I'm going to quote you a couple of time here Cornish -
"Im sure he loves the attention, and he does seem to stir things up when I get settled and happy. It's as if he has a self-destruct button that he likes to press when Im happy. Maybe he just finds life boring and likes the drama? He tried to drag me into a card shop to buy her a birthday card once! He is certainly a huge flirt. Maybe Im just not enough for him?"
" I'm reluctant to throw away the relationship over this as apart from this it's good."
Now, to me, these don't match. Because your relationship cannot be good if he presses the self-destruct button every time you are happy. And that's without mentioning that he pisses your finances into the pub's till, and does so FIVE nights a week. Even in my twenties and at the centre of the social whirl I enjoyed for some of those years (ah, the eighties!
) I would only very rarely be out that often. But by the sound of it, this is pretty much every week. When you can't afford it.
As for his little affair-by-text - no, I would not be happy with it at all. I would view it as one of these three possibilities -
- They are having an affair
- They are on the cusp of having an affair
- He is being taken for a ride by a young woman who finds it amusing how easy it is to have an old man drooling over her.
The first is a dealbreaker for me. The second would have me kicking him out until he came to his senses and offered up a grovelling apology (as opposed to saying "its normal and Im just a jealous cow"). The third would have me lose respect for him, and the marriage is probably doomed from then on anyway.
Cornish, he convinced you to come back to him on the grounds that you were being unreasonable. YOU WERE NOT BEING UNREASONABLE. He got you back on false pretenses. He's not a keeper.