Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this mother's attitude is far from typical

149 replies

nippiesweetie · 24/10/2015 14:47

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/oct/24/a-letter-to-my-10-year-old-son-who-needs-to-hear-a-few-home-truths

Her poor son. A letter that should have been written, read and discarded, I think.

OP posts:
knittingwithnettles · 24/10/2015 23:00

Thisismy such a wise post..I think it is the moment we realise we are superhuman grownups.

YouTheCat · 24/10/2015 23:01

In all my years as a parent, I have never once said 'after all I've done for you'.

It never occurred to me that my kids should be grateful that they were born and that there was stuff I couldn't do because I chose to have them.

This silly woman has made her choices and if she is regretting them now that is her problem and not the fault of her 10 year old.

Give it another 10 years and her child will be NC and she'll be wondering why he is so awful to her. Hmm

squoosh · 24/10/2015 23:04

I read this letter this morning and just felt massive sympathy for her poor ten year old.

She sounds like a high maintenance, me me me, pain in the absolute arse.

MiscellaneousAssortment · 24/10/2015 23:13

The reality is for me, that getting pregnant and carrying DS to term, plus breast feeding for 10 moths, kick started an underlying genetic condition that has left me severely disabled. My marriage, livelihood and whole life collapsed, my body is not only falling apart in multiple devastating ways, but it's transformed my looks and tbh, I look fuck ugly and gross.

Bear with me, there is a point in here! ...

Until tonight and this article, I can hand on heart say it had never occurred to me to 'blame' DS for any of this happening... Yet can you imagine this letter written about my experiences? 'DS I bf you even though it meant my body deteriorated to the point of needing carers. I did it for you so repay me now by being abjectly grateful 24/7"

That's one of the reasons this letter annoys me.

It's so 'mummy martyr' competition, which quite frankly I win hands down, and it's a point of pride that my son knows little about my struggle. I can see its damaging to hold a child responsible for the events that got us to now. It's nothing to do with him.

And ooh, what about the time when DS wet my bed mid potty training, and I injured myself (badly) trying to clean it up in the middle of the night. Can you imagine how awful it would be to ever wrote some drivel about resenting DS for this? In the same way the author has whined on about the potty training awfulness of her DS who she implies resisted being potty trained and was responsible for doing that to her 'I spent years washing trousers you decided to pee on regardless' grrrr.

Makes my hackles rise!

At the other extreme, tbh, the only reason I'm alive is my little boy. He's both a miracle and also a responsibility. He needs me, and he needs me to be his mummy, his rock and foundation. So I'm here. But saying this, I'm keenly aware how damaging it would be if DS ever knew this -how awful to put that responsibility on s child's shoulders, that he's the reason I exist. (Shudder. I feel guilty for even thinking this let alone communicating it!)

So both ways are terribly terribly damaging, to blackmail a child by holding them to a debt accrued without their knowledge or consent, or, to make a child responsible for an adults existence and happiness. There's a theme, and that is the separation of children from parents lives/ identities/ decisions/ impact.

Here's my letter to DS:

Dear boy,
I love you so much, I wake up every day so happy that I have you in my life*. We make a great team, and you make me laugh even when the bottom burp joke has REALLY worn itself thin. I expect and appreciate when you behave kindly and politely to me, because that's how I treat you. It's the way we show each other that we love and care about family. I respect you, care about your feelings and understand that there are good days and bad days for everyone, and I love it when you show me the same thoughtfulness back. It makes me proud to be your Mum.

Sometimes I know you take out your feelings on me, and in a way, that's ok as I'm your mum and you should feel safe enough to do that when the rest of the world is unfair and frustrating. All I ask is that you let me help you get to the bottom of it, and join in with me in helping you learn other ways of dealing with it.

I am sorry I can't give you a 'normal' life like your friends have, but I hope you have enough love and support and protection that you can cope with being different. And I hope you know that I would do anything to help you grow and become the amazing grown up you'll be (even if that 'anything' means telling you off from time to time, or letting you discover what happens when you make a wrong choice!).

And above all, I hope you know that whatever happens, I am your mummy, and you are my little boy, no matter how tall you grow, and you should never ever take on responsibility for grown up things, that's my job. And I love that it's my job, even when it's tricky,

I love you my dear darling funny silly sausage. And that's the only 'home truth' you'll ever hear.

Mummy xxx
(And yes I know you want to call me Mum, but let me have Mummy a wee bit longer - at home, not in front of your school mates!)

*I'd say 'blessed' at this point apart from that term makes me vom!

Error404usernamenotfound · 24/10/2015 23:18

'I didn't mind, because...'

Clearly you did, a little, or you wouldn't have written a letter to be published in a national newspaper.

I know exactly how much my mother resented me (in secret, as she thought), and I hope my dd and any younger sibling(s) will never know anything of my pain and sacrifice, which every parent experiences, as the shame and self-hatred it engenders is not what any loving parent would knowingly inflict on their child.

squoosh · 24/10/2015 23:20

Oh what a beautiful letter Miscellaneous. Brought an actual tear to my stony eye. It sounds like you and your son make a fab team.

Extra kudos for leaving out the 'blessed' Grin

Error404usernamenotfound · 24/10/2015 23:26

MiscellaneousAssortment, your letter is amazing.

Octopus37 · 25/10/2015 06:59

I hope I'm not the only Mum having read this thread who feels massive guilt because at first I did really identify with the Mother. However, it is true that I would never blame my labour on my 8 year old (although he does know about it), I think that it is the being taken for granted and thoughtlessness that we are supposed to just take on the chin that is the hardest. I know I shouldn't find this hard, because your child needs to feel safe with you and it is a back handed compliment blah blah blah, but it so hard. Is is ok to admit that?

Mehitabel6 · 25/10/2015 07:04

I think it OK to write it just to vent on a bad day- as long as you tear it up afterwards, never let you child see it and don't publish it for others to read!
We all have bad days when we think 'poor me'. However she does seem, as someone had already said, high maintenance.

IfOnlyIKnewThen · 25/10/2015 09:04

I didn't think the letter was that bad. Not something I would write myself (my dds naughty behaviour is annoying purely for the incident itself, not because of the sacrifices I have made to be a mum - rarely think of those), but nothing that made me think the poster was a terrible person or mother.

Don't really see much difference between people on here moaning about their children and the article. So she never listed all the great stuff about being a parent - why would she, she was having a bog standard moan. There was thread on here which was hilarious about teenagers basically not pulling their weight around the house. Very few posters qualified their rants with the good points about their dc - and why should they need to.

I agree with all the other posters that children (especially young ones) don't usually care or understand the sacrifices we make as parents which is why I doubt the poster has any intention of showing the letter to her son as it would be pointless.

Some have said that they feel this mum was trying to make her son feel guilty...really? Gosh me and my siblings must have been awful as if my mum ranted at us like this or worse showed us a letter she penned we would have been rolling our eyes and trying to suppress our giggles, we certainly wouldn't have cried or felt a jot of guilt.

TheSconeOfStone · 25/10/2015 09:13

bigmouthstrikesagain we're going through the same with my DD who is just 8. ASD screening started this week. I never expected to have a child who can't behave at school and who has dropped out of numerous activities (all that she asked to do) because of her high levels of anxiety turning into rage. She always says sorry and lies awake worrying that she won't be able to hold it together the next day. I signed up to be a parent and it's my job to support her. She is a joy to have in our lives. It's bloody hard though.

My children didn't make me get pregnant. It's not their fault they inherited there father's big head and I've got the stitches to prove it. I chose to breastfeed. I chose to stay in a part time job I don't like instead of applying for better, full time jobs. If parents don't want to take their children to activities they don't have to. My parents didn't, I wish they had but I've done lots of things as an adult and it's been more rewarding because it was my choice I think.

Sgoinneal · 25/10/2015 09:16

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Lweji · 25/10/2015 09:24

It reads like she thinks she's entitled to a nicely behaved child who doesn't answer back because of all the sacrifices to have and raise a child that she chose to have and raise.
It makes me wonder how much respect and consideration she actually gives her child. There is no mention of that (that I recall).

OurBlanche · 25/10/2015 09:33

As others have said, it isn't even new: There's No Charge

eloise11 · 26/10/2015 20:33

MiscellaneousAssortment - what a fabulous letter. Thank you.

OurBlanche - just listened to this. Sure, it's cheesey but it says it all. No charge. Thanks for the link!

MiscellaneousAssortment · 26/10/2015 21:02

Awww, thank you Blush

strangechild · 26/10/2015 21:21

Wow, the thought police are out in force on this thread tonight. Let the woman have a moan, fgs. The letter is anonymous. When did we start thinking mothers had to experience the shitty bits of parenthood and lap it up uncomplainingly?

Lweji · 26/10/2015 21:24

I think you'll find the thought police has left the thread a while ago. Unless you mean you in relation to everyone else's thoughts.

Mehitabel6 · 26/10/2015 22:17

I don't mind her having a moan- it is having it published in the paper that bothers me and the fact that she, presumably, can't see what is wrong with it.

Mehitabel6 · 26/10/2015 22:18

That is- wrong with the letter.

NotEnoughTime · 26/10/2015 22:32

bigmouthstrikesagain

your post has made me cry. You have nailed that completely are you in fact a ten year old boy? Grin

DotForShort · 26/10/2015 23:07

Appalling letter. Her repetition of "I didn't mind doing XYZ because it was best for you" sounds utterly hollow and false. She clearly does mind intensely and evidently resents her child for every single choice that she made. Poor kid. Nor do I believe that she is expressing things she would never say to her son. She sounds exactly like the kind of martyr who can't keep from saying this sort of thing all the time. "I've done so much for you, I gave up everything for you, and I ask for nothing in return blah blah blah."

As someone mentioned above, it is quite telling that all her vitriol is directed at one child. I wonder about the family dynamics. Is the elder child her golden boy who can do no wrong, while the 10-year-old is blamed for everything from her post-childbearing body to her career and income? I wouldn't be a bit surprised.

And the "I love you" at the end sounds more like a threat than an expression of deep emotional connection. Ugh.

PatrickPolarBear · 27/10/2015 00:37

Ugh. That letter is full of passive aggressive martyrdom. Reminds me of my mother. Her bubbling resentment at all she had sacrificed and had to 'put up with' for us was a constant theme of my childhood.

This woman will learn eventually that martyrdom and self pity only drives your children away in the long run.

pigsDOfly · 27/10/2015 01:08

Christ one day about in about 20 years time some poor woman is going to be posting on MN about her awful martyr of a MIL and how she and her DH can never do the right thing, and how if they try to break away from her she develops all sorts of illnesses, or something similar.

Look how much I've done for you and how much you made me sacrifice, and this is the way you repay me line after line all through that horrible self absorbed claptrap.

Does she really think that is the sort of guilt a parent is entitled to put on the shoulders of her child.

She gave him a natural birth, oh and sacrificed her body for him so she can no longer wear a bikini ffs. Well obviously that's his fault.

Poor little sod.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread