Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this man was horrid

145 replies

dunkedbiscuits · 25/08/2013 13:25

Went to buy DS some wellies so pulled into a car parking space. It's a tight car park and so when I opened my car door it rested on next doors car. I did NOT bash it or open my door hard or anything. Anyway when I got out and turned around this small fat man with a beard (definitely NOT Santa) said 'you'll pay for any damage you've done to my car'. I shut my car door and looked at his car there were no marks, scratches or even dirt transferred to his car. I replied 'but I haven't scratched your car' and then tried to get DS out of my car.
He then said 'that's only because I was here otherwise you would have damaged it.' I was a bit opened mouthed at this and just repeated that I hadn't done anything to his car. He just seemed to be looking for a fight. I really wanted to say that 1. I hadn't damaged his precious car (that had other large dents in),2. That he was stood behind me and I didn't know he was there when I got out. And 3. How the hell was I meant to know it was his car as he stood quite far away from it.
I ignored him after that but he was really aggressive and I expected to come back to find my car damaged.
He made me feel rubbish though, hate confrontation and only think of good things to say afterwards. Did mention it to the shop though in case he was worried to anyone else.
So if that man or his wife is reading this I want to say that I hope you have a lovely day and hope that the bug that is firmly wedged up your arse eventually falls out.

OP posts:
FranSanDisco · 26/08/2013 10:58

ShellyBoob, those winter boots you are hypothetically investing in? How would you react if somebody accidently stepped on them while you were wearing them. Would you react like the man in this post?

KellyHopter · 26/08/2013 11:00

Dunkedbiscuits - glad to hear your mum is home Smile

internationallove985 · 26/08/2013 11:08

I don't think you're being unreasonable at all. As you say your car door wasn't even touching his car.

Isn't he brave (not) challenging a women on her own with a young child, make me wonder would he have challenged a fellow man in this way, err me thinks not.
Don't let it spoil your day though. xx

NotjustaMummy · 26/08/2013 11:45

Yesterday I saw a man and his teenage son leaving their estate car in the last parent and child space. I had 5 kids with me, aged 3, 22 months and 3 of 3 months. I really needed the space. I had to go park on the roof and although I parked as carefully as possible, someone was next to me when I returned. My door certainly touched theirs as I loaded the children, despite being as careful as possible. It's a public car park. Stuff happens.

JollyHappyGiant · 26/08/2013 11:53

I was at work last Monday and accidentally touched someone's wing mirror with my shoulder when I was getting out of my car. I was very upset that I'd done this, despite the fact that there was clearly no mark.

Obviously some people believe it is acceptable to lean on or touch another car. Some people don't. The issues presumably only occur when these two factions clash.

VerySmallSqueak · 26/08/2013 11:58

international if he did,it'd not be long before he'd come a cropper that's for sure.
It is,imo,very much to do with the fact she was a woman alone with her child.

Which makes him a particularly lovely specimen.

BlingBang · 26/08/2013 11:58

Thanks JollyGiant - you actually made me burst out laughing there - tis good to laugh!

JenaiMorris · 26/08/2013 12:13

There's no need to rest a car door against another car - I have dozens of little scuffs on mine from people doing this (and from manoeuvring with their eyes apparently closed). I make a point of parking as far away from other vehicles as I can to avoid the careless, selfish fuckwits but sometimes they seem to seek me out.

This chap wasn't at all polite but possibly he's at the end of his tether - minor, almost invisible scuffs incrementally damage the paintwork. This isn't purely cosmetic, either.

YW both BU.

GangstersLoveToDance · 26/08/2013 12:22

Some people are ridiculous about their cars.

I once bumped my handbag against someone's wingmirror in passing, in Tesco. It was a 'soft' bag - no keys or clinky bits that could have scratched iyswim - it literally barely just touched the wing, a small thump on the way past.

I thought nothing of it and carried on...about 30 seconds later I heared 'Oi, oi!' behind me - cue some woman running up behind me looking furious. She gave me a mouthful about daring to touch her car, that I should be more careful - she wanted me to come back to the car while she examined it for 'damage' and possibly exchange details if there was.

After politely declining to indulge her ridiculousness more than once, she was told to not so politely fuck off.

Ghanagirl · 26/08/2013 13:49

Chopchopbusybusy
Not boasting, only mention this as a rebuttal but we have two lovely cars won't mention make as might out myself.
I'm just saying I still wouldn't go crazy if someone touched or breathed on them, as they are not children just lumps of metal that take us from A to B

NomDeOrdinateur · 26/08/2013 15:00

I think you've been getting an unnecessarily hard time from some posters AND the man handled the situation very badly, OP, but you are nonetheless BU in my opinion.

I would be 100% on your side if you had parked centrally within a bay of adequate size, but returned to a space to find yourself tightly boxed in because of somebody else's bad parking. I would also be sympathetic if you were taking appropriate care when opening the doors, but a gust of wind/loss of balance caused you to knock the other car accidentally.

However, it is never OK to park in a space which is too small for your to get out of without deliberately making contact between your door and somebody else's. When parking next to somebody else, you should always hold onto a door while it is open and (if necessary due to the tightness of the space) shield the edge with your hand to prevent metal-to-metal contact. As others have mentioned, your car bouncing up and down on its suspension could have caused the door to rub and cause scratches, and it would also have been easy to brush against the door or slip so that it was no longer resting but pushing against the other car.

The above is the case regardless of the condition of the other car, or any personal problems you have at the time (genuinely sorry to hear about them, btw Sad, and glad to hear that your DM is on the mend). Only exception I can think of is if a medical emergency occurs while you are parking, and you need to exit the car very quickly for personal safety.

On the subject of pre-dented cars: my DH and I bought our first car (an old but very neatly kept Fiesta) a couple of years ago. We weren't precious about it, but were pleased that it had no deep scratches or obvious dents, and took care to park it out of harm's way. We never found/saw any evidence of anybody leaning their doors against ours when it was pristine. However, DH once (somehow) dinged the front passenger door quite badly against a pillar whilst parking at the local supermarket, so we found a more appropriate space. We returned to the car approx half an hour later, to find a man leaning his wide-open door against the dented panel and he looked absolutely bemused when we asked him to stop it! Over the following month, that panel picked up three more light dings while we were shopping (and always taking care to park well), so we got fed up with it and paid to have the lot taken out. The difference was immediate: the carpark dings stopped happening as quickly as they had started, and we have never since found anybody leaning their door against ours Hmm.

ShellyBoobs · 26/08/2013 17:17

As you say your car door wasn't even touching his car.

RTFT.

ShellyBoobs · 26/08/2013 17:20

FranSanDisco - WTF has that got to do with my explaining that there's difference between financial investments and capital investments?

And yes, if someone stood on my foot I'd probably tell them to be more careful.

I suppose you'd apologise for having a fucking foot.

VerySmallSqueak · 26/08/2013 19:35

dunked are you a blue badge holder?

I just wondered if you were in a 'disabled parking bay',in which case I would think perhaps there isn't sufficient width in these particular bays which may be worth drawing to the shop's attention.

If you haven't got a blue badge,I wonder if you should perhaps apply to hopefully make things a bit easier for you in the future.

LondonMan · 26/08/2013 20:30

All the people getting upset at someone else's door touching their car remind me of the people who get in a fight if someone spills their beer.

I would only get at most mildly irritated by spilled beer, say if my clothes got wet. A spilled beer is at no risk of doing damage that will cost somewhere between £100 and £500 to rectify.

schmee · 26/08/2013 20:46

Whether the OP was right or wrong in the way she parked, she felt intimidated by the man and it sounds like it was his intention to intimidate (from what she says).

I'd say it's pretty "horrid" to intimidate someone. Increasingly I am finding that people think it's OK to be aggressive or intimidating.

The correct and constructive behaviour from the man would have been to say "can I hold the door for you while you get out as it looks a little bit close to my car" or "I see you've parked a bit close, do you want me to see you in again so you've got room to get out". Problem solved, and no-one upset or harmed.

But why do that when you have the satisfaction of making another human being upset or frightened, and get a lovely little rage-high for yourself into the bargain?

FranSanDisco · 26/08/2013 21:11

ShellyBoobs, you are unhinged!! Do you have to swear so much? So much anger isn't good for your health Grin.

ShellyBoobs · 26/08/2013 21:24

ShellyBoobs, you are unhinged!!

Ok, Fran, well I'm very calm to be honest but fair enough if that's what you think...

To be fair I'm not the one using the manic '!!!', though, am I...

twistedtoffee · 26/08/2013 22:31

OP YANBU. No idea why you are getting such a hard time on this thread, you certainly don't deserve it.

VerySmallSqueak · 27/08/2013 19:09

Just been discussing this one with DH and as I suspected, his response would have been one the man wouldn't want.
He also mentioned that if he heard a man treating a lone woman and her child like this in a carpark, he would have a little word.

Perhaps one day this man will indeed meet his match.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page