Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send MIL a passive aggressive text

248 replies

Ruperta · 31/12/2014 09:47

Ok so bit of a back story and posted a few times previously. PILS are very involved in SIL family, essentially amazing GPs, provide childcare 2 days a week, often have them over night and take their son swimming every Saturday. They live 30 mins drive away which obviously is a reason for them being closer but there is a loooooonnnggg history of obvious favouritism to SIL family and children. SIL is lovely by the way and fair play I would gratefully take all help offered in the same way as she does.

In comparison we live further away (london) 2hrs on train, 4 hrs drive and we have a two children (1&3), the youngest the same age as SIL youngest. There has been lots of little episodes of things that have gradually grated me & my DH re:favouritism and lack of effort from MIL, many many many which are too petty to go into but last episode left a bit of a frosty atmosphere.

E.g they visited us twice last year, the second time we asked as a favour as we needed someone to look after children as I was a bridesmaid at the wedding. It was the first time me and DH had been out and DS2 was 10 months. They came down and basically used our house as a base, went out to meet old friends, arranged for family to come round on the day we were out at the wedding - I put my foot down and said that they agreed to look after children and they weren't to have friends round (they didn't ask us by the way, we found out the day before that 4 additional adults were coming round). Mil went sulky and didn't speak to me in my own house all weekend. So obviously things are quite frosty anyway. I was just annoyed as I thought they may want to spend a bit if time with GC.

Anyhoo so Xmas comes along, it was our 'turn' to spend Xmas with them (which I was slightly dreading) but when we asked them what their plans were they said 'we are going to SILs, what are you doing?' Absolutely no thought of spending time with us. Eventually a couple of weeks later SIL invited us but by then I arranged for my family to come round and there wouldn't 't have been any room at SILs for us anyway and we all seemed quite happy with plan.

Anyway (I hope your still with me) on Xmas day we facetime'd SIL (PILL had forgotten their ipad) and chatted to everyone but MIL didn't come to screen and say hello, benefit of the doubt she was probably busy I know. Then we tried face timing again over the next few days, they never rang us back. Eventually facetime'd again on Sunday but MIL had been out the night before and was unable to speak to us. So we haven't even spoken to her over Xmas.

I am so tempted to send her a passive aggressive text with pictures of the children over Xmas saying 'hope she had a lovely Xmas, we had a great time, it's a shame we weren't able to catch up properly over the Xmas period but thank you so much for the toys the children loved them. Hope you have a great new year'.

I just really want to highlight it to her and make it clear it's not really acceptable. They are such wonderful GPs to SILS children (they are having them overnight tonight) but she can't even be arsed to say merry Xmas to my kids. Relations are quite strained anyway, maybe I'll regret it but I'm really at the stage of thinking it is her loss if she can't be bothered to put the effort in.

FIL is lovely by the way but (as with the whole of the ILs family) he does exactly what she demands to get the easy life - I think that is why she doesn't get on so well with us as we don't do this and my DH (her son) apparently never has.

Sorry very long.

OP posts:
Ruperta · 31/12/2014 10:36

Wowzers everyone, glad to start a debate, esp on AIBU :-) I won't be sending the text, got to go out now

OP posts:
limitedperiodonly · 31/12/2014 10:37

My MIL lives three hours away. When she comes to us in London she treats the place like a base and like a cat, returns only at dinner time.

I might send her a passive-aggressive scented notelet.

DreamingDiva13 · 31/12/2014 10:38

Clam I wouldn't feel happy going out and leaving my children with someone if they had other people coming round. My circumstances are a bit different in that my eldest has ASD and whilst she would appear to 'cope' okay with it in front of whomever was babysitting and their friends it would be me left to deal with the after effects of anxiety that would leave.
Not all children are happy and confident to be left with others, even more so when you put people they don't know into the mix.

clam · 31/12/2014 10:38

Ok, so even if we concede that you're entitled to 'put your foot down' about your ILS and tell them you think their behaviour is unacceptable, can you seriously be wondering why they're not mad keen to spend time with you?

OutsSelf · 31/12/2014 10:38

OP, that's not passive aggressive. Passive aggressive would be saying 'it's a shame you couldn't find time to talk to us over Christmas, we understand you were very busy with everyone else.' That said, your text is 100% more stylish and I'd send that.

Mandatorymongoose · 31/12/2014 10:39

Did you have a thread about the babysitting at the time OP? It sounds familiar.

It sounds like you really dislike your Mil and would probably take a negative interpretation of anything she did. Why not just talk to her and explain you feel sad that your children don't have the same relationship with them as their cousins and see what you can do to improve it?

clam · 31/12/2014 10:39

diva I don't recall the OP saying that either of her dcs had additional needs.

MinnieM1 · 31/12/2014 10:41

Well I'm glad my family aren't like some of you, just because you're family you all think it's ok to have strangers in and out of other peoples houses at any point?! Just incredibly rude!

clam · 31/12/2014 10:41

The OP seems determined tone professionally offended by her mil, so I don't see a way forward really.

MiddleAgedandConfused · 31/12/2014 10:41

I think it is rude to invite people round to somebody else's house without asking, but understand that others might not.

But YABU if you think that the PILs should just spend all their time gazing in admiration at their GCs when they visit. They probably arranged to go out and meet friends as a way to give you all some space - it can be very intense staying with family if you do not get on very well.
I would let it go. Possibly apologise for the way you spoke to them over the 4 family members visiting, and explain you were nervous about leaving the kids with a group of people they did not know as it was the first time they had been left with anyone else.
I would try and build some bridges as this is the kind of thing that can fester and cause real damage. Everybody loses if you fall out with them properly.

MrsDeVere · 31/12/2014 10:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DreamingDiva13 · 31/12/2014 10:42

But it isn't just children with additional needs who may find strangers coming over when they are being babysat by family they don't know that well upsetting (the child hadn't seen gps in 6 months). Every child is different and just because one persons child would find it fun and exciting doesn't mean everyone's would and each parent has the right to make that call for their own child.

Velocirapture · 31/12/2014 10:42

I think you were rude saying she couldn't invite people to your house when you were at the wedding. If it was a teenager, I could see your point, but a grandmother, no.

gamerchick · 31/12/2014 10:44

But they weren't friends coming over.. they were other family members? Are family members banned if you're not there to supervise? I wouldn't have any issue with my mother inviting other family members here for a catch up.

NYCHIC · 31/12/2014 10:44

I think you need to accept your relationship with your MIL is always going to be different from your SIL's. She is not going to behave in the way you'd like her to so you really need to accept this before your relationship deteriorates any further. Passive aggressive texts are just a way of trying to control someone else's behaviour and is never a good thing imo. Why don't you just sit down and have an adult conversation with her and tell her how you feel - see what she says?

I also agree that you were rude when they came to babysit and I suspect they wouldn't be in a hurry to do it again.

YABU

Only1scoop · 31/12/2014 10:44

Oh for goodness sake....whether the grandparents were rude or not to invite friends over....I'm sure Op wasn't overly concerned that they were a threat to her dc Confused

Ffs

Pagwatch · 31/12/2014 10:45

I have a child with ASD and I would leave him with my mother and would have no problem leaving him if she invited friends or family around. He wouldn't care in the slightest.
If the ops child had specific issues that were in any way relevant I'm sure she would have said

paperlace · 31/12/2014 10:48

I'd like to know exactly 'how you put your foot down' about their guests OP.

There is a very big difference between ' oh gosh would you mind if I said no to the guests as dc isn't great with big crowds and is so looking forward to having you to himself' and 'No way are you having people round - you have come to focus on dc and look after him not see other family' '.

If it was closer to the latter I think you burnt your bridges.

I do understand your disappointment and jealousy with PIL but you have to own that and accept life isn't always fair - and that it's very probably not done with any malice.

TattyDevine · 31/12/2014 10:49

OP, YABU. You were rude to her when she did you a massive favour holding the fort whilst you went to a wedding. And your attitude does reek of something dictatorial "I just want to make it clear to her its not really acceptable". Seriously? She's not a member of staff you know!

Wallaby - Facetime is free, so a great way to talk to relatives in Australia for instance (where mine are) and whilst I don't feel the need to "see" them on screen and for them to see me, its a great thing for my 5 and 7 year old to have a visual of the grandparents they haven't seen for over a year now. Also lovely for the grandparents to get an idea of how much they have grown and developed, which is much easier to see than to hear.

DreamingDiva13 · 31/12/2014 10:50

Not necessarily pagwatch. I left my dd's with one of the in-laws once. They knew she found strangers upsetting but invited two of their friends around when I was out.

Firstly it never occurred to me that they would invite people into my home without having the courtesy to check it was okay. Secondly I would have thought as it was an evening they babysat they would invite them in whilst the children were still up-meaning complete strangers to me where left alone downstairs in my house whilst family member was upstairs sorting out the children for bed. It was actually my Dp who was more angry about that.

MrsDeVere · 31/12/2014 10:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Snappynewyear · 31/12/2014 10:50

The PILS didn't invite for friends round, they invited family to the house! Maybe not the OPs family but not a bunch of strangers, so therefore the childrens extended family too!

OP was incredibly rude. I'm sure the PILS didn't spend all their time visiting friends from your home base and must have spent time with you. Especially after travelling 4 hours to do YOU a favour!

No wonder they prefer the SIL

DreamingDiva13 · 31/12/2014 10:51

*wouldnt invite them whilst the children were still up

DreamingDiva13 · 31/12/2014 10:52

Family or not it is strangers to the child if they have barely met them.

DurhamDurham · 31/12/2014 10:53

Those moaning about how rude it would be for a babysitter to invite friends over.....this isn't just any any babysitter it's the Grandparents probably wanting to show their grandchildren off to family members while they are there. Not some 16 year old they were paying to babysit.

And you can't say you were dreading Christmas with your inlaws and then moan when they make other plans.