OP it is most certainly not bridezilla-y
This We didn't get our official photos back until about a month after the wedding. I put a few on fb, but I expect most people had lost interest by that point. Is a perfect illustration of one of the points. By the time the bride herself had the opportunity to share her photos of her own wedding, people had lost interest because they'd already seen the previous FB ones.
and this BTW, some of the guest photos are my favourites. I set up a Dropbox and asked people to drop their photos their so I could have them too and some of them are brilliant - that's absolutely fine, and missing the point entirely. Other guest's photos being shared with you privately is absolutely fine, and of course you want to see their point of view of your wedding. That's not what OP has an issue with at all
and KingRollo if you think OP is precious, I suggest you read MrsMoon's comment above yours: there were fb photos up before I even walked into the church. FB saw me before my DH did
Finally, I do love a good snoop through other people's wedding photos on FB as much as the next person. But when it's someone I don't even know, it does make me feel uncomfortable (doesn't stop me though!). The thought of people I don't know, or maybe people I do know but don't like, seeing pics of my own wedding day, in an anonymous fashion, poring over pics of my own private event is just nasty
Stand your ground OP, you're NOT being unreasonable. And any of your guests who give you an 'inward eye roll' at your request can just sod off into a corner where they can amuse themselves staring at photos of other stranger's weddings, while you get on with enjoying the actual day in the real world.