When I asked my sister why she said she thought it would be OK by the I.e. We could both attend. I was upset that she had been so inconsiderate. I knew my ex would go to the party so there was no way I could go.

So the party happened last night & sure enough STBXH was there and to make matters worse with a new woman he turned up with on Christmas Day when he picked the kids up to take them to his parents. Christmas Day!!!

There are picutres all over FB of him & her surrounded by my friends & family and it hurts. I am so hurt by my sister for doing this & I don't feel like I can talk to her any time soon.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Epilepsyhelp · 02/01/2016 00:31

I think OP is being misunderstood here. She wants to talk to her own sister, how on earth is listening to your sisters unhappiness 'getting involved'?! That's bullshit on the part of the sister.

She absolutely should have checked with you before inviting him, she/they should see him separately as much as they wish.

fidel1ne · 02/01/2016 00:31

I agree with Nicki, so I won't bother to duplicate everything she's written. Unbearably uncomfortable for you OP - you should be able to expect more consideration and basic loyalty from family.

Caprinihahahaha · 02/01/2016 00:32

I love everyone but I think it's a huge load of crap too

Grin

Seriously Balders, I'm sure your sister is nice and probably thinks she is just being fair/even handed so forgive her and try to let it go. But it does totally suck and you are entitled to feel hurt and excluded, because you were.

I'm sure it will get easier but I'd try to understand there is no intent to hurt but she will continue to handle it like this.

Cahu58 · 02/01/2016 00:32

Your sister and brother in law were in my opinion wrong to invite him and 'not take sides'. If your family can't side with you, who can. Do not listen to the posters here, they have obviously never been in your position. You are quite right to feel hurt, I'm sure his family are supporting him, yours need to support you.

Balders74 · 02/01/2016 00:34

That sounds like an ideal situation Worra. I was very close to my IL's and tbh stayed longer than I should have because I didn't want to lose them, it was their choice. I have reached out in a number of occasions but have been told they can't forgive me for not sticking with him.

They knew how bad things were but the expectation was that I would put up with it as his DM has ( and she told me that in an email).

It would make our lives so much easier if there was no bad feeling but it hasn't worked out that way.

OP posts:
VelvetSpoon · 02/01/2016 00:34

If a couple split and say to everyone that it's amicable, they'd like to stay friends with each other (and current mutual friends, family etc) then that's great, makes it easy.

But when it clearly ISN'T an amicable split, you just can't be friends with both sides. Sorry, but it doesn't work and it's fucking hurtful.

When I split with my abusive Ex, I told friends some of the shit he put me through, and even after hearing that, a few of them thought they should keep in touch with him on FB etc Hmm.

As far as his family were concerned, I didn't contact them after we split. I never expected them to contact me, I entirely understood their loyalty was to their son, whatever I thought of him.

My bf is in a situation where his family have decided (for pretty pathetic reasons) to remain in contact with his Ex...he's tried to explain to them that he feels it's disloyal, and that he actually really needs their support, but his parents just gloss over his feelings, his DBs have splinters in their arses from taking the 'we're not getting involved' tack and his SIL (who is now best buddies with the Ex, despite her slating SIL constantly behind her back) now refuses to speak to BF or have anything to do with me (I'm not the OW, I met him a year after his Ex left him!). If they didn't live several hours away, I wouldn't put it past his SIL inviting his Ex to a party. The only difference in that case would be she wouldn't invite us (unless pressured by BF's mum).

I'm afraid I do think blood is thicker than water - I see how upset my Bf is by it all (his Ex isolated him from all his friends, so the only friends they had were her friends and their DHs...who have all cut him dead since the divorce - hence why his family are so important, but they can't see beyond 'keeping the peace').

Sorry for your shitty situation OP, I do think you're entirely right to be hurt. The only consolation is that your arse of an Ex is some other woman's problem now. Not that it makes up for the lack of support from your own family though.

Mrscaindingle · 02/01/2016 00:36

I completely disagree with posters saying this is OK for your sister to do this, no one is saying they have to drop him but to invite him to a New Years party with other family members when that means the OP can't go is really hurtful.

It sounds as though the sister is being influenced by her own OH and it is a shame she didn't feel she could put her foot down. Some of my inlaws took my ex's side and that's completely I fine I expected it, but I would not expect my own family to do this.

WorraLiberty · 02/01/2016 00:36

Nicki you seem to be assuming that everything that went wrong in the marriage is the ex's fault?

Maybe it was, but maybe it wasn't and the OP's sister knows more than you/we do?

There are a million reasons why some people don't get involved in other people's break ups.

It doesn't automatically make anyone a 'shit'.

But if for example the sister thinks they were both to 'blame' and she and her DH are close to the BIL as well as the OP, it doesn't make her a bad person for wanting to invite him to a party.

WorraLiberty · 02/01/2016 00:39

It would make our lives so much easier if there was no bad feeling but it hasn't worked out that way.

Do you think there might have been bad feeling if your BIL and sister didn't invite your ex to the party?

If your BIL is that close to him then I think there might have been.

What's the point in having bad feeling on both sides of the family, because your inlaws have been horrible?

magoria · 02/01/2016 00:41

YANBU

OP's BIL has clearly from the first post taken the ex's side. Despite knowing what a shit he has and is still being.

Her sister maybe going along with him for a quiet life not caring that her sister is hurting.

That is a choice (her H which it is difficult to argue is wrong) and a side in doing so which is clearly going to hurt OP.

I don't know what the answer is OP. I am sorry you are hurting.

Balders74 · 02/01/2016 00:41

I don't want bad feelings. Just one night with my friends & family.

OP posts:
LittleBeautyBelle · 02/01/2016 00:42

Flowers, OP. How upsetting...it's like your ex who was a toad and his ng out of the blue has settled in with your family and friends within one day complete with smiling group pictures all over FB, with you looking in from the outside. I can totally see why you're feeling upset with your sister. Your sister is being very insensitive and cold hearted in my opinion.

LittleBeautyBelle · 02/01/2016 00:45

especially at a major family holiday gathering at your own sister's house where is the one place you should have felt safe and included, and supported.

thelifeofamber · 02/01/2016 00:45

i absolutely understand that I would feel hurt in that situation.

But his GF would want to spend NYE with him surely? She shouldn't be judged for that or expected not to go.

Again your sister doesn't have to get involved and pick a side.

Its a sad situation but as you have children together he will always be a part of your life anyway.

WorraLiberty · 02/01/2016 00:46

Anyway I'm off to bed.

Good luck OP. I hope the divorce isn't too long drawn out and it's over relatively easily Thanks

I do think deep down that in years to come, you might just be glad that your sister and BIL didn't treat him the way your inlaws have treated you. If only for the sake of your kids.

Night.

Mrscaindingle · 02/01/2016 00:47

I'm not quite sure why it's not OK to upset the ex Worra but it is OK to upset the OP.

Basically the BIL and sister have prioritised their friendship with the ex over their relationship with the OP, that is shit and she is entitled to feel crap about this.

ScoutandAtticus · 02/01/2016 00:50

Yanbu. This is your sister we are talking about. Wrong, wrong, wrong.

Cahu58 · 02/01/2016 00:51

Can't stand the righteous tone some posters have taken here. Does it matter who is to blame for the break up.... The OP needs support and her family and friends should be providing that regardless of who did what etc....

Nonidentifyingnc · 02/01/2016 00:51

I'm with nicki too. The OP should be able to rely on the loyalty of her sister. Sometimes you do have to pick sides and OPs sister should have picked hers! Inviting her ex to a family party is skanky behaviour. The bil has clearly chosen his friend and the sister is too weak and pathetic to display any loyalty to her own dsis.

Potatoface2 · 02/01/2016 00:53

im quite surprised that his new girlfriend wanted to spend new years eve with his ex wifes family and friends....seems very strange...she has got to be a bit odd to do that cos no sensible person would imo

NickiFury · 02/01/2016 00:55

I cannot seem to see anywhere on this thread where the OP has suggested that she wishes that her relatives drop her ex and treat him in the way that she's been treated by his family. All I can see is someone who is hurt that she couldn't go to a family party.

What a shame the ex isn't as concerned about future amicable relationships as the OP is expected to be? If he had been he would have known to bow out of this party and leave it for his ex wife to be with her family on NYE.

chinam · 02/01/2016 00:57

I like my BILs, but I love my sisters. If my sisters were to split with their partners, I would be as polite as always to the in laws, but it would be my sisters who would take priority. YANBU, op.

ZenNudist · 02/01/2016 00:58

Poor you. It's in the past now. Are you going to talk to your dsis?

Ask her not to put you in that position again and put you first.

Caprinihahahaha · 02/01/2016 01:04

It's not about the op expecting her sister to 'drop' the X. Where did that idea come from?

That's quite a leap from wanting to be able to go to a NYE family party.

The op just wanted her sister to give her priority at a significant family gathering. Of course she's upset. She's not fucking Ghandhi

gleam · 02/01/2016 01:10

YANBU Op. Flowers